WrassleGAF is filled with a bunch of wrestling hipsters if you ask me. They only praise jobbers, like the current Otunga and Ziggler, and then hate them when they get too mainstream. See Miz, Del Rio, Punk, Sheamus, and now Jericho.
People don't like the way those guys have been booked, it's nothing to do with getting too mainstream. The Miz has been in a slump creatively since last Mania, Del Rio was booked awkwardly, had his push stalled numerous times and was never allowed to deviate from his promo formula, Punk's popularity reached such levels that he had to be turned into a prototypical WWE face, Sheamus has ZERO character as a face and Jericho, hell, I don't know why anyone would dislike what the guy's currently doing.
People like Otunga at the moment because he's got a good character, but you take that away and he's nothing, while people like Ziggler because he's great in the ring and sells like a champ, but all it will take is a few bouts of Shitty WWE Booking to knock him down a few notches.