Most of the management changes posted here seem fair. I hope that more vengers agree to relinquish their commander status. I rarely ever place top 5, but am almost always #8-14 in or group during events (PVE and PVP). Would be a bit of a bummer to be kicked because there are only 5 non-commanders in GAF-vengers. If I was always #17-20, then I would obviously understand.
I also think that we should wait some time before shuffling more than is required to get those top 100 placements. Some people join the game, play like a fiend for 4-6 weeks and burn out. Doesn't seem fair to boot someone who has been steady for months for a moderate temporary improvement if we are already getting covers.
For PVE comparison, I would suggest this:
If you can't manage to get say 75% of the alliance average during a 9 day event, than you are not pulling your weight. Obviously 10 of us are going to be in the bottom 10 for any given event. That is not avoidable, even if everyone is doing pretty well. However, you shouldn't be so far down that you are cancelling out the efforts of our power players. In the last event, I think we ended up around 720k total. That means, based on an average of 36k, you would have had to be at 27k to hit that average. When I went to bed with an hour left in the Sentry event, we still had a 2-3 people in the 15-20k range. That really hurts any advantage that our top players pulling 50k+ points get us.
I also think that we should wait some time before shuffling more than is required to get those top 100 placements. Some people join the game, play like a fiend for 4-6 weeks and burn out. Doesn't seem fair to boot someone who has been steady for months for a moderate temporary improvement if we are already getting covers.
For PVE comparison, I would suggest this:
If you can't manage to get say 75% of the alliance average during a 9 day event, than you are not pulling your weight. Obviously 10 of us are going to be in the bottom 10 for any given event. That is not avoidable, even if everyone is doing pretty well. However, you shouldn't be so far down that you are cancelling out the efforts of our power players. In the last event, I think we ended up around 720k total. That means, based on an average of 36k, you would have had to be at 27k to hit that average. When I went to bed with an hour left in the Sentry event, we still had a 2-3 people in the 15-20k range. That really hurts any advantage that our top players pulling 50k+ points get us.