• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

May 7th | UK General Election 2015 OT - Please go vote!

Status
Not open for further replies.

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
What? I always thought you were German. Not that being a British expat instead is a bad thing ;)

c7NJRa2h.jpg
 

iceatcs

Junior Member
Hopefully it won't cut disability benefits too much. I wish they should look on people who claim benefit just because low earn or weak disability or illness like despression
 

iMax

Member
Disabled people aren't important to you?

What is happening? Are you reading my posts in full or just pouncing on individual words?

I don't subscribe to the criticism the Conservative Party receives for its approach to a reformed NHS and I don't agree with certain peoples' cross-examination of it.

To say that—simply because I have a different view to yourself—I must, therefore, hate disabled people, is frankly symbolic of the short-sighted vitriol I've come to expect from some people.
 

MrChom

Member
I genuinely feel the UK is turning into a far right country. The way we treat immigrants, and the vulnerable is absolutely disgusting. We are being taught it is okay to treat these people like sub human.

Yup.

It's disgusting. No one seems to put a stop to it for reasons I have yet to be able to fathom.

If Scotland goes then I can imagine cities like Birmingham/Manchester/Liverpool/Newcastle wanting greater autonomy in time because they're becoming steadily more divorced from the government too.
 

Tak3n

Banned
whatever your opinion, the conservatives have just had their best election result since 1863!

like them or loathe them, that there is a mandate to govern
 

BigDes

Member
How is that sociopathic? Come on.

Implication of that post, that other posters have already commented on is that disabled people are irrelevant to him.

I am sure they're not, hence the fact that I am putting it down to a poorly written post than anything else.
 
UKIP is now the third most voted for party now in the country. That's unexpected!

The decline of the libs in terms of votes and seats over the last 5 years happening in one fell swoop is a fascinating thing to witness.
 

RangerX

Banned
As an Irishman looking in one thing I have noticed is that the UK's electoral system is broken. When the greens and ukip get 5 million votes but only a handful of seats then there is something fundamentally wrong.
 
I wonder if the SNP will now try to get another Scottish referendum before we leave Europe.

fun times ahead

Why would this matter? Europe has made it clear that Scotland would have to go through the full application process if it wanted to join. And many Eurozone members would be hostile to this because it would weaken their own national unity.
 

iMax

Member
Woof, I suspect that this didn't mean to come off as sociopathic as it did.

Do people not read the posts they quote or something? You're making the most incredible reaches here. Stop putting words in my mouth. You plainly know that isn't what I said. Nobody has that view.

I'm simply questioning why I'm expected to publicly justify my voting behaviour. Why is it relevant whether or not I care for disabled people? Leaving the subject of that aside (which I've stated, of course I care), I'm challenging this belief that has repeatedly reared its head in this thread, that somehow, voting behaviour needs to be justified before it can be respected.
 

kmag

Member
yes it is, a lot of the brown deadwood is being cleared out today. hopefully the party will now move out of the shadow of new labour.

move out of the shadow of new labour? Given what's happened overnight, they're almost certainly going to tac right because the centre ground of English politics now seems to be the centre-right. They'll be added the new back on as soon as they find some tape.
 
Not anymore it's not, I'm afraid. Social Media is increasingly driving the modern news agenda and is a far stronger influence for many.

As for the treatment of the disabled by the Tories, I'm not really sure what you're trying to achieve. I'm either going to say i) I condemn it, so you'll condemn me for my opinion, based on whatever contrived, out-of-context, hyperbolic example you'll inevitably cite, or I'll say I ii) support it, so you'll condemn my sense of humanity.

I'm not going to entertain this ludicrous approach to discussion. Nobody's going to advocate for the criminalisation of the disabled, as you put it.

Actually you would be wrong, recent studies and polls have shown that the majority of people get their information on political news and what policies Government are implementing etc. from Newspapers and TV.

This is coming from someone in Government Comms who primarily works in digital engagement.

Social media is great for 35 and under but for all those above the main place they get their information is more traditional sources
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
They aren't important to most of the country it seems. The shocking treatment of the disabled recently has been largely ignored.

honestly i think most people get to an election and they're like, 'well, i know that a lot of people are worse off, but i'm richer now, so i'll vote tory'

i don't mean this in a rude way. it's a lot to ask people to vote selflessly, and i'm not going to pretend that not voting tory is some noble and selfless act.

but this is also why people lie about voting tory, i think. they know that it's probably a bad thing to be voting for yourself when there are thousands of people in the country who are worse off, but they look at their own situation and think, 'well i'm doing okay...'

when you combine that with a complete lack of a compelling alternative from labour, it's not difficult to see why millions of people vote for the tories even with all of the data showing how bad they are for the most vulnerable people in the country.
 
It's not 100% on 'the media', I completely agree that Labour failed to offer anything compelling too.

But the fact that the media are either controlled by Tories or, in the case of the BBC too scared to question them, certainly helps the Tories to turn their mistruths and distortions into 'facts'--'austerity fixed the economy' is a perfect example.

I'm not sure that's particularly reasonable. In 2010 all the major parties signed up to austerity as a solution and on 2015 they all basically did the same. If the Beeb have a representative from each party on, I'm not sure the unbiased approach is for their interviewers to go off in a Keynesian critique that literally none of the parties support - except the SNP (though that was largely just a rhetorical difference since their manifesto was similar to Labours) who did gangbusters. So maybe if this is the argument that should be put forward, Labour should have been doing it (and I'm sure you think they should), but that doesn't mean the BBC is somehow favouring the Tories when they themselves don't bring it up.

I think this BBC Bias thing has more or less been conjured up in the last 12 hours.
 

DECK'ARD

The Amiga Brotherhood
As an Irishman looking in one thing I have noticed is that the UK's electoral system is broken. When the greens and ukip get 5 million votes but only a handful of seats then there is something fundamentally wrong.

Well we had a chance to fix that, but the Lib Dems ballsed it up by offering AV which wasn't a compelling enough argument.

Now we stand no chance of fixing it.
 

Tak3n

Banned
Not the right candidate.



Markets reacting favourably to the result it seems

they said last night it would simply be a response to stable government, nothing to do with the tories...

but this will quickly disappear once the uncertainty of a EU referendum comes into play

Energy companies will see a boost though with a tory win
 

iMax

Member
Actually you would be wrong, recent studies and polls have shown that the majority of people get their information on political news and what policies Government are implementing etc. from Newspapers and TV.

This is coming from someone in Government Comms who primarily works in digital engagement.

Social media is great for 35 and under but for all those above the main place they get their information is more traditional sources

showmethereceipts.gif
 

Matt_

World's #1 One Direction Fan: Everyone else in the room can see it, everyone else but you~~~
Not the right candidate.

Markets reacting favourably to the result it seems

although Im not happy with the result a majority is a lot better than a sketchy minority government or a shaky coalition
 

BigDes

Member
I'm not sure that's particularly reasonable. In 2010 all the major parties signed up to austerity as a solution and on 2015 they all basically did the same. If the Beeb have a representative from each party on, I'm not sure the unbiased approach is for their interviewers to go off in a Keynesian critique that literally none of the parties support - except the SNP (though that was largely just a rhetorical difference since their manifesto was similar to Labours) who did gangbusters. So maybe if this is the argument that should be put forward, Labour should have been doing it (and I'm sure you think they should), but that doesn't mean the BBC is somehow favouring the Tories when they themselves don't bring it up.

I think this BBC Bias thing has more or less been conjured up in the last 12 hours.

My favourite thing about the whole BBC bias is when the conservatives used to lambast Paxman for being biased against them, and then once he retired from Newsnight it turned out he had been a conservative voter all his life.
 

kmag

Member
Well we had a chance to fix that, but the Lib Dems ballsed it up by offering AV which wasn't a compelling enough argument.

Now we stand no chance of fixing it.

AV isn't proportional. It actually produces more disproportional results in most situations.
 

Tak3n

Banned
honestly i think most people get to an election and they're like, 'well, i know that a lot of people are worse off, but i'm richer now, so i'll vote tory'

i don't mean this in a rude way. it's a lot to ask people to vote selflessly, and i'm not going to pretend that not voting tory is some noble and selfless act.

but this is also why people lie about voting tory, i think. they know that it's probably a bad thing to be voting for yourself when there are thousands of people in the country who are worse off, but they look at their own situation and think, 'well i'm doing okay...'

when you combine that with a complete lack of a compelling alternative from labour, it's not difficult to see why millions of people vote for the tories even with all of the data showing how bad they are for the most vulnerable people in the country.

a lot of 'experts' believe just that, they got to the booth and though, no tax rises for 5 years, so voted on personal circumstances rather than country specific issues
 
What is happening? Are you reading my posts in full or just pouncing on individual words?

I don't subscribe to the criticism the Conservative Party receives for its approach to a reformed NHS and I don't agree with certain peoples' cross-examination of it.

To say that—simply because I have a different view to yourself—I must, therefore, hate disabled people, is frankly symbolic of the short-sighted vitriol I've come to expect from some people.

Your post gave the impression that you didn't care about disabled people, which is why I asked. I don't care if you voted Tories, that's your prerogative, and it turns out a lot of people did the same as you.
 

tomtom94

Member
My favourite thing about the whole BBC bias is when the conservatives used to lambast Paxman for being biased against them, and then once he retired from Newsnight it turned out he had been a conservative voter all his life.
To be fair, the two aren't mutually exclusive. There was a perception with Bercow for a while that he deliberately tried to position himself against the Conservatives to avoid accusations of bias in their favour (him being an ex-Conservative and the Speaker being impartial).
 
showmethereceipts.gif

I cant as this is stuff that i have been told at work so its not material i have at hand but honestly that is the facts of the matter.

I actually do the social media analytics for a government body Comms team so for those results i know them better than anyone.
 

DECK'ARD

The Amiga Brotherhood
AV isn't proportional. It actually produces more disproportional results in most situations.

I'll never understand why they went for that with what was clearly a one-shot attempt at change.

Straight PR would not only have been better but also have been a much easier sell to the public.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom