The end actually came last fall when the Pirates offered Burnett a one-year, $8.5-million contract before he became a free agent.
Burnett was said to be insulted with an offer that represented a 47 percent pay cut from his 2013 salary of $16.5 million. The Pirates rationale was that the Yankees paid $8.5 million of that $16.5 million, part of the terms of trade that sent Burnett to Pittsburgh at the start of spring training in 2012.
Even when the Pirates increased their offer to $11 million, it wasnt enough to entice Burnett to come back.
It also showed how little the Pirates wanted Burnett to return. Considering owner Bob Nutting recently bought a second ski resort in the Laurel Highlands, he certainly could have sprung for $16 million for one more year of Burnett.
Burnett told the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review last year during spring training that he would either return to the Pirates in 2013 or retire and had no desire for any other team. He reiterated those feelings late in the regular season, saying I cant imagine playing for anyone but the black and gold.
But everything changed when the Pirates decided not to start Burnett in the decisive Game 5 against the Cardinals in the National League Division Series after he had been rocked for seven runs in two innings in Game 1. Rookie Gerrit Cole got the start instead and the Pirates lost.
Manager Clint Hurdle told Burnett of his plan immediately after the Pirates lost in Game 4 at PNC Park, setting up the winner-take-all game two nights later at St. Louis.
Burnett was enraged by the decision and threatened to not fly with the team to St. Louis despite being told he would likely start Game 1 or 2 if the Pirates advanced to the National League Championship Series to face the Dodgers.
While the clubhouse was closed to the media, sources on the inside said it made for an awkward scene with the players still upset about suffering a tough 2-1 loss and failing to clinch the series while Burnett ranted.
Meanwhile, a source close to Burnett, said being bypassed for the Game 5 start motivated the 37-year-old to play one more year. He felt he still had something to prove and also did not want to end his career on such a bad note.
So now Burnett is with the Phillies and the Pirates are without their first true No. 1 starter since Doug Drabek was anchoring the rotation back in the early 1990s.