Bishman said:
Top 5 P4P
1. Anderson Silva
2. Frankie Edgar
3. GSP
4. Jose Aldo
5. Jon Jones
I can't think of any other fighters that would belong in the top 5 at the moment, even if 2-5 are damn near interchangeable in my book.
K.Jack said:
Wtf I know he's the champ, but there's no way I could give Frankie 9 points for that round.
Maybe Maynard wouldn't have slept on Edgar during round two had he known he lacked a cushion in the points game. Regardless he did sleep on him, and the whole fight went tits up in Edgar's favor by Round 4.
UFC considering Frankie Edgar vs. Jose Aldo super-fight: Fan reaction
When it comes to P4P, I would really like to see a Edgar/Aldo matchup in the not-so-distant future. His previous few decisions notwithstanding, Aldo has had some quality KO's on his resume and was knocking out cans in the WEC left and right, but seeing Edgar's KO power on Maynard makes me think this one could be a winner. I'm wondering if Aldo's best shot would be for Edgar to drop down since it might take some power and speed out of Edgar, or if it would be better for Aldo to move up. Aldo's still fast, but not like he was in the WEC days (I say that like it was years ago). He put some meat on his bones and exposed some holes in his game. His last two fights looked like he had to work hard to pull off the win, while his match against Faber made his opponent look like an amateur. Made Faber drop to 135 for a belt.
That's why the matchup makes sense, it's not so difficult to conceive a loss on either fighter's part.