Support NeoGAF

[Razek]

In some (don't think all) cases they got some input. What type of pony, and colors.

That makes this tough besides the obvious ones. I'm still thinking on it. So far I know:

Belle Eve is given (top right)
Pandaman is the panda (top/mid left)
Owl is super easy
The white pony with the Black mane/Pink bow at the far far corner right is a posters avatar they have worn here for at least a year. They don't post in this thread. They have a sword CM.

I'm still thinking on others.

 

[LuffyZoro]

Myke can probably shed more light on it. I know I was asked for type and colors.

I know that I already had a pony.

 

[Razek]

Any hints you guys could give me?

 

[DrForester]

I know that I already had a pony.

I didn't know that any of Mykes were base don pre-exisiting OC's.

Moreyouknow.jpg

 

[DrForester]

Any hints you guys could give me?

If you knew Hito's old avatar you'd ID his right away. To be honest a few of them would be given away based on old Avatars if the person posted regularly here. Cheezmo and Ookami Wolf would probably be quick ID's.

One hint for mine, it has nothing to do with MST3K or Sci-Fi.

 

[LuffyZoro]

Any hints you guys could give me?

I can tell you that your current guesses are right, and also that Bak, Doc, and I are all in there.

 

[Razek]

Is buf's the brown/white ear tipped bearded one that looks sort of like viking in the middle?

And the similar one in the middle right?

 

[LuffyZoro]

Is buf's the brown/white ear tipped bearded one that looks sort of like viking in the middle?

And the similar one in the middle right?

Yep, those are both him.

 

[Razek]

Yep, those are both him.

I know he does music and draws (which I just found out now) so I figured from the cutie mark being a note and pen + the stash.

This is my first mostly blind guess: Is the pony in the lower middle slight left with the fishermans hat ahoyhoy?

Edit: Another. Mykes is the spiker haired one on the right because of the obvious cutie mark: a grey wolf.

 

[LuffyZoro]

I know he does music and draws (which I just found out now) so I figured from the cutie mark being a note and pen + the stash.

This is my first mostly blind guess: Is the pony in the lower middle slight left with the fishermans hat ahoyhoy?

Edit: Another. Mykes is the spiker haired one on the right because of the obvious cutie mark: a grey wolf.

Those are both wrong actually.

 

[Razek]

Those are both wrong actually.

boo

 

[LuffyZoro]

boo

I'm not joking, if that's what you think. I'll tell you that ahoy isn't in there.

 

[Amibguous Cad]

Any hints you guys could give me?

It was drawn while I was in law school

 

[ahoyhoy]

I'm not joking, if that's what you think. I'll tell you that ahoy isn't in there.

The birthing pangs of my OC were too pain-inducing for the collective creative minds of PonyGAF to handle in time for this wonderful group portrait, unfortunately

 

[Silvawuff]

Rainbow PJs? Pfft. I raise you a Twilight in PJs.

 

[Razek]

No I believe you Luffy. I was just disappointed, especially at my Myke guess.

Cad, is yours the one in the window?

Rainbow PJs? Pfft. I raise you a Twilight in PJs.

http://i.imgur.com/kSHWI.png[IMG][/QUOTE]

Already got it covered last page :p

 

[Amibguous Cad]

No I believe you Luffy. I was just disappointed, especially at my Myke guess.

Cad, is yours the one in the window?

Nope.

It's an homage to a video game.

 

[LuffyZoro]

I see your Twi in PJs and raise you a Fluttershy in PJs.

 

[Razek]

Foxix is the yellow brown on the very far middle right laughing because of Vinyls glasses. He always had vinyl as his avatar.

I assumed Cheezmo's and Okamis would be super simple but I just can't figure it out.

 

[LuffyZoro]

Foxix is the yellow brown on the very far middle right laughing because of Vinyls glasses. He always had vinyl as his avatar.

I assumed Cheezmo's and Okamis would be super simple but I just can't figure it out.

Yep, you got Foxix right.

 

[Razek]

Cheezmo's is the sleeping one because of the bloody heart....???? That's a stretch and I know it.

 

[LuffyZoro]

Alright, I have to go to sleep, but you can keep guessing and I can tell you right/wrong in the morning, or someone can fill in for me.

EDIT: Correct on Cheez, actually.

 

[DrForester]

Foxix is the yellow brown on the very far middle right laughing because of Vinyls glasses. He always had vinyl as his avatar.

I assumed Cheezmo's and Okamis would be super simple but I just can't figure it out.

The Cutie Mark gives them both away. Okami's is more obvious though.

 

[Razek]

Alright, I have to go to sleep, but you can keep guessing and I can tell you right/wrong in the morning, or someone can fill in for me.

EDIT: Correct on Cheez, actually.

WOW, g'night.

The Cutie Mark gives them both away. Okami's is more obvious though.

He's the grew wolf one I thought was Mykes isn't he?

 

[DrForester]

WOW, g'night.



He's the grew wolf one I thought was Mykes isn't he?

yup

 

[Rhomega Beta]

My OC is in the top left corner. I probably plug it more than anyone else here, save for Bak.

 

[Razek]

My OC is in the top left corner. I probably plug it more than anyone else here, save for Bak.

See, I was thinking this but in your picture you posted (yesterday I think) it's a male pony and the one in the Party Pic has a more female hairstyle.

 

[DrForester]

My OC is in the top left corner. I probably plug it more than anyone else here, save for Bak.

Easily the second best white coated, blue haired Pegasus in the group picture.

 

[Razek]

Easily the second best white coated, blue haired Pegasus in the group picture.

You're goggles?

 

[DrForester]

You're goggles?

Figured it was too blatant a clue, but yes. Honestly thought the scandalized look would have given me away earlier

 

[$200]

 

[Razek]

^
WTH?

More guesses:

Cad is either the Masked pony (middle left) OR the green pony (bottom Right)
Hito is the space ranger??? (bottom left)
Luffy is the window?

Edit: I feel bad not realizing yours earlier Doc. I forgot about 'best race'.

 

[blamite]

fav rarity thing


oh jeez just noticed the camera angle the focused bow looks like her diamond shaped cutie mark

Okay this is the best ever. Rarity is tied for best pony. (I'm not telling you with whom)

 

[DrForester]

Hito is the space ranger??? (bottom left)
Luffy is the window?

Nope. These are tough becasue their old. Hito is the pony in the painting, was based on his old avatar. Window is Careksims (aka John Joseco)

 

[Razek]

I think I hit all the ones I'm going to get then without cheating. Any obvious ones you remember you want to give away or have any last hints you want to give?

The one that's bugging me the most is the green pony. I swear I have seen that cutie mark before and it's killing me.

Cad could also be the spiky middle one with the super dark goku hair.

Orcs the pink flying one because twilight is pink??

Yeah, I'm just dumb guessing now.

 

[Orcastar]

Guessing games, huh?

Orcs the pink flying one because twilight is pink??

Nope, that's Chuck (he doesn't post here much).

However, since you already figured out buf, figuring out me and Myke should be easy since the three of us make up Manestream Games.

 

[Razek]

Guessing games, huh?



Nope, that's Chuck (he doesn't post here much).

However, since you already figured out buf, figuring out me and Myke should be easy since the three of us make up Manestream Games.

Wait, so you guys all know each-other IRL?

Edit: Got lost reading the website, and obviously you guys are the three ponies with the beers in the middle. I assume your the back one because Mike is the grey one?

 

[Orcastar]

Wait, so you guys all know each-other IRL?

Edit: Got lost reading the website, and obviously you guys are the three ponies with the beers in the middle. I assume your the back one because Mike is the grey one?

Nah, we just met through the PonyGAF IRC and decided to try and make a pony game, that's all. Never met each other IRL.

And yup, that's correct.

 

[Razek]

Nah, we just met through the PonyGAF IRC and decided to try and make a pony game, that's all. Never met each other IRL.

What was with all the notes in the pictures then from eachother?

 

[Dark Phoenix]

You'll never find my OC in there.

Spoiler

It's not in there.

Edit: New page, new art.

 

[DrForester]

 

[Razek]

And wow Orc and Co. This demo is really impressive. You guys still working on the game? Did any of you have prior experience programming?

 

[DrForester]

You'll never find my OC in there.

Spoiler

It's not in there.

Edit: New page, new art.

 

[Razek]

Awww that's it? Well that was fun!

Edit:

Spoiler

Who sang the song?

 

[Orcastar]

And wow Orc and Co. This demo is really impressive. You guys still working on the game? Did any of you have prior experience programming?

Thanks!

We are still working on it, though progress has been very slow lately due to IRL reasons... And no, we didn't have any experience with game development when starting this. Myke's doing all the programming anyway. Meanwhile buf is in charge of music and most of the graphics while I'm in charge of story and dialogue.

 

[Horse Detective]

 

[Razek]

Thanks!

We are still working on it, though progress has been very slow lately due to IRL reasons... And no, we didn't have any experience with game development when starting this. Myke's doing all the programming anyway. Meanwhile buf is in charge of music and most of the graphics while I'm in charge of story and dialogue.

I've done quite a bit of game design over the years. I'll be honest, seeing many collaboration projects I was expecting something much less polished going in. The fluidity and general pleasing nature of everything including the animation was quite a surprise. Moving around is easy and snappy. Sound/Music design is good and varied while staying faithful to the show. Your HUD is mostly simple to understand, it didn't take me too long to figure things out. The writing was funny and enjoyable; I read every character in their voice. I very much enjoyed solving the puzzle, and I hate adventure games! You've done some great work. Again, I'm very impressed.

The only thing I really didn't enjoy so much were the default reading voices. Just personal preference of course. I had enough of issun in Okami, I didn't need a repeat with Sweetie Belle. Luckily, you guys were kind enough to give a VO volume bar. Way to go!

When/if you guys start active development up again, I'd like to donate something for your hard work. I can't offer much, but I think you guys deserve the price of a game at least.

 

[Slamtastic]

http://equestriangirls.tumblr.com/

 

[Professor Beef]

I'm liking that comic.

 

[Owlowiscious]

Owl is super easy

At least take me to dinner and buy me a drink first