• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NASA's Mars Science Laboratory |OT| 2,000 Pounds of Science!

Status
Not open for further replies.

asa

Member
Greenhouse?

I mean, I would recon Mars soil properties must be about the same as earth soil. To get something grow naturally on mars is impossible, to get earth plants to grow on mars soil inside a greenhouse/mars station would probably be totally doable.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
For a moment i though i as reading fox news ...

I've mentioned before but NASA funding is not really a partisan issue. There are plenty of people on both sides that are for and against more funding. And likewise, there are people on all sides of the media with the same, differing viewpoints. I'm sure you could find articles similar on Fox and MSNBC. For example, MSNBC has many positive articles about the landing, but also only dedicated about 10 minutes of live coverage of the event before going back to some prison show. Fox stuck with it for about a half hour after landing. CNN also had much wider coverage than MSNBC, yet has stories like this on their front page.
 

Trouble

Banned
100 billion lol,
it was $2.5billion spread over 7 years, or something wasn't it?

Mission to Mars: $7 per US citizen.
2012 Presidential Campaign is also estimated to cost $2.5billion

London Olympics: £148 per UK citizen.
US War on Drugs: $42 per US citizen in 2010 alone

That is some depressing shit. The forward march of the human race is being actively held back by not funding importan science like this.

Now imagine we had a worldwide space agency on that budget per citizen

Humans on Mars in less than a year, I'd guess.
 

Bitmap Frogs

Mr. Community
I mean, I would recon Mars soil properties must be about the same as earth soil. To get something grow naturally on mars is impossible, to get earth plants to grow on mars soil inside a greenhouse/mars station would probably be totally doable.

Didn't they find that the surface soil was swamped in perchlorates?

I'm not an expert but I'm not too sure you can grow stuff on that, nevermind the fact it fucks up your thyroid...
 
I am interested in knowing the radiation level on the ground (there is an instrument for this i think). Mars is geologically dead and has no magnetic field to deflect the sun's solar wind. If we ever to colonized Mars. Living on the surface is pretty much impossible.
 

besada

Banned
Didn't they find that the surface soil was swamped in perchlorates?

I'm not an expert but I'm not too sure you can grow stuff on that, nevermind the fact it fucks up your thyroid...

It's unclear. Originally we didn't find perchlorates and then we did. One of the things Curiosity will do is hopefully clear up the question of whether perchlorates are widely dispersed and at what levels.

Curiosity will also be measuring surface radiation.
 

1stStrike

Banned
I'm quite interested in the trip to 3 of Jupiter's moons (including Europa) they have planned for 2022 (won't arrive until like 2033, though).

Even if that goes well, at the rate of travel I'll be old as fuck or dead by the time they plan a second expedition anyway, though. I wish I could just peek into like a couple hundred years in the future to see where we were at in regards to space travel and such.
 
I'm quite interested in the trip to 3 of Jupiter's moons (including Europa) they have planned for 2022 (won't arrive until like 2033, though).

Even if that goes well, at the rate of travel I'll be old as fuck or dead by the time they plan a second expedition anyway, though. I wish I could just peek into like a couple hundred years in the future to see where we were at in regards to space travel and such.

man, it drives me absolutely nuts that i probably won't live to see what's swimming in Europas vast oceans (or other moons that potentially have oceans, Enceladus etc).

it likely has more water than our blue planet, which is just goddamn amazing.

tumblr_m4j3yoNRpY1rqpa8po1_500.jpg


can you imagine that much water mass having NO life whatsoever? i can't.
 

owlbeak

Member
man, it drives me absolutely nuts that i probably won't live to see what's swimming in Europas vast oceans (or other moons that potentially have oceans, Enceladus etc).

it likely has more water than our blue planet, which is just goddamn amazing.

tumblr_m4j3yoNRpY1rqpa8po1_500.jpg


can you imagine that much water mass having NO life whatsoever? i can't.
If I were a betting man, I'd definitely bet money that the oceans of Europa are teeming with creatures.
 

Log4Girlz

Member
man, it drives me absolutely nuts that i probably won't live to see what's swimming in Europas vast oceans (or other moons that potentially have oceans, Enceladus etc).

it likely has more water than our blue planet, which is just goddamn amazing.

tumblr_m4j3yoNRpY1rqpa8po1_500.jpg


can you imagine that much water mass having NO life whatsoever? i can't.

I'm pretty sure we were asked to leave it alone like 2 years ago.
 
If I were a betting man, I'd definitely bet money that the oceans of Europa are teeming with creatures.

definitely. maybe just single-celled micro-organisms, but even still.. that would be the most amazing scientific discovery ever.

btw does anyone know how old exactly Europa is? (wikipedia fails me, wtf). has it had billions of years of time for life to develop, as earth has? i assume so. i'm confident that is more than enough time for life to spark into existance in such a water rich and energy rich (heat from tidal flexing) environment. it happened on earth fairly fast too.

goddamn i want to see manned submarines explore the hell out of that water world. imagine the things we could encounter there... maybe there are even some intelligent beings there :O probably not, but we have to make sure! to not at least check out what's there would be an insane notion.

I'm pretty sure we were asked to leave it alone like 2 years ago.

hah, i only recently just watched 2010 :p great movie IMO.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Isn't it possible that if we find life elsewhere in the solar system, it may have come from Earth after asteroid/meteor impacts?
 

1stStrike

Banned
definitely. maybe just single-celled micro-organisms, but even still.. that would be the most amazing scientific discovery ever.

btw does anyone know how old exactly Europa is? (wikipedia fails me, wtf). has it had billions of years of time for life to develop, as earth has? i assume so. i'm confident that is more than enough time for life to spark into existance in such a water rich and energy rich (heat from tidal flexing) environment. it happened on earth fairly fast too.

Europa is much younger than earth and is still quite unstable.

Europa's icy crust gives it an albedo (light reflectivity) of 0.64, one of the highest of all moons. This would seem to indicate a young and active surface; based on estimates of the frequency of cometary bombardment that Europa probably endures, the surface is about 20 to 180 million years old

The crust is estimated to have undergone a shift of 80°, nearly flipping over

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_(moon)

Not sure I'd want to live in a place that's as unstable as that - it even changes shape depending on the proximity to Jupiter. I'd say that perhaps the moon is a bit too watery.
 
I watched the series while reading the book. My body barely could handle all that Carl Sagan goodness.

That's awesome! So far I have only seen the, "play blue dot" speech from his Cosmos television series. I love Carl Saga! BTW my dad gave me the book, it's the original/first print edition ;)
 
Isn't it possible that if we find life elsewhere in the solar system, it may have come from Earth after asteroid/meteor impacts?

i believe so. the whole panspermia thing makes total sense to me.

it's also possible for example that Mars was the place in our solar system that had life first. then it spread to Earth via meteors. we could all be Martians.

worst case scenario for me would be finding life on Mars and realizing they are originally from Earth and that there is nothing particularly genetically interesting about them :/ would prove panspermia though.
 

Log4Girlz

Member
i believe so. the whole panspermia thing makes total sense to me.

it's also possible for example that Mars was the place in our solar system that had life first. then it spread to Earth via meteors. we could all be Martians.

worst case scenario for me would be finding life on Mars and realizing they are originally from Earth and that there is nothing particularly genetically interesting about them :/ would prove panspermia though.

Its weird because the seeding material was probably not much in such a scenario. So the pattern was Martian but its using earthly products. Its like designing something in the US and having it sent to China for manufacture.
 
N

NinjaFridge

Unconfirmed Member
Now imagine we had a worldwide space agency on that budget per citizen
I always thought that space should be a worldwide thing. Probably wouldn't happen though, too much cock waving to make it work.
 
Europa is much younger than earth and is still quite unstable.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europa_(moon)

Not sure I'd want to live in a place that's as unstable as that - it even changes shape depending on the proximity to Jupiter. I'd say that perhaps the moon is a bit too watery.

i noticed the bit about the surface being young yeah, but i assumed it just means the current surface. surely the whole moon is older than just 100 million years or so? my guess would be that it was formed "shortly" (in relative terms) after Jupiter, so it would have to be more than 2-3 billion years old. no idea when the oceans formed though..

and the changing shape thing, doesn't even the Earth change slightly in shape from the Moon's pull? probably so slightly that it is almost impossible to measure but still. too much tidal flexing is probably a bad thing for life though, i agree.
 

FACE

Banned
That's awesome! So far I have only seen the, "play blue dot" speech from his Cosmos television series. I love Carl Saga! BTW my dad gave me the book, it's the original/first print edition ;)

Actually, that speech comes from the audiobook version of Pale Blue Dot which is also a great book.

You're really lucky, that version has a lot more images than mine.
 
Man, imagine if Curiosity finds out that actually, some millions or billions of years ago Mars was indeed covered with water (or at least had a good amount of it on the surface). That would drive many scientists nuts.
 

owlbeak

Member
Man, imagine if Curiosity finds out that actually, some millions or billions of years ago Mars was indeed covered with water (or at least had a good amount of it on the surface). That would drive many scientists nuts.
They are already pretty sure Mars had substantial amounts of liquid water on its surface a long time ago. They've found many mineral deposits that, as far as we know on Earth, only form in the presence of liquid water. They've also seen clear areas of water erosion along with dried river channels and deltas. They've also recently found a lot of water ice below the surface that melts during the Martian summer and sometimes seeps up to the surface. (That link takes you to a clip from the press conference where they announce this, with animations from HiRISE of water melting and running down a hillside. Very cool.)
 

Rentahamster

Rodent Whores
Man, imagine if Curiosity finds out that actually, some millions or billions of years ago Mars was indeed covered with water (or at least had a good amount of it on the surface). That would drive many scientists nuts.

There already is lots of evidence to suggest that Mars once had surface water. Currently the temp is too low and the atmosphere too thin to allow for liquid water on the surface, but there is evidence for frozen water at the caps and under the ground.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_on_Mars

The Mars Rovers Spirit and Opportunity found a great deal of evidence for past water on Mars. Designed to last only three months, both were still operating after more than six years. Although Spirit got trapped in a sand pit, Opportunity continues to provide scientific discovery.

The Spirit rover landed in what was thought to be a huge lake bed. However, the lake bed had been covered over with lava flows, so evidence of past water was initially hard to detect. As the mission progressed and the Rover continued to move along the surface more and more clues to past water were found.

Curiosity will only further build on the current evidence and is well equipped to possibly detect signs of past life.
 

ckohler

Member
Also, they chose Gale Crater as the landing site specifically because it would have served as a natural reservoir for surface water in the distant past. They want to look into the sides of Mt. Sharp to see what the sediment layers tell them.
 

beast786

Member
man, it drives me absolutely nuts that i probably won't live to see what's swimming in Europas vast oceans (or other moons that potentially have oceans, Enceladus etc).

it likely has more water than our blue planet, which is just goddamn amazing.

tumblr_m4j3yoNRpY1rqpa8po1_500.jpg


can you imagine that much water mass having NO life whatsoever? i can't.

If its water , wouldn't it be frozen at those temps?

It could be ocean of liquid methane.
 

owlbeak

Member
If its water , wouldn't it be frozen at those temps?

It could be ocean of liquid methane.
The surface is a layer of frozen water ice. Below the ice is a liquid ocean of water that is kept warm(er) by tidal forces from Jupiter and internal heat from the planet's geological activity.
 

gutshot

Member
The surface is a layer of frozen water ice. Below the ice is a liquid ocean of water that is kept warm by tidal forces from Jupiter and internal heat from the planet's geological activity.

This is why I'm very interested in what they find below the Arctic ice cap. It should give us an idea of what kind of life could develop on Europa.
 

owlbeak

Member
This is why I'm very interested in what they find below the Arctic ice cap. It should give us an idea of what kind of life could develop on Europa.
They've found a lot of extremophiles in polar oceans that thrive off of small heat vents on the sea floor. It's very possible that the same thing is going on under the ice of Europa. Would be amazing to be able to get there and find out.
 

owlbeak

Member
From MSL site. Some of this is from this morning, so I'm not sure why they're going over it again almost 12 hours later, but it does outline plans for what we should hear about in the press conference tomorrow.
Curiosity Gets More Looks at its Surroundings; Health Checks Continue
Tue, 07 Aug 2012 10:47:37 PM EDT

Curiosity is healthy as it continues to familiarize itself with its new home in Gale Crater and check out its systems. The team's plans for Curiosity checkout today included raising the rover's mast and continued testing of its high-gain antenna, whose pointing toward Earth will be adjusted on Sol 2. Science data were collected from Curiosity's Radiation Assessment Detector, and activities were performed with the Rover Environmental Monitoring Station instrument. Curiosity transmitted its first color image from the surface of Mars, from the Mars Hand Lens Imager, or MAHLI, showing part of the north rim of Gale Crater. Additional calibration images were received from Curiosity's Navcam and Mastcam. All systems are go for deployment of the rover's remote sensing mast on Sol 2, followed by a 360-degree pan by the rover's Navcam. The Mastcam will also be calibrated against a target image on the rover. NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter returned a spectacular image of Curiosity's landing site, depicting the rover, parachute, back shell, heat shield and descent stage. Data were received from both NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter and Mars Odyssey.
I'm interested to see what the radiation readings from the surface are like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom