NeoGAF Arcade Stick Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Trax416 said:
I am looking into buying an arcade stick for the 360.

Does anyone have a suggestion on which one I should buy? Also, does anywhere make custom ones for the 360 and if so where?
HRAP EX if you like JPN sticks

as for customs and Happ/American style sticks google arcade in a box
 
Whats a good price for a virtua stick high grade? If someone was to sell me one for 90 dollars??? would that be a good price? If so I am going to pick that up right now. LOL


Actually peace lol. After looking on ebay. I will be driving fast as hell to the store for this. Hell yeah
 
Ryder said:
The stick has arrived!

It came in a bawkz!
23jgp0.jpg


Ooooh... buttons!
2ivjg9d.jpg


And a stick!
2m3pxg7.jpg
quoting pretty pictures
 
Spiderjericho said:
dfyb, that was an awesome project. Yeah...you're top tier. I mean for your first joystick, it came out very well. Except for creating your own PCB, everything was from scratch. I like the artwork and layout.

You won't catch me in a million years doing the same...just don't have the patience...

But who knows...

If you refine it or work on a second, definitely post it.
yeah i got a new router and drill -- the new router should make the hardware mounting painless (dremel w/routing attachment took ages), so we'll see. a PS360 stick would be nice. maybe save it for this summer.
 
First pickup of the year. It is a doozy. Camera phone does not really do it justice. This one will proudly go next to MarkMan's forthcoming SF IV Tournament Edition stick.

IMG_0159.jpg


IMG_0160.jpg
 
Got it. Traded in my tekken 5 stick and some old games. The total for the stick was 99.79 after taxes. Pictures coming soon. My stick game is increasing.

It was brand new in box!!!!!!
 
dfyb said:
quoting pretty pictures

:D

In other news these buttons are freaking mushy, gonna replace them ASAP. Of the two, which are 'mushier': Sanwa or Seimitsu? I definitely don't like the mushiness, no sirree!

Also, dragon punch motions facing left... ugh. Time to get over this hurdle again.

edit: Also, wtf MT grats on the stick :lol My T5 stick has traveled long and far *sheds tear*
 
MThanded said:
Got it. Traded in my tekken 5 stick and some old games. The total for the stick was 99.79 after taxes. Pictures coming soon. My stick game is increasing.

It was brand new in box!!!!!!

Bastard.. nice.. honestly if its new in box you should sell it for like 200-300 bucks, no lie.
 
Ryder said:
:D

In other news these buttons are freaking mushy, gonna replace them ASAP. Of the two, which are 'mushier': Sanwa or Seimitsu? I definitely don't like the mushiness, no sirree!

Also, dragon punch motions facing left... ugh. Time to get over this hurdle again.

edit: Also, wtf MT grats on the stick :lol My T5 stick has traveled long and far *sheds tear*
Yeah into someone elses hands soon I guess. They had an HRAP for the ps2 also. Seeing as people are always praising the vshg I got this one. Also I still had no converter for it.

haunts said:
Bastard.. nice.. honestly if its new in box you should sell it for like 200-300 bucks, no lie.

Hmmm....
 
What do I do with this thing? Sell it or keep it.

I put it back in the box. Im scared... lol
 
Okay. So for those of you who were wondering the difference between a Square Gate and Octagonal Gate. The left being square, the right being octagonal.

ddgmjn.jpg



So what's the difference between the two? The biggest differences if your dead zone area. With square, you have a more tight and narrow area to play on. Being on a square, you can feel your corners. With octagonal, you have a full circle you can play around in. Just you have more room to move which can be a good or bad thing for you. In my case, I've been playing on a square gate for the past year. After a couple of hours of play with the octagonal gate, here are my impressions of the games I picked out. Tekken 5: DR and SSF2THDREmix.

First is Tekken:

Square:
This is ideal for Tekken (and VF as well in this case). It was made for Tekken in mind with EWGF, wave dashing, etc. You have quick reaction with a flick of your wrist.

Octagonal:
It's tricky at first but after you get a hang of the extra room with your motions, you'll play it like it were a square gate. The only big problem I see with this is you'll get tired in your wrist a lot quicker because of the large motions you have to make with your moves compared to the smaller movements with the square.

Conclusion:
If you are a first time Tekken player, either one will do you fine. Long time player, I highly suggest the square gate. Octagonal is optional under the circumstances that you play other fighters. If not, stay with the square gate for games like Tekken and VF.

Now onto Street Fighter:

Square:
Fireballs, dragon punches. It takes some time getting used to doing these with a square. But with patience, you'll catch on. Performing a super move I still struggle with. Granted I've only been playing Street Fighter on a arcade stick for the past month. So this could be due to my inexperience of the game on a stick. Performing a full 360 is really tricky because of the square corners that you can catch on and slow your roll. Charge characters are easily played. For me, I played much better with a charge character (Guile, Blanka, etc) than the others by far.

Octagonal:
Just with the two hours played, I was able to easily adjust my game with perform moves with Ryu, Ken, Cammy, etc. Fireballs, dragon punches, supers. All performed without any issues on either side. Even Zangief I was able to perform his 360 moves on classic mode without any hitch. As for charge characters, the difficulty turns up. You have a much larger area to perform this moves. Charge back to forward you'll get used to but charging down to up is very difficult.

Conclusion:
Between Square and Octagonal, they both have their ups and downs. You might want to look at who your main characters will be in the long run. If you're gonna play a charge character, the Square gate works perfectly. Other characters such as Ryu or Sagat, the Octagonal make them playable without having to worry if you're going to perform a super or not on either side.


Super Conclusion:
These are all my opinions and based on 2 hours of playtime with an octagonal gate today. At this time, I will be staying octagonal because of how it improves my performance with Street Fighter. As for Tekken, it remains the same. It was a little awkward at first because of the huge space I had to use with my wrist motions, but I got used to it and am able to keep the same performance with Tekken as if I were playing on a square gate.

If it's your first time using an arcade stick and going to start off with Street Fighter, I'd suggest going the octagonal route. This could also be applied to future games such as KOF12 and Blueblaze (I get that right?). But either gate can go either way for you. Everyone will have their own preferences.
 
Awesome writeup. Please make the picture smaller. I have to scroll over on my macbook pro to read some of the text. You have any idea what I should do with this vshg? lol
 
Octagon gate is a waste of money for me. After playing an hour on it, I swapped the square gate back in and I'm happier.
 
leehom said:
Octagon gate is a waste of money for me. After playing an hour on it, I swapped the square gate back in and I'm happier.
I never really played on an arcade stick before I got this hori ex2 for the xbox 360. When i first started using it the square gate felt weird to me. Now I love it.
 
MThanded said:
I never really played on an arcade stick before I got this hori ex2 for the xbox 360. When i first started using it the square gate felt weird to me. Now I love it.

There's this difference of feel between and EX2 and say HRAP3. Especially the corners. The EX2 feels like it hits the corners but slides right past it without you feeling it. On a HRAP3, you can feel every corner you hit with a QCF move.
 
Can anyone give me a review on the VSHG? How it feels to play on it. I am tempted to sell but if I keep it I will have a good stick for the ps3 and a good one for the xbox 360(TE sf4 stick). Does anyone on here want to buy the stick from me. I feel like an amateur race car driver in a F1 racer. I haven't taken it out of the plastic yet. Don't want it to lose value in case I do want to sell it. I am ultra indecisive. MarkMan are you around to give me some words of wisdom?
 
nice write up CcrooK. Anyone at SF State know if the SF IV machine was square or octagon? I felt at ease when I played it before break.
 
^^Keep it! It is a nice stick and the window for ordering was so small that a lot of us missed out. I opted for a HRAP3 at the time because of quality problems with the first run of the VSHG and regret to this day not having one.
 
MThanded said:
Can anyone give me a review on the VSHG? How it feels to play on it. I am tempted to sell but if I keep it I will have a good stick for the ps3 and a good one for the xbox 360(TE sf4 stick). Does anyone on here want to buy the stick from me. I feel like an amateur race car driver in a F1 racer. I haven't taken it out of the plastic yet. Don't want it to lose value in case I do want to sell it. I am ultra indecisive. MarkMan are you around to give me some words of wisdom?

MarkMan has a "rank" to sticks in terms of quality that you could use on his site (sdtekken.com). Top of the list is the SFIV TE stick. :D
 
I've been hearing good things about the TE joystick but I am going to wait until after CES. Most likely though, I will be pre-ordering it :lol .

When they said limited quantities of the TE sticks, how limited are they?
 
kiun said:
Does your VSHG have the 3 buttons input issue ?
That is a good question. I have not opened it at all yet. It still new in box and plastic. Just took it out to look but have not had the stick all the way out. Is there a way to tell without opening it. Different batch or model number or something?
 
MThanded said:
Can anyone give me a review on the VSHG? How it feels to play on it. I am tempted to sell but if I keep it I will have a good stick for the ps3 and a good one for the xbox 360(TE sf4 stick). Does anyone on here want to buy the stick from me. I feel like an amateur race car driver in a F1 racer. I haven't taken it out of the plastic yet. Don't want it to lose value in case I do want to sell it. I am ultra indecisive. MarkMan are you around to give me some words of wisdom?

I'm not going to lie to you, the Virtua Stick God Grade is the best commercial stick I've ever used. Ever.

just mod it for use with the 360.
 
viewtiful_dru said:
I'm not going to lie to you, the Virtua Stick God Grade is the best commercial stick I've ever used. Ever.

just mod it for use with the 360.

Whats the deal with this multiple button press problem?
 
Ordered two.


Product Total $79.98
Estimated Shipping $3.97
Estimated Tax $6.70
Order Total $90.65

Goddamn. They charged my account already.

I better get them.
 
zewone said:
Ordered two.


Product Total $79.98
Estimated Shipping $3.97
Estimated Tax $6.70
Order Total $90.65

Goddamn. They charged my account already.

I better get them.
What if they end up charging you the real price for both? :lol
 
MThanded said:
That is a good question. I have not opened it at all yet. It still new in box and plastic. Just took it out to look but have not had the stick all the way out. Is there a way to tell without opening it. Different batch or model number or something?
Might as well try it out yourself. It's not like putting electricity though it kills the thing's value. :D
 
RBH said:
Street Fighter IV Tournament Edition Fight Stick (Xbox 360) for just $39.99:

http://videogames.barnesandnoble.com/search/product.asp?ean=728658015589&itm=2


Most likely a pricing error, but doesn't hurt to try.

I ordered 1 using paypal generated one use credit card number... They cannot charge it again because its a one time use number.

For all that don't know Paypal will generate a Mastercard number that will access your funds and it will only work once.
 
MThanded said:
I ordered 1 using paypal generated one use credit card number... They cannot charge it again because its a one time use number.

For all that don't know Paypal will generate a Mastercard number that will access your funds and it will only work once.


Interesting, but how can any legit company charge your regular credit card for a price you didn't agree to?
 
Darkman M said:
Interesting, but how can any legit company charge your regular credit card for a price you didn't agree to?
Not sure but apparently this will be sent from gamestop. If that makes any difference. Thats what it said on the side of my page. lol
 
V. PRICES
The price for an item on the Barnes & Noble.com Site may differ from the price shown in a User's shopping cart — it is possible that such price may increase or decrease between the time the item is placed in a shopping cart and the time that the purchase is actually made. On rare occasions, an item may be priced incorrectly on the Barnes & Noble.com Site. If the price for the item on the Barnes & Noble.com Site is incorrect and is actually higher than the price provided at the time of purchase, then, at the sole discretion of Barnes & Noble.com, Barnes & Noble.com may either (i) contact the User for instructions before shipping the item or charging the User for such item; (ii) cancel the order for such item and notify the User of such cancellation; or (iii) ship the item at the incorrect price to the benefit of the User.

Please note that this policy regarding prices applies only to items sold and shipped by Barnes & Noble.com. Any purchases from any third-party sellers on the Barnes & Noble.com Site (e.g., sellers of products provided via Barnes & Noble BookQuest LLC) may be subject to different policies in the event of an incorrectly priced item.

This is from the site. So it really depends on gamestops pricing policy.
 
I really can't believe that this they'll charge 40 bucks for that stick and not notice the difference. They won't fuck you, though... that much I do believe.

Taken from gamestop website:

Pricing
All prices shown are in U.S. Dollars. Store pricing may vary. Pricing for some pre-orders may be estimated. If the price of a pre-order decreases between the time you place your order and the time it ships, you will be charged the lower price. If the price increases, you will be given the option to keep your order at the higher price or cancel it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom