NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.
Xaero Gravity said:
For now
Click to expand...

72nd.gif
 
That was the most pathetic display of attempted crybullying since Arkage Arkage . Cunt won't even hold himself to the standards he expects of everyone else and has the gall to demand censorship of well-earned jokes at his expense. Throw out an unsubstantiated claim to victimhood then refuse to provide evidence. Misrepresent criticism as being a function of your political alignment rather than your personality and rhetorical methods (never mind the fact that we have plenty of leftists who engage just fine because their arguments don't revolve entirely around Orange Man). Present jokes out of context in order to strawman and paint yourself as a victim in your appeal for authority to intervene. Just a pathetic display all around. "I'm not a Reeturner, I just got banned from there and came back here to use their tactics". The problem is you, mate. You never give an inch to anyone but expect them to give you a mile then cry when they don't.
 
EviLore said:
Our report search function searches by the person reported, not the person submitting the report, so we can't pull it up and won't look through three months worth of reports. It's going to fall to you to find it if you want to discuss the matter further.
Click to expand...

That's a shame. I would have expected xf to have a more featured ticketing system.

In any case, beyond the attempts to make this this about myself and not the situation of the forum, my point stands that the politics subforum has become, as you put it, hostile.

I said what I had to say.
 
Is and 3 others going to get resurrected? Thought his posts in here on the matter were pretty good. It definitely can be a tough line to straddle when you're devil's advocating a theoretical idea and actually advocating for something. To some of us it looked like a suggestion that animated violence was equivalent to animated CP but with that post explaining I think it's good he's getting reconsideration.

Bitmap Frogs Bitmap Frogs no one likes the persecution complex in the ban thread, it's a bad look when SONY/XBOX warriors do it and it's a bad look for political folks. Biden won and EviLore EviLore himself has said there was no fraud and Biden will be Prez, even to the point of kicking Compsiox Compsiox out of the politics section. Doesn't sound to me like the right wing echo chamber you believe it to be, but then your best evidence seems to be people posting memes in troll threads?
 
Piku_Ringo said:
Please understand Bitmap Frogs Bitmap Frogs has had his well being threatened due to his political views on here. So he's relayed to me. So maybe there is something to that board being waaay to hostile to certain users.
Click to expand...

Receipts required. I highly doubt based on the track record of moderation here that someone genuinely threatening bodily harm to another poster would be swept under the rug.

So either it never happened, or is being blown out of proportion by you for fake sympathy.

Bitmap Frogs said:
There cannot be a market of ideas when posting left means you're trolled out of the forum.
Click to expand...

Do you actually believe that? If leftist/progressive posters could stop consistently trolling and actually present a logic-based argument, they would have no problem easily fighting back in any thread they wade into. I certainly don't agree with some of the regulars on here, and feel no real pushback when I go against the grain in a thread. Who cares if people don't agree with you?

If you and a few others were actually the great persuaders of "the left", then anyone who argued differently would get stomped, looking foolish as they did so. If your arguments were unimpeachable, then their weak strawman attacks or "trolling" wouldn't do a damn thing, and your argument would stand.

Instead we get a new crop of disingenuous "leftist" posters every few months, after the current crop finally cross the Rubicon and account suicide when they say all the hateful, vile shit they have really wanted to say all along. The ones that seem to stick around are the ones that just throw supportive reactions to martyrs that actually say all the vile shit. Nobody is really fooled by someone like that playing coy. But hey, if it works, and is allowed, then I guess that's what a fervent ideologue has to do to fly under the radar.

Also, how can anyone on here even have the same politics, anyway? We're from all over the fucking place, and the political definitions vary so wildly from country to country that saying "left" or "right" means nothing online. You seem to get off on blanket trolling conservative US politics, for some reason, while I have no idea WTF you stand for or support within your own country.
 
Last edited:
Yuri Normus said:
This isn't as much an Account Suicide is it's a goodbye. I won't be here with an alt account pretending to not be me. So, after having my 'and 3 others' account permabanned, the only recourse was to email to someone @ GAF asking (nicely) for a reconsideration, which either didn't make it's way to a person, or fell on deaf ears.

Now, for those of you who were saying "I didn't know he was like that". I was in no way advocating; promoting, or arguing for CP. I was merely trying to get NI to argue where and why the line is set. For those who may know, I've been an avid lurker on GAF for a long time, and (was) a member for 10 months. As such, I've come to understand certain sections of GAF are policed more heavily. However, the day I was banned, I was just jumping around from section to section, and thread to thread.

I never heard, seen, or experienced any policy in which I ever thought me just asking a question like the one I did, would get me permayeeted. Add to the fact sometimes I like to push Nobody Important to see if I can find some of his cracks, as I find him one of the most disingenuous poster on GAF.

Normally I'd take the ban and slink off, but due to several instances in my life over the course of the last 2 weeks and social isolation, GAF felt even more like a community in which I belonged to. Furthering that feeling of isolation.

I would like to apologize to anyone who took offense to my posts, and to the mods who I respected, even when I thought they were to harsh (my circumstances included), and i apologize for making a new account, and this one being banned soon too.

I want to thank all the cool people I'd met here, and even those who I 100% disagreed with politically, a few of which in private messages, we were able to find common ground, and it humanized them outside of me just mocking them with a few words or pictures.

And to thank EviLore for 1) opening up non-paid email signups. Due to a long list of circumstances, I never got one, and therefore was never before able to sign up. And 2) for not buckling, and not giving up, and not selling GAF when the crazies tried to burn it down. Guess I'll just go back to lurking for another 10 years.

I shall now piss off into the sunset. Pray for me that I get a PlayStation 5 soon. Auf Wiedersehen.
Click to expand...

Your perm did feel kind of weird since from what I was reading, you weren't advocating for the creation of any kind of CP imagery. Like one guy asked you "why would anyone draw CP" which was pretty irrelevant to your post which was questioning whether someone had a right to do draw it, rather than it being morally correct in any way at all. I think it ties into some free speech type arguments / where the line is / etc. Obviously, GAF isn't a home for anything like that, but it did feel kind of trigger-happy to ban you for that without a warning of any kind.
 
I hope Yuri Normus stays, or mods allow to stay. He's a good guy in my books who looks like got too heated.

I didn't read in depth all that crap people were going back and forth on about CP as it seemed to be fueled in a couple threads. As a whole, all mention of that stuff should be capped asap.
 
Last edited:
It's always hilarious to me when a group of people feign innocence when a wrong was done. "Who backed their truck into the side of the building?"....Absolute silence from everyone in the room, knowing someone in the room had to have done it. Sometimes I will confess, even though I didn't do it, just to amuse myself and the guilty party.

Anyway, I will confess to the crime of threatening poor Bitmap Frogs Bitmap Frogs with images of violence this summer. Pretty sure he is referring to this picture.


iiu4R8R.jpg


I am truly sorry for my transgression. Please forgive me.
 
Yuri Normus said:
Now, for those of you who were saying "I didn't know he was like that". I was in no way advocating; promoting, or arguing for CP. I was merely trying to get NI to argue where and why the line is set. For those who may know, I've been an avid lurker on GAF for a long time, and (was) a member for 10 months. As such, I've come to understand certain sections of GAF are policed more heavily. However, the day I was banned, I was just jumping around from section to section, and thread to thread.

I never heard, seen, or experienced any policy in which I ever thought me just asking a question like the one I did, would get me permayeeted. Add to the fact sometimes I like to push Nobody Important to see if I can find some of his cracks, as I find him one of the most disingenuous poster on GAF.
Click to expand...
And I don't mind being pushed and prodded. (Obviously. Because I am still here) But man that was a really bad topic to try to argue for. Push me on pretty much anything if you want, but picking something that is so black and white and so against the rules (and the law) was just a really odd choice. It obviously (and apparently inadvertently) painted you in a bad light. If you truly have no interest in trying to defend child pornography no matter it's form and you were just try to push my buttons on a topic then I do hope that EviLore EviLore reconsiders your ban.
 
Piku_Ringo said:
You gotta let go of that hate in your heart, brosef.

AllTha Snackbars to you. :cool: :messenger_ok:
Click to expand...
WTF?

First of all, why are you even sticking your nose into what I said about him?

I didn't even mention you in this thread and now you're trying to sneak diss with that lame namecall?

I've seen your posts about me before I came back in November and how much shit you were saying about me.

Go fuck yourself, seriously.
 
Hey -Arcadia-, NeoGAF is going to be offline for a forum upgrade today starting at 7:00 PM EST (00:00 GMT) for approximately one hour. Don't panic!

You tell me not to panic, yet for a second I thought you were calling me out on top of the whole forum.
 
-Arcadia- said:
Hey -Arcadia-, NeoGAF is going to be offline for a forum upgrade today starting at 7:00 PM EST (00:00 GMT) for approximately one hour. Don't panic!

You tell me not to panic, yet for a second I thought you were calling me out on top of the whole forum.
Click to expand...
I can see it happening

Real Gaf hours isn't til after midnight anyway lol
 
-Arcadia- said:
Hey -Arcadia-, NeoGAF is going to be offline for a forum upgrade today starting at 7:00 PM EST (00:00 GMT) for approximately one hour. Don't panic!

You tell me not to panic, yet for a second I thought you were calling me out on top of the whole forum.
Click to expand...

You big dork, LMAO! :pie_roffles::messenger_ok:

Blast from the past when we had those ghost tags they disabled.
 
Last edited:
BlackOlivesMatter said:
If the hot dog had ketchup on it, now that's a bannable offense.

I believe he was 3others and EviLore EviLore tried to reach out with some terms for a possible return and didn't respond or wasn't agreeable, or something to that effect.
Click to expand...
That's exactly who he was and it felt like evilorrwas going to give him a second chance based on this thread but then he posted that. hey speaking of ketchup on hot dogs have you seen sudden impact with Clint Eastwood?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Snow & White | Review Thread
Community  2
80
5K
GymWolf replied
Feliz Navidad |NEOGAF|
19
736
Pyramid Song replied
Dark/light mode Neogaf feature request
20
719
Danknugz replied
Major Reddit Forums Ban X Links
News  2 3 4 5
213
13K
Bitmap Frogs replied
Help with neogaf website functionality. Constant freezes
2
64
2K
Major Insano replied
Top Bottom