NeoGAF Fantasy Football Paypal League (Season 3)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Crazymoogle said:
lol yeah. At first I was "wow, 2nd pick!" but in a 16 teamer, fuckkkk -_-;;

Yeah really, I didn't get nearly any of what I was hoping for in my 12 team league and I picked 12th. The couple of people who for some reason decided autodraft sucked up players I wanted that I didn't think others would really pick. Blah.

I'm looking a lot better in my 8 team pay league.
 
no one gives a fuck, but...

Economy League (12 team league):
1. (7) LeSean McCoy RB
2. (18) Roddy White WR
3. (31) Ahmad Bradshaw RB
4. (42) Dallas Clark TE
5. (55) Knowshon Moreno RB
6. (66) BenJarvus Green-Ellis RB
7. (79) Chad Ochocinco WR
8. (90) Josh Freeman QB
9. (103) Malcom Floyd WR
10. (114) Chicago DEF
11. (127) Ryan Fitzpatrick QB
12. (138) Earl Bennett WR
13. (151) Marion Barber RB
14. (162) Jason Snelling RB


No Quitters 3 (16 team league):
1. (9) LeSean McCoy RB
2. (24) Hakeem Nicks WR
3. (41) Dallas Clark TE
4. (56) Jahvid Best RB
5. (73) Chad Ochocinco WR
6. (88) Santana Moss WR
7. (105) Kevin Kolb QB
8. (120) Lee Evans WR
9. (137) Thomas Jones RB
10. (152) Jason Snelling RB
11. (169) Chicago DEF
12. (184) David Garrard QB
13. (201) Visanthe Shiancoe TE
14. (216) Adam Vinatieri K
15. (233) Chad Henne QB
 
Finally got done with the most brutal draft ever. 16 team $50 GAF league.

QB: Joe Flacco
RB: Jamaal Charles
RB: Ahmad Bradshaw
WR: Greg Jennings
WR: Steve Johnson
TE: Vernon Davis
WR/RB: Lance Moore
D/ST: Cincinnati
K: Rob Bironas
Bench: Danny Woodhead, Jacoby Ford, Ryan Torain, Javone Bess, Derrick Mason, Jason Campbell

Every team's bench is LOL in this league.
 
No Quitters 3

1. (7) Michael Vick , QB
2. (26) Felix Jones , RB
3. (39) Antonio Gates , TE
4. (58) Brandon Lloyd , WR
5. (71) Percy Harvin , WR
6. (90) Julio Jones , WR
7. (103) LaDainian Tomlinson , RB
8. (122) New York Giants , DEF
9. (135) Delone Carter , RB
10. (154) Devin Hester , WR
11. (167) James Jones , WR
12. (186) Robbie Gould , K
13. (199) Tashard Choice , RB
14. (218) Brandon Gibson , WR
15. (231) Alex Smith , QB

My plan was to get great RB value in the later rounds, but I was seeming poached of SO MANY RBs it's amazing. If I could've had Bradshaw/Jones, I would've been so happy. now I'm going to have to fight/scratch on the waiver wire and pray I don't have an injury to Vick early. I'm happy with the WR value I have, even if Lloyd is not an elite WR he'll still be ok w/ Orton there and the Falcons invested too much not to push Juilo Jones.
 
Round Pick Player Position
1. (16) Philip Rivers QB
2. (17) Matt Forte RB
3. (48) Ryan Mathews RB
4. (49) Mike Tolbert RB
5. (80) Pierre Garcon WR
6. (81) Malcom Floyd WR
7. (112) Aaron Hernandez TE
8. (113) Nate Burleson WR
9. (144) Eddie Royal WR
10. (145) Justin Forsett RB
11. (176) Brent Celek TE
12. (177) Tennessee DEF
13. (208) Donald Driver WR
14. (209) Donald Brown RB
15. (240) Lawrence Tynes K

Not terrible but I make a strategic mistake with my Matthews/Tolbert B2B. I could probably have got Tolbert later and snagged a top-flight WR instead. I feel good about getting Driver that low though and Forsett is still better all-around than Lynch IMO.
 
I'm not going to post my rosters in this thread because you guys were there when I drafted them. :D

Props to Bail Kings for scoring the big Toyota projection award!

Cloudy said:
Not terrible but I make a strategic mistake with my Matthews/Tolbert B2B. I could probably have got Tolbert later and snagged a top-flight WR instead. I feel good about getting Driver that low though and Forsett is still better all-around than Lynch IMO.
I doubt you could have picked up Tolbert 30+ picks later.
Yahoo has him rated ahead of Mathews right now.
 
1. (11) Aaron Rodgers QB
2. (22) Frank Gore RB
3. (43) Dwayne Bowe WR
4. (54) Knowshon Moreno RB
5. (75) Austin Collie WR
6. (86) Fred Jackson RB
7. (107) Marcedes Lewis TE
8. (118) Johnny Knox WR
9. (139) Ronnie Brown RB
10. (150) Matt Cassel QB
11. (171) New Orleans DEF
12. (182) Sebastian Janikowski K
13. (203) Jamie Harper RB
14. (214) Kevin Walter WR
15. (235) Carnell Williams RB

Overally pretty happy with it. A lot of my bench productivity is predicated on injuries.
 
Azwethinkweiz said:
Overally pretty happy with it. A lot of my bench productivity is predicated on injuries.

wow your team has a tooooon of potential injury problems based on the last few seasons.
 
Ember Island Players

1. (13) Michael Turner RB
2. (20) Darren McFadden RB
3. (45) Matt Schaub QB
4. (52) Mike Williams WR
5. (77) Brandon Jacobs RB
6. (84) A.J. Green WR
7. (109) Greg Olsen TE
8. (116) New England DEF
9. (141) Jay Cutler QB
10. (148) Nate Kaeding K
11. (173) Jacoby Jones WR
12. (180) Andre Roberts WR
13. (205) LaRod Stephens-Howling RB
14.(212) Houston DEF
15. (237) David Buehler K

The Turner-McFadden combo could potentially get really nice, but it's definitely nowhere near the team I had last year. Unless someone really breaks out, most of my bench picks (aka the extra DEF and K) are just going to be used as fill-ins for the starters bye weeks then I'm dropping them. Took a gamble on A.J. Green and I hope that pays off.
 
And I have already made the first move!


Romo Wittenhispants
1. Rashard Mendenhall (Pit - RB)
2. Peyton Hillis (Cle - RB)
3. Peyton Manning (Ind - QB)
4. Matthew Stafford (Det - QB)
5. Kenny Britt (Ten - WR)
6. Green Bay (GB - DEF)
7. Danny Amendola (StL - WR)
8. Sidney Rice (Sea - WR)
9. Dustin Keller (NYJ - TE)
10. Mike Williams (Sea - WR)
11. Dexter McCluster (KC - WR,RB)
12. Jermaine Gresham (Cin - TE)
13. Kansas City (KC - DEF)
14. Anthony Dixon (SF - RB)
15. David Akers (SF - K)
 
acksman said:
And I have already made the first move!


Romo Wittenhispants
1. Rashard Mendenhall (Pit - RB)
2. Peyton Hillis (Cle - RB)
3. Peyton Manning (Ind - QB)
4. Matthew Stafford (Det - QB)
5. Kenny Britt (Ten - WR)
6. Green Bay (GB - DEF)
7. Danny Amendola (StL - WR)
8. Sidney Rice (Sea - WR)
9. Dustin Keller (NYJ - TE)
10. Mike Williams (Sea - WR)
11. Dexter McCluster (KC - WR,RB)
12. Jermaine Gresham (Cin - TE)
13. Kansas City (KC - DEF)
14. Anthony Dixon (SF - RB)
15. David Akers (SF - K)

I'm up against you first week. I'm predicted to lose.... but then again they have Hillis getting 16 points. Doubt that.
 
rinker said:
no one gives a fuck, but...

Economy League (12 team league):
1. (7) LeSean McCoy RB
2. (18) Roddy White WR
3. (31) Ahmad Bradshaw RB
4. (42) Dallas Clark TE
5. (55) Knowshon Moreno RB
6. (66) BenJarvus Green-Ellis RB
7. (79) Chad Ochocinco WR
8. (90) Josh Freeman QB
9. (103) Malcom Floyd WR
10. (114) Chicago DEF
11. (127) Ryan Fitzpatrick QB
12. (138) Earl Bennett WR
13. (151) Marion Barber RB
14. (162) Jason Snelling RB


No Quitters 3 (16 team league):
1. (9) LeSean McCoy RB
2. (24) Hakeem Nicks WR
3. (41) Dallas Clark TE
4. (56) Jahvid Best RB
5. (73) Chad Ochocinco WR
6. (88) Santana Moss WR
7. (105) Kevin Kolb QB
8. (120) Lee Evans WR
9. (137) Thomas Jones RB
10. (152) Jason Snelling RB
11. (169) Chicago DEF
12. (184) David Garrard QB
13. (201) Visanthe Shiancoe TE
14. (216) Adam Vinatieri K
15. (233) Chad Henne QB


Did he get traded? Why so early in the draft to take him?

Just curious..


I do like ur econ draft
 
I'm pretty sure that my group of RB1, RB2, WR1, WR2 and TE is the best in the league going off projections (which mean little). I feel confident that no one has a group as good as Charles, Bradshaw, Jennings, Steve Johnson and Vernon Davis, which is good, because if Joe Flacco is even a top 13 QB I'll be lucky. Nobody really has a great flex in this league. But I'm really counting on Flacco to be adequate.
 
Not sure who to start in my econ league for RB's. Not thrilled with any of them but this is what happens when you go WR,WR,QB and have the 12th turn and RB's go fast.

Ingram vs. GB
Tolbert vs MIN
Hightower vs NYG
McGahee vs OAK
Starks vs NO
Bush vs DEN
 
minx88 said:
Not sure who to start in my econ league for RB's. Not thrilled with any of them but this is what happens when you go WR,WR,QB and have the 12th turn and RB's go fast.

Ingram vs. GB
Tolbert vs MIN
Hightower vs NYG
McGahee vs OAK
Starks vs NO
Bush vs DEN
If you put a gun to my head right now I'd say start Ingram and McGahee but you should really wait for the weekly rankings in the next couple days.
 
Looking back over the No Quitters results, I'm amazed that the top 8 quarterbacks plus Matt Ryan were all off the board by the middle of the 3rd.
 
UberTag said:
If you put a gun to my head right now I'd say start Ingram and McGahee but you should really wait for the weekly rankings in the next couple days.

Starting 3 btw. Yahoo has them all with 5-8 points. I'll be in Vegas from Thursday through Sunday. Don't think I can play Starks as I'll be betting on NO.
 
minx88 said:
Starting 3 btw. Yahoo has them all with 5-8 points. I'll be in Vegas from Thursday through Sunday. Don't think I can play Starks as I'll be betting on NO.


Is Starks starting? I have Grant in a league..


I like hightower for one of ur RB's to start.


Have fun in Vegas and bet early. Lines take forever and the teaser cards are the best
 
minx88 said:
Starting 3 btw. Yahoo has them all with 5-8 points. I'll be in Vegas from Thursday through Sunday. Don't think I can play Starks as I'll be betting on NO.
Roll with Hightower, McGahee and Ingram then.
 
Figured i'd post this here since the football thread has been fairly anti fantasy. This is my team for my private 10 man league (first pick).

Shaub

Peterson

Forte

Matthews

Fitzgerald

Maclin

V. Davis

Rackers

I'm very happy with my draft but I'm contemplating switching Ryan Matthews out with Santana Moss for the flex. I have feeling tolbert will kill his production.
 
Puddles said:
Looking back over the No Quitters results, I'm amazed that the top 8 quarterbacks plus Matt Ryan were all off the board by the middle of the 3rd.
Happens every year. At first people go for value, but it's a 16 teamer - if you wait on your QB you'll find nothing left. I mean, besides TJack I'm not sure there is a starting QB on the waiver wire. Even Alex Smith got drafted!
 
Crazymoogle said:
Happens every year. At first people go for value, but it's a 16 teamer - if you wait on your QB you'll find nothing left. I mean, besides TJack I'm not sure there is a starting QB on the waiver wire. Even Alex Smith got drafted!
I'm hoping not drafting a backup QB will work out and just pick up a waiver wire wonder after an injury happens to someone.
 
With 16 teams, I think it's easy to get into an ADP-value mental trap. When my 2nd round pick came up, I didn't think that Romo, Big Ben or Schaub represented good value for the slot. But with 16 teams, you can get completely fucked at the QB position, especially when you have douchebags like Romo Wittenhispants taking 2 QBs in their top four (my strategy was to get Stafford in the 4th).
 
Puddles said:
With 16 teams, I think it's easy to get into an ADP-value mental trap. When my 2nd round pick came up, I didn't think that Romo, Big Ben or Schaub represented good value for the slot. But with 16 teams, you can get completely fucked at the QB position, especially when you have douchebags like Romo Wittenhispants taking 2 QBs in their top four (my strategy was to get Stafford in the 4th).

Why thank ya! Since I went with Manning and hes hurt needed an immediate playable QB, plus part of that is for trading purposes if needed.
 
minx88 said:
I'm hoping not drafting a backup QB will work out and just pick up a waiver wire wonder after an injury happens to someone.

I think that will eventually happen - I took Hasselbeck more because of an early bye week than anything else - but for future seasons I do recommend a shorter bench. With so many teams a shorter bench prevents stashing that kills any waiver wire activity, in turn forcing us to make real decisions.


acksman said:
Why thank ya! Since I went with Manning and hes hurt needed an immediate playable QB, plus part of that is for trading purposes if needed.

Agreed, absolutely the right move since Peyton's early season is compromised. The trick for you is simply that you're going to have dormant value that needs to be dealt.
 
Alright Fantasy-GAF, as a total newbie to fantasy in joining a work-league this year, I could really use a little help in a surprising big early decision.

Skill position-wise, I wound up coming out of my draft with Michael Vick, Adrian Peterson and Steven Jackson as my RBs, and some combination of Dwayne Bowe, Jeremy Maclin, Kenny Britt and Nate Burleson as my main wideouts. I was fairly satisfied with it overall, but I feel like my WR core is a weakness right now, and another guy in the league REALLY wants Vick. This wound up bringing a third guy to the table and after some deliberation back and forth, here's the deal that he's proposing:

I give up: Vick, AP, and Maclin

Receiving in return: Aaron Rodgers, Vincent Jackson, and Rashard Mendenhall

A lot of big pieces move around in this, and it's tempting. I have more faith in Rodgers' consistency than I do Vick's, and if Ken Britt manages to keep himself in good standing then having him, Vincent Jackson and Bowe would give me the most lethal receiving corps in my league. Going from AP to Mendenhall is obviously a downgrade, but probably not as big of a hit as what I would gain at QB and WR...yet for some reason I'm really, really hesitant to deal what is right now the surest thing on my team.

I've been pondering over this thing all day and neither answer seems clear to me, even still.
 
Doorman said:
Alright Fantasy-GAF, as a total newbie to fantasy in joining a work-league this year, I could really use a little help in a surprising big early decision.

Skill position-wise, I wound up coming out of my draft with Michael Vick, Adrian Peterson and Steven Jackson as my RBs, and some combination of Dwayne Bowe, Jeremy Maclin, Kenny Britt and Nate Burleson as my main wideouts. I was fairly satisfied with it overall, but I feel like my WR core is a weakness right now, and another guy in the league REALLY wants Vick. This wound up bringing a third guy to the table and after some deliberation back and forth, here's the deal that he's proposing:

I give up: Vick, AP, and Maclin

Receiving in return: Aaron Rodgers, Vincent Jackson, and Rashard Mendenhall



A lot of big pieces move around in this, and it's tempting. I have more faith in Rodgers' consistency than I do Vick's, and if Ken Britt manages to keep himself in good standing then having him, Vincent Jackson and Bowe would give me the most lethal receiving corps in my league. Going from AP to Mendenhall is obviously a downgrade, but probably not as big of a hit as what I would gain at QB and WR...yet for some reason I'm really, really hesitant to deal what is right now the surest thing on my team.

I've been pondering over this thing all day and neither answer seems clear to me, even still.



I like this trade. Got a QB and WR in a pass friendly team IMO and Pitt loves to run
 
Crazymoogle said:
Happens every year. At first people go for value, but it's a 16 teamer - if you wait on your QB you'll find nothing left. I mean, besides TJack I'm not sure there is a starting QB on the waiver wire. Even Alex Smith got drafted!
Three Week 1 starting QBs remain on the waiver wire now that Sexy Rexy was snapped up by Peyton's Creaky Neck to back up Rivers in Week 6 (Grossman is at home against Nnamdi and the Eagles... it won't be pretty... and that's even if he's starting at that point and not Beck):

Kerry Collins
Tarvaris Jackson
Andy Dalton

Puddles said:
With 16 teams, I think it's easy to get into an ADP-value mental trap. When my 2nd round pick came up, I didn't think that Romo, Big Ben or Schaub represented good value for the slot. But with 16 teams, you can get completely fucked at the QB position, especially when you have douchebags like Romo Wittenhispants taking 2 QBs in their top four (my strategy was to get Stafford in the 4th).
I expected QB scarcity after reviewing your draft from last year. Main reason I scooped up McCoy so quickly in the 9th. I wanted nothing to do with any other starting QB as far as backups go.

What surprised me more than anything was how quickly all of my sleeper receivers were pillaged. Was not expecting to be so thin at that position post-draft but thankfully that's the easiest position to salvage via the waiver wire.

Crazymoogle said:
I think that will eventually happen - I took Hasselbeck more because of an early bye week than anything else - but for future seasons I do recommend a shorter bench. With so many teams a shorter bench prevents stashing that kills any waiver wire activity, in turn forcing us to make real decisions.
Given the number of bye week headaches we all have, I would have actually preferred a deeper bench. I thought the draft was fascinating and was thrilled to see everyone taking their time to think their picks through so meticulously. Should portend to a competitive season. I'm really looking forward to it.
 
Doorman said:
This wound up bringing a third guy to the table and after some deliberation back and forth, here's the deal that he's proposing:

I give up: Vick, AP, and Maclin

Receiving in return: Aaron Rodgers, Vincent Jackson, and Rashard Mendenhall
I love this deal for you and really the only variable that comes to mind for me is a potential downturn for Mendenhall's numbers given his 420+ touches last season. This isn't nearly as big of a red flag as Maclin's mysterious health issues, but it's still worth noting.

If you have the bench depth, pick up Isaac Redman for insurance after making this trade.
 
Help me out here.

Thinking of going Maurice Jones-Drew and Desean Jackson in return I get Greg Jennings and Felix Jones.

my team

Qb- Drew Brees
wr- Desean Jackson, Santonio Holmes, Marrio Manningham
Rb- Adrian Peterson, Maurice Jones-Drew
w/r- Beanie Wells
Bench- Boldin, Brandon Marshall, Ryan Matthews, Brandon Jacobs, Lee Evans, Ryan Grant

Either that or I'll trade Jackson and Holmes for Andre Johnson and move Marshall in to a starting spot.
 
If you post your team and do not post:

The size of your league.

A few scoring details (PPR, points per passing TD, etc.)

Your draft position.



....how can you expect anyone to chime in on your results?
 
msdstc said:
Help me out here.

Thinking of going Maurice Jones-Drew and Desean Jackson in return I get Greg Jennings and Felix Jones.

my team

Qb- Drew Brees
wr- Desean Jackson, Santonio Holmes, Marrio Manningham
Rb- Adrian Peterson, Maurice Jones-Drew
w/r- Beanie Wells
Bench- Boldin, Brandon Marshall, Ryan Matthews, Brandon Jacobs, Lee Evans, Ryan Grant

Either that or I'll trade Jackson and Holmes for Andre Johnson and move Marshall in to a starting spot.

You should be starting Marshall, no questions asked, over Manningham.

I would also give Mathews the start over Wells with Chester now in the mix in AZ.

You're team's strength is clearly at WR. Boldin off the bench as your bye week, flex or weekly match up option is a nice luxury.

Therefore, I'm suggesting that you do not make this trade. Jennings is a streaky WR for fantasy. Look at the first half of last season. Before their week 9 bye he had 6 TDs, which is great. However, during that time he had only one 100 yard game, which is shit. The TDs offset his actual production. Over those first 9 weeks he averaged 4 catches and 58 yards a game. With what you already have on your team, that's not worth giving up MJD for.
 
Oh sweet, Yahoo said I had the best draft in NQ3?

lol I could absolutely see a reason to start Manningham over Marshall. It's called Henne. Look, based on sheer talent I think Marshall has much better upside, but damn, he had a lot of lean weeks last year, and now it's the Pats strolling into town.

Beyond that I totally agree; I would rather have MJD over Felix at this time, and Greg had a serious questionmark about how he performs if all of the other receiving options are in the lineup. I mean, people can be down on DJax if they like but he's got Vick tossing to him...
 
Crazymoogle said:
Oh sweet, Yahoo said I had the best draft in NQ3?

lol I could absolutely see a reason to start Manningham over Marshall. It's called Henne. Look, based on sheer talent I think Marshall has much better upside, but damn, he had a lot of lean weeks last year, and now it's the Pats strolling into town.

Beyond that I totally agree; I would rather have MJD over Felix at this time, and Greg had a serious questionmark about how he performs if all of the other receiving options are in the lineup. I mean, people can be down on DJax if they like but he's got Vick tossing to him...

hmmm now I'm not so sure which way to go. MJD's stock went up when Rashad went down, but I'm really low on Desean this year. I need to get something in return for him, and that's why I feel my WR depth is a strength in the trade market.

GQman2121 said:
You should be starting Marshall, no questions asked, over Manningham.

I would also give Mathews the start over Wells with Chester now in the mix in AZ.

You're team's strength is clearly at WR. Boldin off the bench as your bye week, flex or weekly match up option is a nice luxury.

edit-

Therefore, I'm suggesting that you do not make this trade. Jennings is a streaky WR for fantasy. Look at the first half of last season. Before their week 9 bye he had 6 TDs, which is great. However, during that time he had only one 100 yard game, which is shit. The TDs offset his actual production. Over those first 9 weeks he averaged 4 catches and 58 yards a game. With what you already have on your team, that's not worth giving up MJD for.

Matthews over wells? I dunno I'm pretty high on Beanie this year. Chester Taylor is old, I think he's more of an insurance pickup.
 
msdstc, the team seems fine I don't see why you would trade. Bench is as solid as can be too. Seems like a very lateral trade, with you given up the higher ADP (Average draft pick) for I guess players you prefer?
 
Milabrega said:
msdstc, the team seems fine I don't see why you would trade. Bench is as solid as can be too. Seems like a very lateral trade, with you given up the higher ADP (Average draft pick) for I guess players you prefer?

I have a ton of WR depth, and I love my RBs, but I would rather a better number 1 receiver. I feel like I could put Marshall, Holmes, and Manningham almost interchangeably. So I feel like trade off some of the depth for more valuable starting receivers overall. Both times reap benefits, but I would feel more comfortable with a top tier Receiver on my team to round it off.

How about Desean Jackson and Santonio Holmes for an elite reciever? That would leave.

1. WR1 (Calvin Johnson, Andre Johnson, Vincent Jackson, etc.)
2. Brandon Marshall
3. Manningham

Boldin as the alternate.
 
GQman2121 said:
You're team's strength is clearly at WR.

AP and a healthy MJD are a brutal 1-2 at RB. I'd say that's his team's biggest strength. He doesn't have a true #1 WR, but he has three very capable #2s.

Also, I wouldn't trade Andre Johnson or Megatron for two #2 WRs, but if you can find an owner who takes that trade, go for it.
 
UberTag said:
Three Week 1 starting QBs remain on the waiver wire now that Sexy Rexy was snapped up by Peyton's Creaky Neck to back up Rivers in Week 6 (Grossman is at home against Nnamdi and the Eagles... it won't be pretty... and that's even if he's starting at that point and not Beck):

Kerry Collins
Tarvaris Jackson
Andy Dalton

Tavaris has been picked up too! I didn't want to take a backup QB but the hoarding forced me into it. Better to take Rex now than get stuck having to make a lopsided trade in Week 6 lol
 
Code:
The Sexy Rexs (NeoGAF Economy League)
Round	Pick	Player	              Position
1.	(10)	Aaron Rodgers	        QB
2.	(15)	Maurice Jones-Drew	RB
3.	(34)	LeGarrette Blount	RB
4.	(39)	Brandon Marshall	WR
5.	(58)	Anquan Boldin	        WR
6.	(63)	Vernon Davis	        TE
7.	(82)	Brandon Jacobs	        RB
8.	(87)	Mike Thomas	        WR
9.	(106)	New York	        DEF
10.	(111)	Plaxico Burress 	WR
11.	(130)	Danny Woodhead          RB
12.	(135)	Colt McCoy	        QB
13.	(154)	Michael Crabtree	WR
14.	(159)	Dustin Keller	        TE
Might as well post my picks.
 
Just had my draft in a 12-team, standard scoring league. Would like some feedback.

1. (9) Michael Turner (Atl - RB)
2. (16) Hakeem Nicks (NYG - WR)
3. (33) Miles Austin (Dal - WR)
4. (40) Matt Schaub (Hou - QB)
5. (57) Jermichael Finley (GB - TE)
6. (64) Tim Hightower (Was - RB)
7. (81) Fred Jackson (Buf - RB)
8. (88) Malcom Floyd (SD - WR)
9. (105) Braylon Edwards (SF - WR)
10. (112) Thomas Jones (KC - RB)
11. (129) Kyle Orton (Den - QB)
12. (136) New England (NE - DEF)
13. (153) Ronnie Brown (Phi - RB)
14. (160) Todd Heap (Ari - TE)
15. (177) Derrick Mason (NYJ - WR)
16. (184) David Akers (SF - K)
17. (201) Denarius Moore (Oak - WR)

I like Mike Turner but DMC was also available...feel like I may regret that pick.
 
The Frankman said:
No Quitters 3



My plan was to get great RB value in the later rounds, but I was seeming poached of SO MANY RBs it's amazing. If I could've had Bradshaw/Jones, I would've been so happy. now I'm going to have to fight/scratch on the waiver wire and pray I don't have an injury to Vick early. I'm happy with the WR value I have, even if Lloyd is not an elite WR he'll still be ok w/ Orton there and the Falcons invested too much not to push Juilo Jones.

You gave up a lot at RB and WR to get Vick and Gates. It depends on a lot of things. If Brandon Lloyd has a repeat of last year, you should be fine at every position except RB2. And it's very possible that Vick and Gates will win a few games for you themselves.
 
Puddles said:
You gave up a lot at RB and WR to get Vick and Gates. It depends on a lot of things. If Brandon Lloyd has a repeat of last year, you should be fine at every position except RB2. And it's very possible that Vick and Gates will win a few games for you themselves.
That's the thing that kills me. In this thread I have said the point of FF is picking a team that minimalizes risk yet gives you the best chances to win. I also believe you win a league by winning Week to Week, and trading players a lot more frequently than most. That's what kills me about my pick, not only did I spend 3-4 months talking about Vick will come back to Earth bigtime, I had to build a team that is the opposite of my normal strategy. Most of my WR core is risky, but it's deep. I also really like the sleepers I have.
 
Red Blaster said:
Just had my draft in a 12-team, standard scoring league. Would like some feedback.

Is this Yahoo standard or ESPN standard? You've got:

QB: Schaub/Orton (a good compromise)
WR: Nicks/Austin/Floyd/Braylon/Mason/Moore (Two good receivers and some gambles)
RB: Turner/Hightower/Jackson/TJ/Brown (One great RB, a couple of job-at-risk borderline RB2s, and filler)

So your big problem is RB. You have backups, but not lottery tickets. Neither guy is as likely to become a starter as a lot of the other tickets on guys with injury histories or recent shaky performances. On WR, I'd argue Floyd and Braylon are about equally as likely to do anything, although you'll probably end up frustrated with both. I'd also argue you picked defense way too early considering the rank, but if you like em, stick with it. (Nonetheless, HT and Jackson that late is not too shabby.)

My advice is pretty simple: be ready to cut loose Mason, Moore, Brown, and Jones the instant anything interesting comes along. In a 12 teamer, these guys are probably going to top out as waiver players. (Moore has upside, but he's WR3. On the Raiders.) The most upside I see of those guys is Brown, and that's only if McCoy is KOed early in the season.
 
16 Team- No Quitters
Ku Klux Klams
Round Pick Player Position
1. (3) Chris Johnson RB
2. (30) Miles Austin WR
3. (35) Reggie Wayne WR
4. (62) Beanie Wells RB
5. (67) Brandon Marshall WR
6. (94) Willis McGahee RB
7. (99) Sam Bradford QB
8. (126) C.J. Spiller RB
9. (131) Ryan Fitzpatrick QB
10. (158) Antonio Brown WR
11. (163) Chris Cooley TE
12. (190) San Diego DEF
13. (195) Bernard Berrian WR
14. (222) Derrick Ward RB
15. (227) Anthony Armstrong

I liked my draft except that I autopicked Reggie Wayne in the 3rd. Not bad value but I would of went for Bradshaw in a heartbeat. Luckily Beanie fell in the 4th and should make a decent #2. Marshall and McGahee are solid flex plays, both have potential. QBs got drafted early and I was hesitant to pick one early and ended up with Bradeford which I I'm not a big fan but McDaniels turned Orton in a fantasy starter so there is potential there. Fitzpatrick had a great year and should be solid as a backup.

It was strange drafting with so many people, the biggest I had done before was 12. You definitely need to jump on someone early instead of hoping they come back to you. Most had a good a draft and there is no clear cut favorite. Thursday can't come soon enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom