About the Peyton Manning post-season record, you really can't say "small sample size" or "shit happens in the NFL". We're talking about 12 seasons where he went to the playoffs. That's a huge sample size in the NFL. Most careers aren't that long, and championship windows are even shorter. If that's not a large enough sample size, than nothing is. You can literally declare every outcome in the NFL a product of random chance. Even if you lop off 3 of those one and done seasons where let's say it wasn't really a championship caliber team anyway, that's still a long time. Overall 9-8, barely over .500 and some of those performances in the L's were very bad. Hell, he threw 3 touchdowns to 7 interceptions the post-season they won it all. And we make fun of Joe Flacco and Trent Dilfer for being carried to rings by their defenses? The bottom line is this guy is a fraud in the playoffs. He may the best regular season QB of all time, but he stinks up the joint in the playoffs. Buyer beware.
When reading that, keep in mind I said this earlier,