What to Watch For: Carolina Panthers
Offense
The Right Guard Position – Honestly, I could have named this “The Right Side of the Offensive Line,” as both G and T are shaky on that side. However, seeing as the Panthers cut Geoff Hangartner, the presumed starter at RG, last week, this is the position that warrants the most scrutiny. I was surprised by the move considering Hangartner’s ability to backup all three interior OL positions, so initially I thought it was a precursor to the immediate signing of a veteran G (Travelle Wharton, who had played with the Panthers previously and came in for a visit after being cut by Cincinnati recently, or potentially Brandon Moore), but that looks to not be the case. It seems the team is going to give Garry Williams, who was slated to be the starting RG two years ago before suffering a season-ending injury, will be given every opportunity to lock up the starting gig. And it seems the team has a lot of faith in 4th round DII rookie Edmund Kugbila, who injured his knee in OTAs then promptly injured his hamstring the first day of training camp (and as a result, has missed all of OTAs and training camp to date), as a quality backup. I’m skeptical, and personally, I think the answer at RG is still lurking in free agency. If I had to guess, the team will go through preseason with what they’ve got on hand and wait out Wharton until he’s willing to accept a vet min offer.
The Third Wide Receiver – As incredible as it seems, it looks as if Armanti Edwards may have pole position on the #3 WR spot ahead of Ted Ginn and Dominik Hixon. Edwards, the former Appalachian State QB/folk hero turned WR, has to this point in his career been presumed a bust (drafted in the 3rd round by Marty Hurney, who gave up a 2nd round pick for the opportunity to do it). However, by all accounts, he’s had his best camp to date and has been consistently flashing in OTAs and practices, to the point that Rivera has already said he’s earned a spot on the team. He had a gorgeous over the shoulder TD catch in live scrimmage at FanFest on Saturday between double coverage as well. Ginn has played well in camp too, but the book seems to be the same – blazing fast speed, can make difficult catches, but seems to lack the concentration needed for the easiest of catches. Still, if I had to guess, the WR depth chart 1-4 is going to be Smith/LaFell/Edwards/Ginn. We’ll probably keep Hixon and one of Pilares/Adams/Gettis as well.
Can Cam Step Up in Year 3? – A lot of brouhaha has surrounded Cam his first two years in the league. There have been incredible highs (passing/rushing records) and nadirs (Giants stomping and his reaction, pass into the dirt on 4th and goal vs Seattle, 2-12 record in games decided by a TD or less). I maintain that Cam has unfairly received a lot of the blame for losses due to blunders by the defense and Ron Rivera (Haruki Nakamura anyone?), but this season, it’s time to put up or shut up for Cam. He’s got to lead the Panthers to a winning record this year.
Defense
The Shaky Secondary – When healthy, I would put the Panthers front seven up against any other team in the league. Johnson, D. Edwards, Hardy, Kuechly, Davis, and Beason, along with newcomers (Death)Star Lotulelei, Kawann Short, AJ Klein, and Chase Blackburn give us an experienced and deep front seven. They’ll need to generate tremendous pressure, however, to mask the deficiencies in the secondary. Currently, the opening day secondary looks to be Drayton Florence/Mike Mitchell/Charles Godfrey/Captain Munnerlyn. Other than Godfrey, who’s been fairly inconsistent himself, it’s a mixture of castoffs and guys better suited to be backups/nickels. The Panthers have to hope that Mitchell can capitalize on the potential that made him a former 2nd round pick and that 2nd year CB Josh Norman can live up to his mouth. The secondary, along with the offensive line, are the two weak points on the Panthers that could hold them back from making the playoffs this season.
Special Teams
Nothing much to report here – Brad Nortman is still the Punter (sadly – he’s not very good). Ginn will be returning kickoffs (and punts, if Adams gets cut) and should offer a boost to the dreck the Panthers have had back there the past few years. Gano will be the Kicker to start the season, but given his history, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Panthers end up making a change later in the season.
Wild Card - Health and Depth
As I touched on earlier, when healthy, I feel that the Panthers have a playoff roster. However, health has eluded them for the past few years, and sadly, things look to be more of the same so far this year. Two key cogs, Beason and Stewart, have yet to participate in offseason activities, and a third, Thomas Davis, is generally healthy but has been held out of team contact drills as a precaution (probably a good idea with a guy who's torn the same ACL three consecutive times in a 2-year span). Additionally, and concurrently, depth will be paramount. I'm comfortable with Klein and Blackburn backing up Davis and Beason, and the Panthers will be fine without Stewart if it comes to it with Williams and Tolbert (personally, I think Williams actually fares better the more carries he gets), but offensive line depth is next to nonexistent and if a guy like Kalil or Gross goes down, the season probably goes down with them.
*phew* Sorry for the wall of text. Excited for this season and hope Cam and the Panthers can finally quiet the haters. The schedule looks daunting, but I think the Panthers actually caught a break by getting Seattle at home Week 1…cross country trip, early game, injuries to Seattle’s defensive line and receiving corps, it just seems like the Panthers are catching them at the best possible time.