Now, if youll indulge, a few personal thoughts for perspective and full disclosures sake: I played baseball at North Carolina during the time of this academic scandal and took an AFAM course, albeit a normal one, where attendance and work were required. I was a low-rung player in a non-revenue sports program, but I hung in the same circles as a lot higher-profile UNC athletes. Never once did I hear about paper courses or this rampant academic fraud. Today, sitting here shocked at the revelations, Im trying to figure out how thats possible and trying to digest the culture of cheating thats now being ubiquitously assigned to UNC student-athletes.
Its difficult, but heres how something like this can run so wild for so long: Academic fraud is the white-collar crime of college sports scandals. It happens behind closed doors, with a few power players driving the business, and people dont talk about it. The numbers on the whole are staggering 3,100 students, almost half of them athletes and the tendency is to believe this was everywhere, but it wasnt. Over 18 years and 28 varsity sports programs, it comes out to about three athletes per team per year (obviously thats just an average, as more football and hoops players than that were involved and some programs probably had none). Academic counselors dont, in my experience, talk about other students course schedules, and getting free grades isnt something players brag about. If they discuss it at all, its in tight, private circles. Nobody is flaunting a free B+ through the locker room, and nobody would think to ask about it. If a teammate is on the team, he must be eligible, and thats where that ends for players.
The non-academic NCAA rule violations that get the bulk of attention in college sports are much easier to detect and expose, because theyre so visible. You know where you can get cheaper, if not free, food. You know which bar owners will pick up tabs because athletes bring crowds and are good for business. If youre a pro prospect in a sport with a booming professional league, I assume you know where to get in contact with an adviser. You know which boosters hang around the program more closely than others and offer things. All of this is in the open and stuff college-aged kids are likely to brag to their friends about. Academic cheating doesnt work like that.
North Carolinas integrity is and will be crushed for the foreseeable future, and deservedly so, but I will defend the culture at large because whats lost in instances like these is that the vast majority of student-athletes DO go to class and do their work and earn their degrees. There is not a ubiquitous culture of cheating at UNC something cant be contained to the underground and simultaneously reflect the culture of an entire university -- but rather a toxic sub-culture thats now being painfully dug out.
I dont want North Carolina to be let off the hook here. The penalty will be incredibly harsh, Im sure, and we have to own it. What took place is indefensible, and I dont really have an appetite today for anything suggesting otherwise. Like probably all alumni and former UNC athletes, I feel much shame in my alma mater today. Speaking only for myself, though, Im not ashamed to hold a degree from the university or be associated with the athletic department, because in totality this scandal is not reflective of UNC student-athletes at large. Its an ugly, ugly point in our history that will forever be represented, but anyone who cares about the school today wont be running from it or touting the everyone does it excuse, whether thats true or not. The vast majority of students and leaders in Chapel Hill want this handled appropriately, and it will be.