e: effzee, good writeup
Disagree on the OL. Peters is not worth his salary, and his unreliable health make him really a bad idea to bring back as a starter. Seems like late-era Jake Long. Kelce is small. He isn't a good fit in all offenses. He may not work in a power scheme if that is the way they go. Two new guards. Could conceivably just be Lane back, though I guess Kelce is back too
Sproles cap savings are minor. I'd move on from Murray out of principle. More than a few players have whined about players not being accountable or wanting a coach that was "hard-nosed". Need another WR but really just have to hope Algholor develops. Bad rookie year.
I like the defense but they need a pass rusher and an ILB. Hard to know really until the new coach comes in and decides on a scheme
Whatever the oddities with Murray, it's clear Howie and the current roster of players won over Chip and his regime. Thay includes Murray who echoed the team's sentiments when he told Lurie he had no confidence in Chip as a coach.
That, the money tied to him, and plus the fact that he is actually a good RB keeps him here I think. Both Ryan Mathews and Sproles are far more cap friendly to cut.
You maybe right about the offensive line but I think Peters is an elite athlete who has another 2-3 years if he chooses to play. His health was only in question this year due to an injury early in camp he tried to play through all season. He was very healthy and elite the last 2 seasons.
At the very least considering the need at Guards, I don't think that you also create a giant hole at LT or RT assuming Lane Johnson moves over.
I'd keep Peters, Kelce, and Land as is for another year and focus on starting guards and depth. I wouldn't be opposed to drafting a OT somewhat early but not necessarily to start now. The whole OLINE needs depth, youth, and talent infusion. They haven't drafted an oline player in two years!
I also think Kelce is fast more versatile and not just a product of Chip's scheme. He was good under Reid as well.
On D, if they switch to a 4-3 guys like Brandon Graham and Vinny Curry can return to their natural positions at DE and rush the passer. I think that suits the D, the depth at DE, and the LBS better. The current log jam at MLB can also be better utilized under a 4-3 scheme.