e: Philly fans would know better, but I was under the impression that Banner, Howie and Reid were all constantly fighting for power in the second half of Reid's tenure
Weren't always constantly fighting. Basically it was all good back when Reid had a grip on things and his 5 year plan. Banner worked the cap, Reid worked with the FO/GM to make personnel decisions, and the fact that they had McNabb and a good to great D kept them atop the division every year.
Once they lost the SB, TO blew up in their face, & McNabb missed 2 straight season with season ending injuries stories started emerging about FO dysfunction. Basically guys like Howie were earning the trust of Lurie and Howie was the force behind getting rid of key veterans like Tra Thomas, Jon Runyan, Dawkins, and ultimately McNabb. These were not moves Reid was in favor of and he really had to be talked into them.
The dysfunction ultimately led to Banner being "fired", Reid going nuts doing shitty things like Juan Castillo as DC with Washburn coaching the Dline, the dream team offseason, and then completely dissolving into a shitty coach. During these years talented FO personnel men like Marc Ross, Licht, Riddick, and some others who didn't or couldn't get along with Howie moved on or were let go.
No shock then that when Chip brought in his own guy, Tom Gamble (from SF), he and Howie clashed. Already reports out that Howie had scouts loyal to him and they would hide or withold reports from Tom and Chip. After Chip's 2nd season, Tom is fired. Chip makes a power play and wins total control. Chip fucks up roster and the terrible season + Howie whispering shit in Lurie's year leads to Chip being kicked out along with Ed Marynowitz who everyone has commended is another bright personnel guy who grew up under Saban.
I really don't get what Howie possess that Lurie loves so much. Howie, much like Banner, is excellent at managing the cap and the Eagles for forever have been salary cap champs. Even after the dream team they were in good shape. But many people can manage the cap and do well. It is much harder to scout talent and draft key pieces to build a championship roster.
I know Lurie wants to win but this kind of loyalty to Howie almost seems like he is far more concerned with managing the cap than winning games.
Wasn't Joe Banner the Eagles salary cap guru? Howie took over the salary cap function after Banner moved on if memory serves. The Eagles were still rolling over 9-10 million every year so the cap management didn't fall off of a cliff once Banner moved on but I have to imagine that Roseman didn't exactly reinvent the salary cap wheel when Banner moved on.
Basically.