Edge was very good. And...who else? Dominic Rhodes? Are we really going to call Joseph Addai great?
Obviously Marvin, Reggie, and Dallas are (were) fantastic, and they also made something out of nothing with guys like Collie.
Freeney was great, although he ran past plays 50% of the time. Mathis' reputation took a big jump about two years ago - everyone assumed he was a secondary guy to that point. I'm failing to think of a significant defensive tackle that played in Indianapolis in the last 15 years.
A HoF talent at Safety the few years he was healthy.
You realize he only played more than 6 games in a regular season twice in Indy? This is over the span of 7 seasons.
And where the hell is this HoF comment coming from? His three best seasons:
96 Tackles, 71 Solo, 3.5 Sacks, 2 INT, 6 PD
91 Tackles, 71 Solo, 0 Sacks, 1 INT, 2 PD
39 Tackles, 25 Solo, 0 Sacks, 1 INT, 1 PD
Compare that to the other teams they were going up against. I always that that those Colts teams were really good. Maybe stacked is to strong a word but it wasnt Manning and 44 nobodies.
It was a good roster dominated by offensive talent (Manning, Harrison, Wayne, Edge, Dallas) and two pass rushers (Freeney and Mathis) and then largely a cast of bodies outside of Bob Sanders and Gary Brackett.
Case in point, who else on that team left Indianapolis and had a markedly better career?
Mike Doss, Raheem Brock, Cato June, Nick Harper, Kelvin Hayden. These are guys that each started 60+ games for the Colts - over 100 for a few of them (Doss and Brock), and they're the most ordinary of the ordinary.