• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NFL Super Bowl XLVII |OT| Where The Magic Happens

Status
Not open for further replies.

jakncoke

Banned
It will have to b/c 2015 is stacked. Isaac Bruce, Walter Jones, Orlando Pace, Junior Seau, Kurt Warner

Bruce isnt getting in his 1st time, Warner doesnt deserve it at all. Seau will be iffy to get his 1st time. Jones and Pace deserve it but will they get it
 

mr2xxx

Banned
Well at least some back log can get cleared out.



Pretty sure this happens with all teams

Pretty much, every team is little a different in how they give stats for tackles. Some are more likely to give out solo tackles to a player despite others helping, while others are more likely to give out assist to everyone involved instead of solo tackles. It evens out in the end.
 

Gigglepoo

Member
Why did it take this long for Chris Carter to get in? HOF is kind of a joke sometimes.

He was cut from the Eagles after three seasons for drug abuse, and it took a few seasons in Minnesota before he made the leap. Taking in his whole career, it makes sense that he wasn't voted in immediately.
 

chuckddd

Fear of a GAF Planet
Happy that Carter got in, now they can commence clearing the wr backlog. And Strahan is going to make it, but he shouldn't get in before Greene and Haley. I was listening to a hof voter on the radio and it sounds like Modell is never going to make it. REJOICE CLEVELAND!
 
Doesn't matter because it happens all the time, not just with Ray Lewis. Pete might have a valid argument if he actually compared Morgans tackles to Rays. I bet we would see the same thing with Morgan.

Doubt it. Ravens have been inflating Lewis' stats for years. If he's even in the vicinity of a play he gets credit for it.

Other teams do this, but not to the degree Lewis gets it. Everyone in the league knows it. It's the reason Ray had no takers in '08.
 

squicken

Member
Bruce isnt getting in his 1st time, Warner doesnt deserve it at all. Seau will be iffy to get his 1st time. Jones and Pace deserve it but will they get it

lol Warner is a lock hall of famer. AZ and STL are two of the all time shit franchises in history, and Warner changed their fortunes. I mean look at AZ before and after he left!

All the STL guys, general fans know from two SB appearance and that's it. Vermeil and Martz have said the guy who powered that offense was Pace. Martz didn't believe in pass protection, so they relied on Pace to always shut down whoever he had 1v1

Bruce idk. Tough for WRs. People seem to think he never existed before SB runs. He had 1700+ yards in 1995 (which is the nuttiest year for passing, ever) w/o a stud QB

Seriously, 1995 is the most absurd WR year ever. I had Scott Mitchell, Brett Perriman and Herman Moore on my FF team and lapped the league

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1995/receiving.htm
 
I've been slacking on NFL-GAF.

THE SUPER BOWL IS TOMORROW

dO9WJpNl.jpg
 
Ravens will win tomorrow. That Ravens defense is going to fall apart with a loss. They don't want to decline with people thinking Lewis held that team together. Defense has been Suggs' for 3 years and you would never know it, as the aging linebacker who should have been gone 3 years ago is getting all the credit.
 

jakncoke

Banned
lol Warner is a lock hall of famer. AZ and STL are two of the all time shit franchises in history, and Warner changed their fortunes. I mean look at AZ before and after he left!

All the STL guys, general fans know from two SB appearance and that's it. Vermeil and Martz have said the guy who powered that offense was Pace. Martz didn't believe in pass protection, so they relied on Pace to always shut down whoever he had 1v1

Bruce idk. Tough for WRs. People seem to think he never existed before SB runs. He had 1700+ yards in 1995 (which is the nuttiest year for passing, ever) w/o a stud QB

Seriously, 1995 is the most absurd WR year ever. I had Scott Mitchell, Brett Perriman and Herman Moore on my FF team and lapped the league

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1995/receiving.htm

If he gets in, i'll knock over a magazine rack
 
lol Warner is a lock hall of famer. AZ and STL are two of the all time shit franchises in history, and Warner changed their fortunes. I mean look at AZ before and after he left!

Are Super Bowl Appearances enough to get in the hall on first ballot? Warner's been to 3 and only won one. Those aren't Hall credentials.
 

squicken

Member
Are Super Bowl Appearances enough to get in the hall on first ballot? Warner's been to 3 and only won one. Those aren't Hall credentials.

QB wins? You're better than that. He has two different 3 year stretches where he was the best QB in football. He will be first ballot.

The bad trend for HoF is that modern inductees are always more offense than defense. They may need a new committee just for defensive players

edit: I think Reed goes in next year. Reading the Twitter of some of the voters, seems Aeneas and Reed in good positions next year
 
QB wins? You're better than that. He has two different 3 year stretches where he was the best QB in football. He will be first ballot.

The bad trend for HoF is that modern inductees are always more offense than defense. They may need a new committee just for defensive players

When Warner was good he was great. Dude had a huge lull in between though. I think they're gonna see him as lightning in a bottle and not a lock.
 

jakncoke

Banned
QB wins? You're better than that. He has two different 3 year stretches where he was the best QB in football. He will be first ballot.

The bad trend for HoF is that modern inductees are always more offense than defense. They may need a new committee just for defensive players

edit: I think Reed goes in next year. Reading the Twitter of some of the voters, seems Aeneas and Reed in good positions next year

No way son, you're drinking rams kool aid hard. Were you even a Rams fan during their run or did you have misfortune of jumping after the good seasons
 

mr2xxx

Banned
Doubt it. Ravens have been inflating Lewis' stats for years. If he's even in the vicinity of a play he gets credit for it.

Other teams do this, but not to the degree Lewis gets it. Everyone in the league knows it. It's the reason Ray had no takers in '08.

This coming from an unbiased Steelers fan? Like I said someone needs to do a comparison to Morgan to even make a legitimate complaint about Rays playoff tackle record. Prisco only had an issue with Ray getting some easy assist and not the solo tackles. Besides the record doesn't even matter because everyone will just say 'deer antler spray' when referring to the record.
 

squicken

Member
When Warner was good he was great. Dude had a huge lull in between though. I think they're gonna see him as lightning in a bottle and not a lock.

The stat geeks are going to spend a year murderizing the hold outs that he'll coast. Lightning struck twice

btw Cris Carter was never in the top 6 in any year in receiving yards. I still would have gone with Reed but whatever
 
This coming from an unbiased Steelers fan? Like I said someone needs to do a comparison to Morgan to even make a legitimate complaint about Rays playoff tackle record. Prisco only had an issue with Ray getting some easy assist and not the solo tackles. Besides the record doesn't even matter because everyone will just say 'deer antler spray' when referring to the record.

The fuck does this have to do with anything? Lame argument bro.

Also, you clearly didn't read the whole article.

The stat geeks are going to spend a year murderizing the hold outs that he'll coast. Lightning struck twice

btw Cris Carter was never in the top 6 in any year in receiving yards. I still would have gone with Reed but whatever

One problem I have with the Hall of Fame. Stick around long enough and you'll get in on sheer volume, even if you never dominated.
 

mr2xxx

Banned
The fuck does this have to do with anything? Lame argument bro.

Also, you clearly didn't read the whole article.

Like I said Bro if you want to take it upon yourself to compare Morgan to Lewis go right ahead but if you only analyze one guy under a microscope and not the other then it is a BS argument. If you don't agree with that then please continue with the Ray Lewis agenda.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom