I really like Reid a a coach. Before this year I would have said hi team always played har and were prepared. When it was him and Chilly I think they did a great job of coming up with plays and formations to get guys open. I think Marty as OC has held the team back these last few years. The talent on O is better but they dont seem to get close to the same production. Malin and DJax are more talented then anyone but TO that Mcnabb had but those guys struggle to get open so often. If I had a team I would hire Reid, but I would want him to get a new OC. I really dont like Marty as an OC at all. Reids biggest problem is he is really stubborn, which is also a plus some times. He believes in his offense and players to a fault. If he had ran more in the NFCC against the Bucs the Eagles would have a SB but most coaches are like that I guess. The Eagles havent been the same since JJ died. Dawkins had a great story the other day about Reid. When the Eagles were getting ready to play the Rams in the NFCC Reid came into a defensive meeting and started to ask questions and Dawk and Trotter got up and told him to not worry that the defense was in good hands and he left. Reid needs to be in a situation where he doesnt even have to think about the defense. It was his idea to hire Washburn which meant they were stuck with the wide 9, and then he promoted Juan when it was clear Juan wasnt ready. When Andy was running the drafts the Eagles did a good job drafting offensive players, but missed on a ton of defensive picks. He needs a strong GM to work with. When the Eagles hired him he had this binder with his 5 year plan in it, that was when he was at his best. He is the guy you bring in to build the team and then get someone else to finish the job.