This might sound ridiculous, since Pittsburgh fans enjoyed two finals in 2008 and 2009 and of course a Cup victory in 2009, but what has having the #1 and #2 players in the world done for Pittsburgh fans lately? Great regular seasons and embarrassing defensive/goaltending collapses for the past couple of years. Crosby is the undisputed #1 and that means almost nothing. Boston, Chicago, LA, New York Rangers, etc... These teams are not close to having anything close to an undisputed, league wide, worldwide best player, and recently they have been way way better than Pittsburgh (though Boston has started a decline).
Of course I'd like McDavid, but the Leafs' road to success is going to be more about dramatically increasing our drafting/development teams' effectiveness from top to bottom. For fuck's sake we need a commitment to drafting speed and skill (with a few helpings of size and character). Give me a roster like LA's or Montreal's or New York's or Anaheim's and I'm a happy man.
More important than McDavid is drafting a GOOD player with our 2nd round pick. And maybe 2016's 2nd round pick. And in 2017. Maybe get at least one fucking Bergeron or Subban in the 2nd round in the next five years.