I thought it was okay after the fact. I did like the homicide cases. I'd probably play it again if it went on sale on PS4.
But I'm not questioning quality exactly. Just the decision itself to have LA Noire remastered vs. Red Dead Redemption, with RDR2 coming out this year. Though, the RDR coding is apparently a mess to deal with anyway.
LA Noire > Red Dead Redemption
But I'm in the minority. And it would probably make more sense to do RDR honestly.