But this is brutal, torture in the Centre of the Hockey Universe, where the Leafs haven’t won the Stanley Cup since 1967, the longest drought in the NHL. The odds are against the Leafs in this position, and the odds caught up with the Leafs to put them in this position. Whether or not the Leafs make the playoffs, they need to take a long, hard look at GM Dave Nonis, coach Randy Carlyle and their overall approach.
The truth is, the Leafs aren’t very good. They never really were. When Carlyle took over, he talked about improving defensively, but the Leafs allow more than 36 shots per game, by far the most in the league. Last summer, Nonis bought out Mikhail Grabovski and let Clarke MacArthur walk in free agency, and he signed David Clarkson and acquired Dave Bolland. Clarkson, the seven-year, $36 million man, has four goals in 52 games. Bolland has played only 18 games because of an ankle injury. Nonis acquired goaltender Jonathan Bernier, too, and Bernier has been brilliant. But he wasn’t that big of an upgrade over James Reimer, and goaltending can take a team only so far.