Back in 2007, Brian McCann and Jeff Francoeur were supposedly offered nearly identical contracts. Francoeur declined, and rumors say he wanted double what was offered. McCann accepted, and has made every All-Star game since (he made one before then too).
Going with the notion that the contracts were more-or-less identical, Francoeur would have been offered a 6 year, $26.8 million contract, with a club option for 12 million in 2013. There was a chance that the contract ended up being too team friendly for Francouers liking, but as we saw there was also a good chance that the contract would have ended up an albatross. Francouer thought he was being undervalued, and the Braves front office was wise to play hard ball with Jeff and not back down to his demands.
Francoeur signed an extension today with the Royals worth $13.5 million. We all have our reasons to dislike Francoeur, being the statements about OBP, the previously mentioned decline of a solid offer, or the poor attitude he showed when he was sent to the minors, but this is a fair deal for a player of his caliber. He earned five million a year ago with the Mets and Rangers, so $6.75 per year is nothing outlandish.
Over the past five years, and now that he is guaranteed $13.5m over the next two, Francoeur will have earned $25.25m. Compared to McCanns $38.80m, that is $13.55m less. It is quite ironic that the deal Francoeur signed through 2013 needed to be twice as much as what he agreed to in order to match McCanns total over that seven year period. He once wanted double what McCann accepted, now he needed double what he agreed to just to match the offer he would have received.
While most athletes maintain a necessary level of confidence and slight arrogance, there is a lesson in this story that says turning down guaranteed money over several years is a risk that many should not take. Thankfully for the Braves, the risk taken by Francoeur saved them millions of dollars and millions of headaches.