catfish said:
yeah thats a good point, but I find that it essentially stops you wanting to dual wield most times because everyone will just be chipping off your shield from way back. I think it's to powerful to give to everyone at start. Much like the old pistol.
Yeah, the pistol is the most overpowered starting weapon ever. It is a handheld sniper rifle. The minuses are obvious. However, with Halo and everyone having the best (non RL) weapon in the game, at any time a good pistol could get you out of trouble because it was two shots to the body and one to the head.
The BR is different because its a bit more utiliarian, maybe even more primitive than the pistol. At long range it's only good to annoy a sniper (the carbine is more accurate at long range and its damage scale was toned down as a result). At midrange it's undoubtedly the best weapon in the game the FSK (four shot kill) is key.
However, up close, the BR is outclassed by almost all of the dual combos, SMG+Magnum, SMG+Plasma Rifle, PP+SMG (though this is admittedly the weakest of the four worth while dual combos) and PP+Magnum (the most lethal, period).
So it's all about the attainability of those duals. Two Plasma Rifles drain shields almost immediately and then a melee will finish the deal.
I like Battle Rifle start because the weapon is the most useful and it also requires a degree of skill to operate. I really don't think dual wielding takes that much skill at all, and the BR stresses the importance and usefulness of grenades, something else that dual-wielding overlooks.
That said, I definitely see the validity in the lack of SMG on Ivory Tower argument.
EDIT: And to Catfish's above comment, that's a good question. I think the Bungie modes are horrid, useless and having radar on is retarded and starting with shit weapons is terrible. Phantom Team King on Foundation Rumble Pit comes to mind as one of their crowning achievements.
But I also don't give a shit where my rank advances or doesn't advance to in this game. The new content will come out and the new matchmaking lists and everyone will run to it for a month and then the cheating will kick up again and everyone will be back in custom games again.
Customs should = less slayer, more Team Ball, KOTH Crazy.