On paper, zone looks to be the best. My problem is I'm struggling to get timing down when I face a pitcher with really good off speed stuff, so I can't imagine combining that with actually aiming the bat. It looks like if you can manage the zone interface, you'd have the best chance of placing the ball where you want or hitting hard drives.
I messed around a tiny bit with analog last night on my RTTS hitter and I think I did better with it than I do with directional. Directional seems to punish you more for being slightly off with your timing. I hit a ton of foul balls or weak bloopers. Even when I string together a couple of hits, I'm almost certain to hit into a double play the next AB.
Have you tried directional at all? What was your take on analog? I think the latter is going to be my new thing.
This might be Tales From My Ass but I think the timing is more forgiving if you use Zone than Directional/Analog.