OMG Wrestling is Fake, why do you watch this crap

Status
Not open for further replies.

krae_man

Member
Eh, I stopped watching wrestling a long time ago when they stopped actually wrestling and instead did nothing but talk. Seriously, every time I turn on the shit they are talking. Shut up and get in the ring you assholes. The talk-to-wrestle ratio is severely skewed towards the former.

It was always more talk then wrestling, Always.

Only difference is now the mid card is held back from performing to their fullest abilities in order to make that same boring "lol I win now" Cena match not look more horrible then it already does.
 
I think less of people that like westling. I can understand if you're a kid, but a grown adult? Get the fuck out of here.

There are some people who still say shit like this about video games. Yet here we are all posting on a forum primarily dedicated to gaming.
 
To be fair, on the flip side, i've seen plenty of people get real up in arms over certain things as if they were "real" like daniel bryan winning Wrestlemania. People are all "OMG I can't believe he did it, i'm so happy for him, He deserves it, blah blah blah" and i'm just kind of like...uh it's written that way. It's scripted. He didn't actually overcome some kind of insurmountable odds or some kind of adversity regardless of what the promos and storylines suggest. He won because it was written that way.

Part of the joy is the fact that some of us have been following his career since 2002 so to see him on top of the world is extremely exciting and humbling considering where he started from. And while he didn't overcome anything in the ring, he certainly had to overcome the backstage politics and the myriad of other issues.
 

slit

Member
I think less of people that like westling. I can understand if you're a kid, but a grown adult? Get the fuck out of here.

I'm not even really a fan anymore, but I bet if you were honest and laid out all your interests I could find something just as "silly and juvenile". Now climb down from your tower before you get a nose bleed.
 

jmdajr

Member
There is an infinite amount of so called idiotic entertainment that people enjoy watching. If it's their free time and said folks are meeting their obligations then let them do what they want. I don't see why people have to take the time to cut it down. Granted wrestling doesn't get a free pass as many other forms of entertainment, but part of the reason is some idiots still think it's a sport. Cats been outta the bag a loooooooooooooong time. It's a show. It might be a dumb show, but it's a show that many people enjoy on many different levels. What I see when I'm watching it is totally different from someone else who hates it. But anyone who thinks it's something easy to do is an idiot. Every time a guest host comes on the show they seem completely lost. No doubt it's not something an ordinary person can do.

In the end, at least it's not anime.
I love DBZ
 

Ithil

Member
I watched it till I was 14. The storylines were enough to keep me interested for a time. It's pretty much just theater.

I think the problem in most peoples eyes is when grown men watch it. It's a product directed towards young people. Not dissimilar to grown men watching My Little Pony. People like what they like.

If all wrestling was WWE, sure, it would be directed towards young people. But there's hundreds of promotions.
Sort of when people think "anime" is some kind of specific genre.
 

Ithil

Member
To be fair, on the flip side, i've seen plenty of people get real up in arms over certain things as if they were "real" like daniel bryan winning Wrestlemania. People are all "OMG I can't believe he did it, i'm so happy for him, He deserves it, blah blah blah" and i'm just kind of like...uh it's written that way. It's scripted. He didn't actually overcome some kind of insurmountable odds or some kind of adversity regardless of what the promos and storylines suggest. He won because it was written that way. We know this.

But he did, massively. Not in the ring, but in his career, he overcome great odds and got higher than anyone expected him to. You don't solely enjoy it for the scripted result of a match, and it does mean more than that to someone who has followed the man's career for years and years.

Trying to trivialise the moment for him by saying "sure it's scripted, who cares" is wrong on two levels, first that it was a great accomplishment for him to get to that level in spite of everything working against him outside of the ring, and second that any movie ending people enjoy could be trivialised by saying "it's not real lol", instead of enjoying a story.
 

see5harp

Member
Being scripted is just one part of why most non fans find wrestling incredibly dumb. I don't have a problem watching The Sopranos because the acting, cinematography, and writing is near perfection. I cannot say that about wrestling.
 
D

Deleted member 47027

Unconfirmed Member
Being scripted is just one part of why most non fans find wrestling incredibly dumb. I don't have a problem watching The Sopranos because the acting, cinematography, and writing is near perfection. I cannot say that about wrestling.

It bothers you that the Sopranos is scripted?
 

Heroman

Banned
Being scripted is just one part of why most non fans find wrestling incredibly dumb. I don't have a problem watching The Sopranos because the acting, cinematography, and writing is near perfection. I cannot say that about wrestling.
Wrestling being dumb is the reason why a lot of people watch it.
 

slit

Member
Being scripted is just one part of why most non fans find wrestling incredibly dumb. I don't have a problem watching The Sopranos because the acting, cinematography, and writing is near perfection. I cannot say that about wrestling.

No, not even close. Anyway, you don't watch wrestling for Academy Award performances.
 

Marvel

could never
ivKxBQ47y8EFL.gif
Horse's owners right here people.
 
D

Deleted member 47027

Unconfirmed Member
Which means nothing since you said it's not good to begin with. The Supranos went waaaaay downhill in the later seasons.

Whoa, hey, hold on

Let's not have that fight right now
 

see5harp

Member
Ah I see. So you have issues with shows like The Office, Parks & Rec, Brooklyn Nine-Nine or Derek for instance as well?

Those are all fictional television shows, all of which have better scripts and acting than the last episode of WWE Raw. I don't despise or laugh at people for liking wrestling, so feel free to watch it yourself. I would never laugh at complete strangers for liking something I dislike.
 

Branson

Member
Who gives a shit what other people say about what I like
While this is the right attitude to have, if you like wrestling, I'm sure you've had that person follow you around to tell you it's fake. It's annoying as shit. I like that it's fake. It gives the real moments more meaning.
 

Aiii

So not worth it
Those are all fictional television shows, all of which have better scripts and acting than the last episode of WWE Raw. I don't despise or laugh at people for liking wrestling, so feel free to watch it yourself. I would never laugh at complete strangers for liking something I dislike.

I don't care if you like it or not, or think the writing that's bad. That's not what I was commenting on. It's all your other reasoning that's wonky to me.

For instance: "Those are all fictional television shows"

So is this. It's fiction, with actors playing roles.
 
Those are all fictional television shows, all of which have better scripts and acting than the last episode of WWE Raw. I don't despise or laugh at people for liking wrestling, so feel free to watch it yourself. I would never laugh at complete strangers for liking something I dislike.

I would certainly hope they would, their budgets are huge!

While this is the right attitude to have, if you like wrestling, I'm sure you've had that person follow you around to tell you it's fake. It's annoying as shit. I like that it's fake. It gives the real moments more meaning.

I just bury them. I learned from the best.

Also GODDAMNIT SUNNY I got like 2 posts down and then gave up. I'll have nightmares forever
 

kiguel182

Member
But he did, massively. Not in the ring, but in his career, he overcome great odds and got higher than anyone expected him to. You don't solely enjoy it for the scripted result of a match, and it does mean more than that to someone who has followed the man's career for years and years.

Trying to trivialise the moment for him by saying "sure it's scripted, who cares" is wrong on two levels, first that it was a great accomplishment for him to get to that level in spite of everything working against him outside of the ring, and second that any movie ending people enjoy could be trivialised by saying "it's not real lol", instead of enjoying a story.

Well said.

The whole Bryan story was more real than a lot of movies are. He overcame real world odds and challenges that led them to write that story and make him win. Bryan's win was real even if the on-screen story wasn't.

I don't think some people realize than winning in wrestling has real implications to the wrestlers and that when you support someone you want to see them win, not because of the story on-screen, but because you want to see the person succeed and see their hard work pay-off.

And that it's more real than pretty much any form of entertainment.
 

hbkdx12

Member
I used to watch in when I was in Junior High; I knew it was fake since I was a little kid but just watched to talk about it the next day with friends.

I remember the moment I stopped watching: it was during the height of Stone Cold's popularity and his "feud" with Vince McMahon. Vince was in the ring spouting off stuff, blah, blah, blah -- he said something about Stone Cold and I started counting, "5, 4, 3, 2, 1, now." Stone Cold's music started and he rushed to the ring.

I changed the channel and never watched wrestling again.

Honestly, a lot of my interest comes from seeing how predictable things are and how much i can decipher before things get revealed. For example, back during the attitude era when they constantly did over the top shit, any time there wasn't a ramp leading to the ring it meant that a vehicle of some kind was going to make it's way to the ring hence why the ramp wouldn't be there. And 9 times out of 10 it would always come out at the end the show like when stone cold brought out the beer truck and sprayed Vince

Part of the joy is the fact that some of us have been following his career since 2002 so to see him on top of the world is extremely exciting and humbling considering where he started from. And while he didn't overcome anything in the ring, he certainly had to overcome the backstage politics and the myriad of other issues.
I can understand that. That's fair but it seems like people were genuinely surprised that he won. The guy had the one of the biggest followings in wrestling in pretty much forever and for what seemed like it spanned forever considering he was consistently being screwed over and held down by the authority (from a storyline persepective, can't speak on the actual backstage politics) the idea that he'd get his comeuppance at their highest rated PPV event of the entire year didn't seem like anything but predictable. That's not to take away from the moment but i just don't see how people who can recognize how scripted wrestling is wouldn't have seen that coming
 

see5harp

Member
I don't care if you like it or not, or think the writing that's bad. That's not what I was commenting on. It's all your other reasoning that's wonky to me.

For instance: "Those are all fictional television shows"

So is this. It's fiction, with actors playing roles.

My other reasoning is that the writing, acting, and performance is poor. I don't know what is so confusing about that. I don't know why you would even try and make a distinction between a show filmed in moc doc fashion and a regular sitcom. No one on the planet thinks that Andy Samburg is an actual NY city police officer.
 

Nameless

Member
A great wrestling match is like a 20-30+ minute action scene that tells its own little story. When it involves characters and a storytline you're invested in it's especially compelling. There's nothing like it.

The real side of wrestling is also part of the draw to a lot of fans, which is something people don't get. The backstage politics, dirtsheet drama, following pushes and watching guys rise and fall. These are things are just as interesting as the on the on screen product--more so a lot of the time.

I don't defend being a wrestling fan. We all realize that on some level it's silly. So what. Half the people who shit on it were watching during the NWO/Attitude era with everyone else.
 

Branson

Member
Honestly, a lot of my interest comes from seeing how predictable things are and how much i can decipher before things get revealed. For example, back during the attitude era when they constantly did over the top shit, any time there wasn't a ramp leading to the ring it meant that a vehicle of some kind was going to make it's way to the ring hence why the ramp wouldn't be there. And 9 times out of 10 it would always come out at the end the show like when stone cold brought out the beer truck and sprayed the Vince


I can understand that. That's fair but it seems like people were genuinely surprised that he won. The guy had the one of the biggest followings in wrestling in pretty much forever and for what seemed like it spanned forever considering he was consistently being screwed over and held down by the authority (from a storyline persepective, can't speak on the actual backstage politics) the idea that he'd get his comeuppance at their highest rated PPV event of the entire year didn't seem like anything but predictable. That's not to take away from the moment but i just don't see how people who can recognize how scripted wrestling is wouldn't have seen that coming

Because those moments when the WWE follows up on a good predictable outcome that the fans want is few and far between these days. He lost the world championship at wrestlemania in 18 seconds.
 

jmdajr

Member
While this is the right attitude to have, if you like wrestling, I'm sure you've had that person follow you around to tell you it's fake. It's annoying as shit. I like that it's fake. It gives the real moments more meaning.

And the real moments are not what people think they are, like people saying that Daniel Bryan didn't really win. I'm pretty sure his tears weren't fake.

It doesn't matter though. The people who enjoy the product can separate everything and enjoy it for, like I said, many different reasons.
 
Embrace it and you will find something special

live-worldwide.jpg

but chikara sucks =/

I can understand that. That's fair but it seems like people were genuinely surprised that he won. The guy had the one of the biggest followings in wrestling in pretty much forever and for what seemed like it spanned forever considering he was consistently being screwed over and held down by the authority (from a storyline persepective, can't speak on the actual backstage politics) the idea that he'd get his comeuppance at their highest rated PPV event of the entire year didn't seem like anything but predictable. That's not to take away from the moment but i just don't see how people who can recognize how scripted wrestling is wouldn't have seen that coming

The original plan was for Batista vs Orton. It only changed because of fan participation.
 
D

Deleted member 47027

Unconfirmed Member
FE gay isn't gendered brah

adding women doesn't un-gay anything nor is it negative

embrace everyone
 

Anth0ny

Member
"Do you ever watch a movie or TV Show?"
-"Yeah"
"Why? Aren't those fake?"

Discussion over.

Actual real response I've gotten from saying this:

"But movies and TV shows aren't trying to be real"



Wrestling is a totally unique beast. Scripted content that also requires real athleticism and encourages interaction from the crowd. Like an interactive play, except way more entertaining.

A lot of today's mainstream product is fucking horrible, but that's not because it's fake. It's because the writing and booking is god awful. Some of the better moments in wrestling (Austin vs. Bret at Wrestlemania 13, Mankind/Taker Hell in a Cell, Punk/Cena MITB 2011) are just as engaging and emotional as a Breaking Bad, imo. Unfortunately, you get that kind of stuff once or twice a year, if you're lucky.
 

jmdajr

Member
I guess my mind works differently but I never associated wrestling with being gay, or looking gay, or what not. I just didn't.

I mean yeah we had gold dust and I guess part of that was playing up on said audience fears. But you have to be real uncomfortable with who you are for not watching or hating for that particular reason.
 

jmdajr

Member
People that run around telling people shit is fake and they hate it are usually joyless individuals.

Most people I know that hate wrestling pretty much hate all sorts of things. The world just pisses them off. Anything they don't like is either dumb or sucks.

Every laid back person I know is at the very least, ok with it, even if they don't watch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom