Counterpoint: Reaper's so cool.
He's second only to McCree in close-range damage (will be king once McCree is brought in line) with Roadhog a trailing third. He absolutely destroys people in close quarters, with his huge ammo capacity and stylish reloads, not to mention his ult. He's like McCree, only not about ambush, but rather assault.
His edge went so far it wrapped back around into being cool again.
Fair enough, I actually never looked at it that way, so thank you for that.
Reaper, Tracer, and Pharah really seem to be who the intended tank killers are right now. Tracer's Ult charges particularly quickly and she does a lot of damage the problem is her accuracy falls off a cliff half a second after she starts firing, so her best targets are tanks. Pharah is incredibly bursty and if played right is going to be far enough away from tanks that they don't really threaten her. Reaper drops just about everyone in three shots and he can be super slippery so he can kill who he needs to and get away. McCree was too good at too many things and it was making other heroes seem worse than they are at the moment as a consequence.
One of my favorite characters with probably get a nerf eventually its the nature of things. In fact I bet Reinhardt is totally going to get a nerf of some kind since he's the default tank at the moment.
As I commented with the above poster, I appreciate insightful replies like this rather than the usual over-defensive, barely concealed insult posts.
I'm just very finnicky about the characters I connect with. For instance, I'm a huge Street Fighter nerd, but I can't play Street Fighter 5 because there's no characters I connect with.
That being said, saying that McCree was doing too many other characters jobs
too well helps me see that side of things. Not saying I completely agree, because I've had plenty of situations where I switched out of McCree to Pharrah or someone else and helped turn a game around because McCree wasn't effective for the situation (shitty at range, bad with mobs, etc) but it does me change my perspective a bit. I honestly wish I could enjoy Reaper, because the gameplay flow sounds somewhat similar.