I don't see whole grain products as processed as white bread products or most fast food and junk food.
Unless you have some sort of gluten or wheat intolerance or are diabetic or some other disease you shouldn't have inflammation or water retention issues.
I have no problem with a relaxed form of the paleo diet.
Replace "inflammation" with "oxidation" and realize how ridiculous this is.
http://eatdrinkbehappy.blogspot.com/2012/04/wheat-belly-wheat-berry.html?m=1
The bottom line
If you take one thing away from Wheat Belly (and this review!), I hope it is this - we are not meant to eat wheat 6 times a day and we should not eat such poor quality, processed wheat foods all the time. Just please don't allow his mis-information to cloud your mind. You are savvy, intuitive eaters - real food brings health, processed food diminishes it. Now go enjoy an apple. You know, to keep Dr Davis away.
Seems to me the gap between that statement and paleo is just a matter of degree. For what it's worth I'm not convinced all grains are bad, but certainly the refined ones are ... concerning. To be eaten in moderation let's say.
well, yeah. One of things though is to start too quickly which is why people get "wheat withdrawal". There is no need to eliminate grains from your diet and also, you can't enjoy some junk food like a greasy pizza or some pasta once in a while without wrecking your shit and where's the fun in that?Seems to me the gap between that statement and paleo is just a matter of degree. For what it's worth I'm not convinced all grains are bad, but certainly the refined ones are ... concerning. To be eaten in moderation let's say.
Plus theres the experience of seeing grandparents, who've eaten lard, and far less processed junk, live till their 70's and beyond, and now seeing stories in the news about how this is the 1st generation that will die before their parents, because of ballooning bellies and diabetes running out of control, which matches carb increase in the average western diet. (and easily visible as other cultures absorb the "cheap stodge is good enough" western way of eating and suffer the consequences)
You don't have to micro-manage your diet to be healthy. A sensible course is better for you in the long term, both physically and psychologically. And any diet that says to use supplements or vitamins is bunk. A varied diet should have that covered. That's the key thing for many Americans, is that we eat too much of the same refined carbs and not enough variety and this is coming from reading a lot of studies on cultures that have adapted the American diet in the last 60 years or so (for example Samoa and other pacific Islands in the pos war era).Eh, that doesn't really show that processed junk is intrinsically bad, only that it makes it so much easier to overeat (and then get overweight/diabetic as a result of this).
I would like to see more studies on this before I make up my mind.
Ensure that you cover every single variables, such as slow vs fast carbs, animalian vs vegetabilian proteins, fats of different kinds, various macro-nutrient ratios, and so on.
So I've enjoyed having chicken with my eggs in the morning but I think I'm switching back to bacon for one main reason. I miss cooking my lunch vegetables in the bacon grease. Nothing like a big pile of broccoli and spinach with a smokey bacon flavor as a base.
I hear a lot of people talking about bacon grease. Is that just literally reusing the grease out of the pan? I am unfamiliar with this. Sounds awesome.
How do you cook your veggies?
I hear a lot of people talking about bacon grease. Is that just literally reusing the grease out of the pan? I am unfamiliar with this. Sounds awesome.
How do you cook your veggies?
Is cheap salmon still good for you, just not as good, or what? I got an individually packaged single serving from Bottom Dollar (discount grocer) from "Ocean Eclipse." I googled and it looks like Costco also sells this brand.
Well I am only on day two of Paleo and anyone else experience noticeable differences in their bowel movements?
Seriously, this diet is clearing me out. haha
Just coming in to say doing well on the diet and it's awesome. Dropped 20 pounds in last 6 weeks and I'm eating as much actual food as I want. I've been eating a few too many full Irish breakfasts though which isn't ideal since sausages and black/white pudding have wheat flour in them. I had a cheat meal last Friday, chinese takeaway and half a bag of Doritos on Saturday and holy shit did I feel the difference in just one day. It was only then that I noticed I had been feeling much better in general recently, less bloated etc. and my previously almost perpetual indigestion was gone. Amazing how much less I want to eat crap now. Keep up the good work people in this thread, there is definitely something to this.
Alos, story on ABC science about tooth decay in Mesolithic hunter gatherer tribes, sorry if old:
http://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2013/02/18/3691558.htm
When I eat processed junk and bread and dairy, I get fat. When I eat the same calories in real food (meat, veggies, fruits), I lean out and I feel better. Totally unscientific I know, but for me that's all the proof I need.
Fell into the rabbit hole of reading up on the research of this, i can spend days on Medline and Pubmed, there are shitloads of peer-reviewed papers, all of this ties into decades of research into diabetes and celiac disease.
It is all mind-bogglingly complicated in our bellies. Short exp: processed shit & refined grains are resistant to being ripped apart by our system, which have adapted to break down plant and animal cells, so they slip between the intestinal villi and interact with the intestinal barrier, which triggers an immune response. Which is fine, if its transient, but not all the time, for years.
One of the latest, most detail packed ones links up that stuff above about the the natural mouth flora being damaged by grains, and presents evidence that the intestinal flora is annihilated too. And in case you don't know, there are more bacterial cells in our gut that the rest of our entire body, the ecosystem itself is now considered another vital organ, we are literally dead without them.
Check out this excellent chart, a comparison of modern-era hunter-gatherers.
I found it interesting. This whole thing is a real headfuck.
I've just realised that for the entire pre-agricultural Era (2.5 - 0.01 million years ago), our systems wouldn't have had to deal with anything that wasn't a whole animal or plant cell, apart from some contaminants. At least, i can't think of anything.
Are any of you guys a little scared about this being a total farse? What if this is NOT how we should be eating at all and we actually end up doing more harm to ourselves than if we just continued with the the more regular way of eating?
The stricter side of this diet is a complete farse. No need to eliminate many of the so called-non-paleo foods from your diet.
No need to add supplements either.
Like what?
Breads, rice, beans etc. All sorts of filling and nutrient rich foods. Now, that doesn't mean that those foods should be the main staple or even a huge part of the diet but it certainly means you can have some rice with your chicken and veggies or eat a burger with buns (as wild as that may sound).
The problem with the normal American diet is huge portions and not enough vegetables and variety and too much empty calories such as white breads and starchy foods such as potatoes. You certainly don't have to eliminate certain food groups, just limit them.
It doesn't have to be this micro-managed mess, it's quite simple and some of the things of this diet are perfectly reasonable.
One thing that I do like about this diet is that it does make vegetables appealing, not that boiled, bland mess that most Americans think vegetables are.
I think many people who gravitate towards Paleo have health problems that tend to get better or completely reversed by the elimination of the very foods you're referencing.
If you're speaking to the average person without these problems, then yeah, I'd agree.
You need to understand this, its not a pass fail diet. Its one of degrees. So if you go all out, but then lapse and have a piece of cake, dont worry about it. You didnt fail. You just need to recognize its bad and do better next time. From your posts, im worried that you'll slip up once and then say "OH NO, I am a failure!" and then abandon the diet. That is not what you want to do
I'd avoid the microwave as much as possible. Best thing to do for reheat is wrap meat in foil and put in oven at a low temp or slice it up and put it in a frying pan. Same for the veggies just a bit of coconut oil and fry them up a bit.
Even though I'm not a physician, I still think that you can benefit from paleo even if you don't do it as thoroughly as recommend (yet). Ditching grains and sugar alone will be a huge step towards a more healthy living.
Don't worry about almonds roasted in peanut oil or sushi with soy beans too much. As a matter of fact sushi with natto is actually acceptable, natto and tempeh are fermented and thus ok to eat, albeit disgusting for many people.
You can also alleviate most of the potential harms of bad PUFAs in vegetable oils with fish oil supplements, take 1 - 2mg of omega 3 PUFAs if you know that you cannot limit your intake of omega 6 enough to the correct ratio.
If you eat lots of vegetables and reasonable amounts of nuts and fruits (frozen berries are cheap and highly recommended) you'll will have enough anti-oxidants and other nutrients to benefit from your diet even though you are not yet able to follow paleo 80% of the time.
Focus on eating lots of the good stuff and accept that you might be eating things that aren't as good every now and then. Acknowledge your "mistakes" but don't let them get to you, you're still learning and you'll eventually get to the 80/20.
In order for Paleo to proven as a legit way of life, doctors are going to have to prove the inflammation factor is the more important metric than overall cholesterol and triglyceride levels. I'm not sure how you do that other than having a control group and then slicing people open.
Yeah, you're way overthinking this. I understand that, i have a scientific mind too, but i despise calorie counting, thankfully its not required on this diet.
No gluten.
No sugar.
No processed stuff.
Avoid rice & potatoes if you want fast weight loss.
Eat everything else whenever you feel like it.
Thats it.
Makes ya think.
Inflammation is caused by legumes and soy and such, right? Just trying to learn here.
And what exactly is getting inflamed here?
Ended up going to Five Guys and getting a lettuce-wrapped burger for dinner. Was needing some form of comfort food. Yes, I got the cheese, too. I think I do well on dairy so I think it's fine....I hope....
Got home and still wasn't feeling well, so I took a big swig of whole mile for some sugar just to not feel so shitty for a little bit. Tomorrow I'll be back on track again! I really didn't do anything bad except the milk. I told myself that cheese, full fat yogurt, and butter would be my only dairy products![]()
Apart from genetic predispositions like celiac or lactose tolerance, you can adapt to certain diets which is why it causes you to be ill when you eat non-diet foods, not because those foods are bad.
Paleo is good marketing at work.
Thats not true a a lot of people are gluten sensitive and they don't even have a test for that. Robb Wolf explains it like a constant little pin prick annoying your body constantly keeping your immune system on full alert constantly fighting off a "leaky gut" and no way for the permeability of your intestine to ever fully heal.
Just because your not celiac doesn't mean you won't be more healthy off grains. Sure your body will "adapt" and try to cope with the diet and do the best it can because we all know the body if flexible but to perform at its peak there may be a good argument against the SAD.
The data obtained in this pilot study support the hypothesis that gluten elicits its harmful effect, throughout an IL15 innate immune response, on all the individuals. This innate response is found in both patients with and without CD, although the triggering of an adaptive response is CD specific.
Okay, cool. This helps a bit. Even if I can only do 70/30 my whole life, I will feel like I'm doing better than most people. I was just mostly worried that if I have any of the bad things, it negates any positive effects of the good things. I take from this that it's still okay
So you're saying I should take fish oil pills then? What about a multivitamin? I have an unopened jar of One-a-Day multivitamin for men. Okay to take?
Also, any good articles explaining the omega 6:3 balance? Is this key to weight loss as well? I'm trying to get rid of stubborn belly and rump fat.
This of course, in tandem with exercise.
![]()
with cara cara orange, my favorite citrus
![]()
What do you guys think of crockpots? I've been checking out some paleo corkcpot recipes, and they seem pretty convenient since I can come home from work and have something cooked.
What do you guys think of crockpots? I've been checking out some paleo corkcpot recipes, and they seem pretty convenient since I can come home from work and have something cooked.
Man I made paleo meatloaf today in the Grokpot. Delish. I'm going to make more.
The paleo ketchup recipe I tried however, was complete crap. But I seasoned the meatloaf enough that it didn't matter.
It took me two weeks to adjust, my GF too, we were serious carb addicts. I often ate bread at every meal, for no good reason usually.
After the 2 weeks something had changed. I know exactly what thanks to all the research stuff i've been reading, as in my body can now switch to fat-store use easily and without fuss, but its still a shock to not get hunger-rage anymore, it was my defining feature!
Now i don't really ever feel "starving", like i used to, i just think "hmm, time to eat i guess. What delights will i have today?".
That said, i don't feel up to doing hard exercise at all right now, i'm just cruising at the moment, i'm losing enough weight without it and will introduce some running when the still-extreme weight loss begins to slow. Ketosis is horrendous, i like to avoid it at all costs.
So, how are green beans regarded in here? from skimming the thread I know that legumes are often "banned" but green beans are the best choice, still some days I eat a lot of them for lunch (mixed with carrots) as it was rice, so I'm wondering if thats ok?
Wow,yeah all of this...
Honestly the whole thing I take away from this diet is eating nutrition. That is what I follow.
Cut the empty crap and the rest will follow...
Breads, rice, beans etc. All sorts of filling and nutrient rich foods. Now, that doesn't mean that those foods should be the main staple or even a huge part of the diet but it certainly means you can have some rice with your chicken and veggies or eat a burger with buns (as wild as that may sound).