buddha0991
Member
SETO KAIBA
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona Community Thread |OT7| P5 is nyaow. (Mark all PQ and P4U spoilers!)
- Thread starter Dantis
- Start date
- Status
It's been a lot since I last played the games but i think it works.
Edit: The first time I played p3p I had a Cybele with mind charge and megidola, and I always used them in combination. I don't remember using almighty much in P4 but I'd assume it still works.
A Dead Diehard
Member
It works. Why else would Naoto have it in vanilla when her only other method of attacking is physical and instant kills?
Fuck this Power Rock quest, that shit never drops and it's already hard enough to find actual Power Castles in
I spent like 1 hour running around and in that time I found maybe 4 of them, and only two of these dropped the item
@
I hate it because I want to finish all the quests... even though there's no real reward beyond the feel of completion... I think.
the secret lab.
I spent like 1 hour running around and in that time I found maybe 4 of them, and only two of these dropped the item
@I hate it because I want to finish all the quests... even though there's no real reward beyond the feel of completion... I think.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
I think persona Q did that kind of quest pretty well in that it makes you kill the enemies with certain moves to make them drop the item.
Is there any reward though? I just found out there's no trophy. Is it really worth doing?
I dont' think there's anything other than the reward directly connected to the quest, though you're required to complete some quests in order to unlock others.
Hot Coldman
Banned
BassForever
Member
There is no trophy for doing all quests in p4g? Never bothering with those again
buddha0991
Member
The Phantom even spoke at the concert, totally think the MC will talk when he is The Phantom.
BassForever
Member
I'd honestly be really surprised if the MC in Persona 5 is completely mute again. It's certainly possible but after they seemingly dropped that from the P4A games and PQ it'd be really jarring to go back to silent protagonist.
Cipher Cat
Banned
I can't think of any voiced protagonist in a SMT game.
And don't say Tatsuya and Maya because they were both muted as MC.
Aigis.
BassForever
Member
Have they at any point referenced this game as SMT: Persona 5? Everything I've seen just calls it Persona 5 same way P4G dropped SMT from the name SMT
ersona 4/I'll be surprised too, since AtlusJP went all the way to get Fukuyama Jun to voice the P5MC. Then again, maybe certain dialogue options will be voiced, while the other are silent.
I'm gonna name my MC Lelouch.
Aadrian1234
Banned
Only reason I want a silent protagonist is to help me project myself as the MC. I did it in P3 and P4, and it made the games that much more memorable and emotional if you feel like you were actually there.
Have they at any point referenced this game as SMT: Persona 5? Everything I've seen just calls it Persona 5 same way P4G dropped SMT from the name SMT
Persona was never "SMT" in Japan. Atlus USA is the one who dropped that nomenclature, which was presumably used beforehand because "SMT" was a more renowned name than "Persona" in the west.
Cipher Cat
Banned
I guess this does not count. As it is too linear and her personality was already revealed in the main game. And as protagonist you would want to choose your own characters personality.
A Dead Diehard
Member
A canon name's more important to me than voiced dialogue.
Not necessarily. Catherine has been cited before, and I would be fine if the protagonist's personality was pre-defined, but the tone of dialogue choices were tinted by the player's decisions like in that game.
Cipher Cat
Banned
Haven't played Catherine yet. Can't talk about this.
Vincent in Catherine is fully voiced, but you get to define him further through the choices you make through the game. It's pretty much an extension of what I expect for Persona 5, although with the protagonist being less chatty unless a dialogue option is selected.
Cipher Cat
Banned
Is Vincent known by the people when you start the game?
Maybe P5MC will be voiced if the trailer showed what it is like. Then that would mean all we see in the trailer happens at the first day of the game. 4/11. And they are planning a heist + dungeon crawling + other stuff. So they already know eachother.
buddha0991
Member
Atlus considers Persona and Devil Survivor "Megami Ibunroku" or, Alternative Tales of the Goddess. Both the first Persona game and the first Devil Survivor game got this label. The first Devil Summoner, on the other hand, got the actual "Shin Megami Tensei" name.
Japan refers to the whole overarching series as Mega Ten or Megaten.
Japan refers to the whole overarching series as Mega Ten or Megaten.
BassForever
Member
Hmm didn't know this, more you know thanks
Its still part of the SMT universe, its just never been a name association.
DryEyeRelief
Member
Yes, like Aigis
A Dead Diehard
Member
Who can forget such brilliant lines as: "NOT ENOUGH THINKING POWER. SHUTTING DOWN."
Cipher Cat
Banned
Then it's no wonder he's voiced.
The Persona 1 protagonist is known by his group when the game starts, and the same goes for Maya in P2:EP (actually, the latter's only really one character, like in P2:IS). What's the connection?
It took nearly two years but...
(Click image for Episode link)
Its really hard to believe, but after almost two years weve made it to Episode 50! Much to our good fortune, Persona 5 also received an incredible new trailer too. This episode is full of analysis, speculation, and predictions regarding Persona 5.
5 hosts, 5th game, 50th episode. Not much else to say, get hype.
(Click image for Episode link)
Its really hard to believe, but after almost two years weve made it to Episode 50! Much to our good fortune, Persona 5 also received an incredible new trailer too. This episode is full of analysis, speculation, and predictions regarding Persona 5.
5 hosts, 5th game, 50th episode. Not much else to say, get hype.
lol
but seriously, it's a really smart system. Much better than, say, "Press circle to reply with a Law text, press square to reply with a Chaos text" or something. Writing, erasing, deciding on how to word stuff that affects the storyline... it was very well made.
tbh that was honestly like one of my favorite things in the whole game.
Aadrian1234
Banned
I still think it went well. It was her story, and she was already an established character.
If Glasses-Kun is voiced, give him a personality. If he's not, leave his personality to the dialogue choices. I don't see much point in trying to convey the MC as your avatar if he is going to speaking most of the time.
Started P4 for the first time. Named my MC John Cena.
but are you golden or vanilla? The world demands to know.
Cipher Cat
Banned
P1 might be the case because it was their first game and then they might have thought that it was a bad decision. P1 isn't that popular here right? Don't know how it is in the east though.
I agree.
Looks like vanilla.
Clearly vanilla. No Marie to suffer through!
BassForever
Member
To be fair even in P4/G I had some disconnect at certain story scenes where Yu would act in ways that I didn't want him to based upon choices I made. Off the top of my head the scene where he and Yosoke devour the girls ramen stands out in my mind.
Towards the end when
Yu's locked in the police station I just couldn't help but wonder why he didn't demonstrate to Dojima that he could enter the TV sitting on that desk, or just try to escape through that TV.
Aadrian1234
Banned
I wanted to drag Dojima into a headlock in front of the TV, stick my hand in, then tell him to shut up and leave everything to the Investigation Team.
And not to mention how many of the options you are given in P4G counteract how i would feel. This is why i like P3MC more, i have more in common with the new kid who just tries to live a shut-in life but slowly starts warming up to everyone.
Cipher Cat
Banned
- Status