Cannon_Fodder
Member
Ah, fair enough. Hopefully I'll come across it someday.
I agree that I would have liked to see more of the manga translated into english. I enjoy what I've read of it, and I quite enjoy the art too.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona Community Thread |OT7| P5 is nyaow. (Mark all PQ and P4U spoilers!)
- Thread starter Dantis
- Start date
- Status
Ah, fair enough. Hopefully I'll come across it someday.
I agree that I would have liked to see more of the manga translated into english. I enjoy what I've read of it, and I quite enjoy the art too.
For Naoto:
Girl Yaso High uniform
Light in Starless Sky (Theme Persona 3 Movie #3 Falling Down) hits Youtube and is awesome-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzjZC2z2-KU
Hands down the best theme of all , and i love Fate in our hands.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzjZC2z2-KU
Hands down the best theme of all , and i love Fate in our hands.
Aadrian1234
Banned
My personal opinion, FES. The world and atmosphere are much more appreciable with the anime cutscenes and 3D environments
I want to get some other girls social links up in Persona 3 but I don't wanna date anyone except Yukari
Same here. I only want to "date" (would you call it dating?) Aigis, but still want to get other's social links up.
Light in Starless Sky gets better with any listening ... my god
A download link if anyone want it ::
http://www.mediafire.com/listen/qap...Sky+-+Persona+3+Movie+#3+Falling+Down+(2).mp3
A download link if anyone want it ::
http://www.mediafire.com/listen/qap...Sky+-+Persona+3+Movie+#3+Falling+Down+(2).mp3
I really want to know the story behind all the localization changes done for that game. :\
It doesn't seem like much of a story. They just thought more Americans would buy it if it seemed more American.
GayForMaster
Banned
I messaged the Atlus QA guy Rob Stone about if a (this is the first time I've ever wanted a remaster by the way, or re-release) Persona 3 re-release would happen consolidating the pros of both games into one game since it's always a hard decision to pick which to play and he said there was no official word of another P3 release. Then he recommended me the PSP version because "the content that isn’t there isn’t really significant when compared to how much better the game mechanics are in the remake." They also said they'll take what I said into consideration but I doubt they'd release another heh. I guess P3P it is. In addition to this guy, the majority of recommendations have been for P3P.
They haven't. Across the hundreds of P3FES vs. P3P debates I've seen, both in our community threads, LTTP gaming threads and "which should I play?" threads, it's very much a 50% split between sides.
There's always a story. But we've never really heard any of the details. I mean, Wikipedia cites Hardcore Gaming 101 for all the changes. That's how few details there are on the specifics of the changes.
The changes were definitely rushed tho. For example, experience points were increased and the encounter rate reduced, but they failed to also adjust money, leaving you perpetually poor in the original PS1 version.
From what I've seen, the general census seems to favor FES ever so slightly. But yeah, it's pretty close to an even split.
Oddly enough, anyone asking which version to get will know of the pros and cons, so they can't really go wrong with either version.
GayForMaster
Banned
I mean from where I've personally asked. Not from doing google searches, or gaf threads.
DryEyeRelief
Member
It honestly seems like you already have made a choice despite what others have said to you.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
I'd say that if you have the time and it turned out that you really like the game, play it normally in fes, and then do FeMC in p3p.
Aadrian1234
Banned
I started with P3P, then switched to FES about 10 hours in. The difference was enough for me to abandon P3P immediately and start from scratch on FES. I got into Persona because of it's story, not because of combat. Funnily enough, despite what people say about Persona 4 Arena, watching a friend play P4A (Labrys' story, to be exact) is what made me drop everything i was currently playing and buy P3 and P4 the next day. Even though FES has gameplay flaws, only reason i went with that is because how much i didn't care for combat, and wanted the best story i could get. I've only recently started warming up to turn-based combat, but my entire driving point in P3 was story, and nothing else.
That's my personal opinion on why FES is better, but some may argue mechanics are better than story. Normally, i'd agree, but P3 is the first game to ever pull me in as hard as it did. I beat it in 60 hours, and in 6 days. 10 hours a day. I have never been hooked to a game that hard before solely from story.
Don't take this as me telling you to play FES. This is my opinion, and my opinion alone. P3P does have a better combat system, and full-party control, along with other Quality of Life additions, and FeMC.
GayForMaster
Banned
Not really. Even though I said "P3P it is," I'm still feeling a bit eh. Dang man why is it so hard to choose?! Gonna end up never playing P3.
DryEyeRelief
Member
The thing is, you express the desire to play 1 and 2 as well. But you want to play P3P because it's more similar mechanically to 4. So when you finally get to 1 and 2 and it's not similar to 4, what are you going to do?
Cannon_Fodder
Member
I'm assuming you're joking there, but just in case, don't let this decision stop you from playing P3 at all. Think of this more of a "can't go wrong either way" type of decision than a "I'm missing something either way" type of decision.
MiguelMexMIstery
Member
That Rise trailer O:
Love the new Yu portrait.
B-but her voice, uggh
UltraGunner
Banned
Coronet Armor ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Vox Chaotica
Member
Fingers crossed we get some new artwork/screenshots of Persona 5 in the Persona Magazine as well. The one week delivery delay is killing me inside. ;__;
Not happening, it seems.
Yes. And they also got different names for the manga.
P4MC's name of Yu Narukami from the anime stuck as his name for the Persona 4 Arena games and (apparently) Persona 4 DAN as well. His manga name was Souji Seta (someone correct me if I'm wrong)
P3MC is Makoto Yuki in the movies and Minato Arisato in the manga.
No I'm pretty sure he wears the Yasogami uniform all the time for some reason. He wears it in the Arena duology as well even though he no longer lives in Inaba.
Yes. And they also got different names for the manga.
P4MC's name of Yu Narukami from the anime stuck as his name for the Persona 4 Arena games and (apparently) Persona 4 DAN as well. His manga name was Souji Seta (someone correct me if I'm wrong)
P3MC is Makoto Yuki in the movies and Minato Arisato in the manga.
ah, that explains it. i guess i'll check out the anime soon just to see how they are. gonna be weird.
They hand wave it by saying he's wearing it for nostalgia's sake.
He's still wearing his Yaso uniform.
In fact, you can bet your sweet bippy that he's still rocking the Yaso uniform at his new (old?) school too.
Teacher: Mr. Narukami, that uniform is not allowed. I'm afraid i'll have to send you back home to change.
Yu: Yu just don't understand.
Teacher: No, i'm afraid it is you that doesn't understand. Get out.
Yu: (Dances out of the classroom)
I'm 68% sure that's how his story will open.
SatelliteOfLove
Member
He just pops his collar and teach shuts it.
DryEyeRelief
Member
He's also Sakuya Shiomi in the stage play adaptation of the game.
The Persona Magazine preview image they put up for the P-Studio interview has the label "P-Studio Interview 1." Maybe that means it'll be a series.
Edit: Actually, it could just be referring to the Hashino and Soejima interview being the first one in the magazine, and "P-Studio Interview 2" would be the Kazuhisa Wada one for P4D.
Edit: Actually, it could just be referring to the Hashino and Soejima interview being the first one in the magazine, and "P-Studio Interview 2" would be the Kazuhisa Wada one for P4D.
Thanks for sharing! Been waiting to hear the full version since I heard it in the trailer. Easily the best movie theme so far.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
What are people's opinions on the Naoto light novels?
Lollipop Dave
Member
Don't take it seriously and enjoy the ride.
It's awesome, but I still prefer more than one heart.
Anyway, I've been playing p3fes almost nonstop in the past couple days.
I'm finally at January, I've got to the top of tartarus on the 1st, now I'm only left with the remaining social links and a bit of grinding, since using the whole party left everyone 10 levels behind me, and I really want Yukari to have mediarahan for the final battle.
For the social links I should be able to complete Empress and Aeon, I should also have 2 extra days for the last Emperor and Star rank, I forgot Star rank 10 can only be reached on school days, that messed me up a bit.
Does the event on the twenty-first take time? If that's not the case I might be able to complete Moon too.
In that case I would be left only with Temperance at 8 and Fortune at 7, Overall I'm satisfied with the results.
For the social links I should be able to complete Empress and Aeon, I should also have 2 extra days for the last Emperor and Star rank, I forgot Star rank 10 can only be reached on school days, that messed me up a bit.
Does the event on the twenty-first take time? If that's not the case I might be able to complete Moon too.
In that case I would be left only with Temperance at 8 and Fortune at 7, Overall I'm satisfied with the results.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Hah, not sure what to make of that.
Reanimatoin
Member
Robot motorbike husbando. That is all.
How do you feel about super creepy fan service?
Because there seemed to be at least one instance of it per chapter, from what I read.
Lollipop Dave
Member
Heh, Read the first chapter, don't expect a literary masterpiece.
That's pretty subjective.
Which part is subjective? That it's creepy?
- Status