Not sure if this is the right place for this... but figured I'd share some quick first timer Nuzlocke impressions.
For the record I am blind Nuzlocking (?) X right now after being inspired by the new Griffin feature at Polygon. (Note - I also went deep down the Pro-Jared rabbit hole with his Red run)
Holy crap! This really is the Dark Souls of Pokemon! (Forgive the cliche, but my anecdote below certainly feels very familiar to experienced I've had in the Souls series)
My first taste of glory (and ultimately painful sadness) came with the appearance and capture of a Pikachu in Santalune Forest.
After naming him Sparkrat and falling for his electric awesomeness get to grinding! I figured I needed to protect my lucky find by buffing him up to a safe level. I win some trainer battles and grind for an hour or two and then...
Then... I run into a wild Dunsparce on Route 3. I wasn't really paying too much attention (grinding on Bunnelbies doesn't require all that much active thinking) and all of a sudden my full health Pikachu is critted by Rollout.
Sparkrat died. I knew right there that the wave of surprise, frustration and anger would shape my future game play. Never again would I take a wild unknown Pokemon for granted.
I am 100% hooked. I can't wait to get back in and continue the Nuzlocke run. I haven't had so much fun with Pokemon since Blue back in '98
TLDR: