Hmmm. A neutral wouldn't want to have to many townpoints, since that could get them NK. But that begs the question: why even target CM at all then? Also, if it was a neutral, then what happened on N1, and why only 1 kill there? I can understand a Town vig not shooting on purpose, but a neutral killer? They tend to shoot as much as they can. So that mean either the neutral or scum kill failed on N1.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Pokémon Mafia |OT| Gotta Catch Em Scum!
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
Hmmm. A neutral wouldn't want to have to many townpoints, since that could get them NK. But that begs the question: why even target CM at all then? Also, if it was a neutral, then what happened on N1, and why only 1 kill there? I can understand a Town vig not shooting on purpose, but a neutral killer? They tend to shoot as much as they can. So that mean either the neutral or scum kill failed on N1.
No action was made ? i mean its the most simple answer
Even before his claim I don't believe a word Blarg says, so it's not really a conversation
you understand that i have my fair share of concerns about you now, do you ?
Sure, but most of your concern is because I claimed veteran and then retracted it, right? Is there anything else?
Possible. That really depends on the power and win condition the neutral would have which outside of them flipping isn't possible to know. And that is if there even is a neutral killer,since we have no hard proof of a third killer existing. Honestly, this is all mostly speculation and I don't know if it will help us to find scum without more information to work with.
Blargonaut
Banned
Because I want to talk about me and you
There is no me and you
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
We owe it to ourselves
Blargonaut
Banned
In Love Boat, we ruled by "see" and "stare" Power. Here, we must scrabble for "just desserts" Power
This is your inheritance, NiN
Blargonaut
Banned
Tell me, *S-rank, what are the odds of hitting a Bulletproof on N1?
Depends how many bulletproof's are in the game.
It also depends on exactly who those bulletproofs are
Blargonaut
Banned
That was a rhetorical question
You're a rhetorical question
Blargonaut
Banned
Never answer me again
Slime to none mate. What are the chances of no night action ? higher
Try harder next time
why the hell are you even tryin ? i mean come on Blarg, you are better than that.
For all the others.
A whole lot of nothing has happened in the past hours.
Several people claiming to have information but in the end not saying a thing.
Bad play
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
our 2 claims come from the resident madman and our certified lier.
oh boy.
is there any easier way to verify this other than lynching them?
i mean im totally okay with lynching blarg, and might be okay with lynching splinter, but i would really rather lynch for perceived scummy play, rather than become even further bogged down in game mechanic speculation.
also, y'know, getting rid of a vigilante could likely be a total waste of a tool that might turn this game around.
oh boy.
is there any easier way to verify this other than lynching them?
i mean im totally okay with lynching blarg, and might be okay with lynching splinter, but i would really rather lynch for perceived scummy play, rather than become even further bogged down in game mechanic speculation.
also, y'know, getting rid of a vigilante could likely be a total waste of a tool that might turn this game around.
Dusk Soldier
Member
After 3 days of mislynches. It should be obvious right now that we're not going to find scum based on studying each others behaviours.
If you know something concrete, come forward and tell everyone. It doesn't matter if you'll make yourself a target for scum.
It this game continues at the same rate of 3 deaths per cycle. Then there is a strong chance you could be killed without ever getting to say anything.
It's better to say something now, rather than die and take your secrets to the dead thread.
Someone in this game must know something useful. It's been 3 days, and no scum or useful PRs have died.
Just come forward.
If you know something concrete, come forward and tell everyone. It doesn't matter if you'll make yourself a target for scum.
It this game continues at the same rate of 3 deaths per cycle. Then there is a strong chance you could be killed without ever getting to say anything.
It's better to say something now, rather than die and take your secrets to the dead thread.
Someone in this game must know something useful. It's been 3 days, and no scum or useful PRs have died.
Just come forward.
you know that led us to the current oath of killing town people only.
I am inclined to agree in this
Blargonaut
Banned
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
yeah i know, thats why im asking for an alternative, i really dont want another lynch to happen for reasons other than killing scum.
i meantioned killing blarg like that because im scumreading him more and more.
Blargonaut
Banned
How about now
What are your current thoughts on getting lynched and/ or NK'ed today ?
Blargonaut
Banned
Are you threatening me
melonrabbit
Member
Dusk, I agree with you.
I wish I had something to add that was helpful. I feel useless. I'm sorry Gorlak.
Thinking about the all NKs. Ty is still the one that stands out. Everyone has been from the middle of the pack. Likely we've been swayed to mislynch CM today, so it seems a bit pointless for scum to do it.
CM dying and flipping town casts Sawneeks in a weird light, not sure if that was the intention.
Our vig "claims" only want credit for Gorlak and cannot explain N2.
And then there was Blarg's big ploy yesterday to vet TheG or expose a lot our PRs.
With all this the discussion on Sophia/SS has completely died down. I know it's a unpopular topic but we now know 2 of the triangle were town.
I wish I had something to add that was helpful. I feel useless. I'm sorry Gorlak.
Thinking about the all NKs. Ty is still the one that stands out. Everyone has been from the middle of the pack. Likely we've been swayed to mislynch CM today, so it seems a bit pointless for scum to do it.
CM dying and flipping town casts Sawneeks in a weird light, not sure if that was the intention.
Our vig "claims" only want credit for Gorlak and cannot explain N2.
And then there was Blarg's big ploy yesterday to vet TheG or expose a lot our PRs.
With all this the discussion on Sophia/SS has completely died down. I know it's a unpopular topic but we now know 2 of the triangle were town.
Blargonaut
Banned
What would your plan or line of thought be then ? go for the inactives ? I am on the same boat , feeling kinda useless.
That still sucked and was an error on your end so please dont try to turn it into a good thing.
melonrabbit
Member
But if the vig is you whom were you waiting for?
Blargonaut
Banned
We should lynch Sophetch Today, IMO
just to make sure
just to make sure
Blargonaut
Banned
A plan is only an "error" if it's actually seen through, k
Waiting for what?
That really doesn't tell us a whole lot unless we are very certain someone in the triangle has to be scum, which I ain't.
Ofc not , Just stating something
For the record up to this point you were never "certain" so thats like saying "...." exactly nothing.
Yeah, that is what I pointed out: that the fact that 2 of the triangle flipped town doesn't really tells us anything.
The error is still there and was made by you. Just wanted to make that clear ok ?
no need to be a wussy about that.
melonrabbit
Member
Honestly? I'm doubtful of my count. I theorized that they were maybe 4 scum and 2 netruals and then rest were town. We started at 23, 8 dead town and are now at 15. That would mean 5 to 6 of the remaining are scum a00nd netruals. And 10 to 9 are town.
We've seen only 2 confirmed Pokemon with abilities (Bronx and SSS) therefore I'm inclined to believe that it's an low % of them occurring. Splinters is claiming a 3rd and that makes 4 I know about.
Where does that leave us? At least one of our more active leaders is scum. That I'm sure of.
I felt suspicious of Sophia but have been less certain with SS.
Sawneeks is a possibility.
And Splinter, I was really against this suggestion because I was like what are the odds of being scum 3 out 3 but then I remembered he replaced Kawl so I don't believe him to be scum but also don't want to be fooled again.
Blarg. Who knows?
I know I'm not scum and I've told you as much before. I hope your not scum, despite my earlier feelings you have definitely helped refocus us and I like to believe you are town, same with Dusk.
Blargonaut
Banned
Just because you keep saying it doesn't mean it's so
That might be true but denying it wont mean that it is not correct.
Thanks Melon, i appreciate those words. even more coming from you.
Ok lets do this and try win the game. I would still hear from Yennek since i dont really get a grip on him.
Blargonaut
Banned
Third's the charm, probably
Rofl.
Heya, everyone
Just want to at least check in and let you know I've been keeping up. I literally just finished getting an unexpected root canal, though, so any specific thoughts/suggestions will have to come later.
So, we have someone claiming responsibility for last night's kill, but we don't know about the 2 kills on the previous night?
Just want to at least check in and let you know I've been keeping up. I literally just finished getting an unexpected root canal, though, so any specific thoughts/suggestions will have to come later.
So, we have someone claiming responsibility for last night's kill, but we don't know about the 2 kills on the previous night?