So I went and saw America: Imagine A World Without Her. It starts in Revolutionary War America with a soldier writing to his wife on September 11, 1777. You might think it's supposed to a 9/11 reference, but it's the actual date of the Battle of Brandywine. This is the scenario where George Washington is shot and America is undone. So it's a good thing that Washington survived and won the batt-oh wait, the Americans lost that battle anyway. So D'Souza asks what would it be like if America never existed, if the country fragmented into several pieces, if the Nazis got the atomic bomb first...and doesn't follow up on it.
He quotes Abraham Lincoln (well, there's an actor playing Lincoln), who says the only way America could be destroyed is through itself, referring to people who want America to become socialist, and themes the movie on how liberals (and especially Howard Zinn) are creating a "culture of shame" that indoctrinates people into hating America and wanting to destroy it through socialism, quoting Obama's "Starting today, we need to pick ourselves up, dust ourselves off, and begin again the remaking of America", which means he's going to make it into an evil socialist state, along with his "Fundamental transformation of America" quote he made during the 2008 election. After all, you guys want to America to be torn down and remade as a socialist government right? No? I thought so.
The movie is essentially split into 3 parts:
1. Indictments against America. This is essentially one big attack on Howard Zinn and his book The People's History of the United States (which I've read part of myself thanks to recommendations from GAF), including scenes from Good Will Hunting and The Sopranos. Oh, and did you know Howard Zinn was a former Communist who left the American Communist Party because it wasn't revolutionary enough? It goes through a list of several grievances against America that claim America has acquired everything through theft and conquest, including...
-Theft of land from Indians. You remember the stories from grade school. We meet Indians, kill them, and take their land as we expand west. However, he points out that most Indians were wiped out by a plague. Some, such as the Sioux, complain how we took "their" land, even though they took the land when they conquered other tribes. We've apparently offered to give them their land back, but they'd rather settle on their new lands. Also mentions Christopher Columbus and the Spanish Conquistadors weren't in the United States, but you all knew that.
-Theft of territory from Mexico from the Mexican-American War, referring to the land as the Lost Province. Several Mexican-Americans were interviewed, saying they weren't Americans, but Mexicans who are living on land that is rightfully theirs. I had never heard of this idea before. Has something to do with illegal immigration or something.
-Slavery. This is the part where D'Souza supposedly says "Slavery wasn't that bad because everyone else is doing it." What he actually is saying is "Don't rag on us like we're the only ones who did it, and besides, we fought a war to end it, so we're on morally superior ground." He goes on to mention that slavery started as indentured servitude for whites, and how many slave owners were black themselves, mostly in Lousiana, so apparently this isn't a race issue...even with the whole "blacks are inferior beings" rhetoric going on at the time. To expand that racism wasn't a thing, he talks about Madam CJ Walker, the first black and female self-made millionaire in the early 1900s. D'Souza says no one talks about her because it goes against the culture of shame of racism.
-Imperialism, aka America Is Trying To Take Over the World. Yeah, you know the claims that we really went to Iraq for oil, and the joke that we'll make up an excuse to invade any country that has oil. There are people claiming we went to Vietnam, Germany, and Japan to steal their resources too, as well as helping coups in Argentina, Iran, and elsewhere. Yeah, I don't believe any of that.
-Theft of the American Dream. You've probably heard of the scene where every worker in a burger joint is played by D'Souza. One would think that this is about income disparity and how workers need to be paid as little as they are for profit. No, he thinks people are complaining about high prices for the consumer, comparing the cost of making a fast-food burger vs. making one at home. He mentions Apple and its iPhone, which is incredible popular, but doesn't mention Apple's wage-fixing. Also, Matt Damon is supposed to be complaining about capitalism and greed, when he's making all this money from the Bourne movies, which people are willing to pay to see anyway. He also interviews a former welfare moocher who was scolded by a person who mentioned God, so she got off her butt, became a Christian, got a job, went to college, got a degree, and became a successful business owner, and if she and Madam CJ Walker can do it, you can do it too, right? Right?
Oh, and there's mention of Tocqueville and how America was made through capitalism and entrepreneurship, not through conquest and looting, as was done through history.
2. Talking about Saul Alinsky, his Rules For Radicals book, his influence penetrating media and the government, including Obama and Hilary Clinton, both of whom associated with Alinsky and are working on his strategy to destroy America by making people hate America and blame Republicans or whatever.
3. Talking about how the government is ruining America through NSA spying, comparing the country to the
Panopticon, IRS harassment of conservative organizations (no mentions of liberal organizations), as well as Aaron Schwarz, who broke into MIT computers that were gathering private information on people.
So the message is be proud to be an America, and don't believe the liberal propaganda that America is an evil nation, and socialism is good. I honestly think he makes some good points, and arguments I've never even heard of, but still is fearmongering about the upcoming destruction of America through far-left Alinsky radicals and whatnot.