I don't want to brainchild up this thread so I am going to limit my posts on this topic, since clearly I am not in the majority. I'm disappointed in the lack of solidarity though
Cmon. He is at least not Heulen, which means there is some self-awareness ergo he's not an alien.
That doesn't make it better, that makes it worse. Huelen is like the one poster I wouldn't call a racist for supporting Trump because there is no way to be sure they even understand the decision they're supposed to be making. That's like yelling at a 6-year-old. Most posters get more credit than that and thus they get more responsibility for their choices.
Poligaf cannot become insulated echo chamber.
This argument is about 9 months too late because that's when this thread got taken over by a bunch of hardline Hillary supporters who spent that period giving shit to every Bernie Sanders supporter that wandered by. That would have been a good opportunity to worry about us becoming an echo chamber, but those days are done.
The position of "we should be relentlessly aggressive towards Sanders supporters but we have to be nice to people voting for the Nazi" seems absolutely deranged to me, and yet that seems to be the position of a bunch of people in this thread. Rethink this.
I don't think that's clear at all. Sounds to me like he is new to politics and maybe naive/gullible to how things really work.
He has avoided or dodged every poster asking him for any information about Trump's positions or why he supports them, not just me. He is not that different from qwerty.
A) Don't be so sure about the "founded on racism" bit - it was founded on oppression, but not just of slaves.
The point is that America was explicitly built, when founded, to give rich whites the right to enslave people because of their race, and people fought a civil war to try to protect that right when they felt it was in danger, so it doesn't require much effort to understand why there are Americans today who are racists. This stuff is deep in American blood and it's frankly frustrating to see people pretend that racism was just invented when we started losing manufacturing jobs. Get real.
As for "pivoting towards whiteness"; I'm not even sure what that really means,
A while ago back in another chat you mentioned that you expected Hillary to come out of the primary and immediately start moving away from her racial justice campaigning towards positions that would be more effective at siphoning white support from Trump. I disagreed with you at the time but clearly you were right. That's all I was referencing when I assigned that to you
Yes, but it may not be a priority issue for them.
That's not acceptable. This is literally a serious version of the joke poster saying "well yeah Trump is a racist but I really want lower taxes." If you genuinely think that potentially electing a white nationalist is not the top priority issue for you than your priority structure is immoral and you should be shamed by your peers so that it's clear to you that that's the case.
This conversation is really disappointing to me because it shows that Trump has already succeeded. The crazy racists at the RNC are right -- they have successfully normalized overt racism in the political discourse. It's okay to be a white nationalist in America again. Progressives will sit down at the table with you and try to find common ground. I am deeply disheartened. It took one year to go from 2015 to 1964.
Like I said, I can buy that large-scale shaming can be very effective. To use gay rights again - increasingly progress here is made just because nobody is willing to be the next Maggie Gallagher. It's hard to transmit this stuff to other people or to organize a movement because everyone will call you a bigot. Large companies will do things like boycott states that pass bad laws because everyone knows that being anti-gay is just not a good look. But as the gay rights example suggests, I'm not sure that this works very well when people don't perceive that the shaming is coming from just about everywhere.
This is actually my argument. That is why it's so important to set a clear example of solidarity and reject and shame racism wherever it appears. That is why that's what I expect from people, and why I'm disappointed. It doesn't take many people saying "well, sure, that's racist, but let's try to get along anyway" to make the social pressure to not be racist disappear.