I skipped to this part.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
POPGAF |OT-11| A Dramatic Reading
- Thread starter Soulscribe
- Start date
- Status
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
At this point I think she is physically unable to just sing a fucking song. Like... is all that shit necessary?
Again, it's a BB King tribute. You know his music, right? He was a "shouting, growling mess" too by the standards y'all are applying to Xtina.
Decent, but she was outshined by:
https://youtu.be/vmUfZjuqr2w
https://youtu.be/q3yHhiqQaEU
Infinitely more usable.
I swear, if I hear one more "oh yeah, yeah, yeah, hee"
That's like her go-to run for everything she does these days.
Fleashia Cole? LOL. That song is wack.
Nicole's song is hot. I'll give her that. But Xtina is more heavily featured in her song.
I always liked how dark and seductive Tell Me is.
I swear, if I hear one more "oh yeah, yeah, yeah, hee"
That's like her go-to run for everything she does these days.
How dare you have the audacity to critique anyone's vocals and then use a Mariah gif as a highlight to your point, seeing as her vocals these days are more reminiscent of the echo a power bottom's ass makes while it's ejecting the creamy white remnants of a Saturday night at the bathhouse into a toilet?
What is your fave's go-to runs these days? This?
Remaining seats are available at the back of the venue.
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
Do you?
You sure about that? If you think that minstrelsy is close to the restrained and tasteful vocals of the original... you've got issues. Christina singin voice is edging ever closer to sounding like any adult in a Charlie Brown cartoon these days.
Yes, I am very aware of BB King's music. And he spends the majority of the catalogue doing the same shouting/growling that people scream "OVERSINGING!" when Xtina does it.
You Know Nothing
Member
It seems I struck a nerve.How dare you have the audacity to critique anyone's vocals and then use a Mariah gif as a highlight to your point, seeing as her vocals these days are more reminiscent of the echo a power bottom's ass makes while it's ejecting the creamy white remnants of a Saturday night at the bathhouse into a toilet?
What is your fave's go-to runs these days? This?
Remaining seats are available at the back of the venue.
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
Maybe it goes back to old argument of AUTHENTICITY. Christina sounds like she's faking the funk. Guess that's what you're into.
How dare you have the audacity to critique anyone's vocals and then use a Mariah gif as a highlight to your point, seeing as her vocals these days are more reminiscent of the echo a power bottom's ass makes while it's ejecting the creamy white remnants of a Saturday night at the bathhouse into a toilet?
What is your fave's go-to runs these days? This?
Remaining seats are available at the back of the venue.
First of all...
Hmmm, you're so concerned about Authenticity, yet you have nothing to say when you're Houston Suburb fave tries to act like a 'round-the-way girl?
Perhaps Christina is criticized for those elements in her vocals because she is not doing them for stylistic effect, but because she is incapable of doing anything else. If you listen to this vocal range video for someone like James Brown, just for example, there's a wide range where he is capable of hitting the notes cleanly - belting up to F5 and head voice up to B5 - but he often screams, shrieks, growls, or strains for effect.
I don't know that this makes her inauthentic, but I do think there's a difference between doing something wrong because you want to get that particular sound, and doing it wrong because you can't do it right.
ZombiePlatypus
Member
This seems really arbitrary though. How would you even measure that? I guess you can say you don't feel like Christina's truly emoting the feelings of the songs in her vocals, but that's subjective at most.
Not my posts heralding Mumei's return to PopGAF. My ImpacT.
That mariah run you linked sounded more on point and less strained than the Xtina run tho...
To be fair to Xtina she can still sound great when she doesn't try so hard to go for those big runs. She needs to take her own advice.
To be fair to Xtina she can still sound great when she doesn't try so hard to go for those big runs. She needs to take her own advice.
I hadn't left; I've just been lurking. This place is a kiii whether you post or not.
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
I don't know why you wouldn't assume that the opposite wouldn't true for Bey. We have clip after clip of Beyonce in the early DC days acting like a banji ghetto mess. I think that as Beyonce has aged, she has learned how to keep that side of herself to herself, while she's up there trying to get this pop money. I know that while I'm at work interfacing with the powers that be, that I don't bring street vernacular into the workplace. I thought this was common among black people, I guess you wouldn't know anything about that.
Not every popstar gets the benefit of doubt that say, a Miley Cyrus gets. Miley can invent twerking one day and open a youth hostel for troubled gays the next and no one blinks an eye. Some girls get to "express themselves" without it defining their career. Others get to make one
titty
Beyonce not conforming to type, and you having a problem with it is more your problem than it is hers. You should examine why you clock Beyonce for things you embrace in other "stars."
Off the top I can think of a few inconsistencies in your criticisms of Beyonce:
- Sings in a fake soulful voice, stans Christina Aguilera.
- Is fake ghetto, stans or has stanned Iggy and Miley.
- Is "bad" for/to/representation of the black community, stans every ghetto soundcloud heffa rapping about her pussy.
and now Cory64
Correction: We have footage of a DC era Beyonce acting like a spoiled brat who possessed no greater than a 3rd grade reading level. That's not the same as acting hood. You're getting offensive, sis.
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
Gather her, Mumei.
I guess, if that's all you've got, it will have to do. Goodnight Roy.
I guess, if that's all you've got, it will have to do. Goodnight Roy.
It's not all I got, but do you have a response? You're equating Beyonce acting less than intelligent as her being "hood", which could really be offensive to a lot of people. I'm more talking about her throwing up signs like she's lived a life she really knows nothing about.
<+)O Robido O(+>
Member
Why would I have a response to this obfuscating bait? You tried it though.
And you've never cheered for a person with the same perceived background doing the same thing? Never? Ever?
Blood Diamonds
Banned
Gangsters don’t cry
Therefore, therefore I’m
Mr. Misty-eye, therefore I’m
Can you save
Can you save my
Can you save my heavy dirty soul?
Can you save
Can you save my
Can you save my heavy dirty soul?
For me, for me, oh
Can you save my heavy dirty soul?
For me, for me, oh
Can you save my heavy dirty soul?
a good song from Twenty One Pilots, but god damn most of the lyrics in their new album make me roll my eyes so damn hard.
this is me listening to Blurryface:
While you guys gurls decide who is flopping harder I'll leave this here as an inspiration for this sunny pre-bank-holiday Sunday in the UK
Get into the classic to be "My Friend Has a Swimming Pool"
Get into the classic to be "My Friend Has a Swimming Pool"
not on drugs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-Qkx9TAM10
i like this song from tove lo but who is justin love ? she keeps saying im justin love
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-Qkx9TAM10
i like this song from tove lo but who is justin love ? she keeps saying im justin love
Well, that might be the song title, but it doesn't describe your current mental state.
Was it? Never knew that. It should be the only version that exists, in all honesty.
So much slayage by Rita confusing you since you have not seen your fave slay over more than a decade ago?
Sis, my fave headlined a fest that's literally 6 times bigger than this thing just last year.
Sis, my fave headlined a fest that's literally 6 times bigger than this thing just last year.
But only you remember this.
But only you remember this.
Better than nobody ever remembering who Rita Ora even is.
Fast and The Furious
50 Shades
The Voice UK
Empire
Meanwhile your fave is only a warming her chair on whatever singing show she is. (Gwen is better judge btw)
And isn't that sad? That she's done all this and people STILL don't know who she is or care? The utter lack of presence and memorable talent. Your fave will only ever be a pop community joke. But I suspect you know this and this is exactly why you stan her.
- Status