Felt very weird and awkward.
FWIW, I, and and what I perceive to be a growing number of other people, think that some/most/all of the awkwardness is not because the game is bad, but because it takes a while to get used to.
I think that once you get used to it the mechanics show a lot of depth in what they allow you to do and work pretty damn well when you get the hang of them.
I suggest sticking with it. See if there is anything there you think you could, with practice, get used to.
--
I guess a lot of it is that they really haven't gone for the 'safe' option here. The have taken risks in a lot of stuff, from the mechanics to the camera positions to making a game three times the length of what you would expect, they have really tried to do new and interesting stuff.
Now, I guess since I think it has paid off and works remarkably well it is easy for me to say this, but I dunno. This is what Change looks like.
--
I don't know if this is true with other players besides Sherry... but I just noticed you have more than just the one vanilla melee.
Normally when you run up to someone and hit R1 you have the basic melee... some can do a small combo.
But if you face away from them and hit R1 she does a cool backwards kick. She attacks in the direction the camera is facing instead of the direction the character is facing.
Chris does a... back elbow thingy I think. There really is a whole lot of stuff to discover in the controls. Someone was talking about dodge cancelling with Jake?