Support NeoGAF

[SalvaPot]

I said ‘offering themselves to the NK’ in that post, not to the lynch.

I mean, if my death paves the way to a scum lynch, its not that big of a loss.

 

[Dr. Worm]

Yeah, seems to me like you are already setting up a path here.

Vote: Giant Panda

Also, to clarify, I don't have a cop role. So my Dusk vote is based on pure scum hunting. I've been tunneling to get reactions and if I get a dusk lynch I'll be satisfied, but this right here by panda makes me believe he is scum trying to lead town.

I mean, I do see where GP would get the idea that you've got something concrete on Dusk Soldier

what with you pursuing him so boldly and claiming PR that you've breadcrumbed hints toward

 

[SalvaPot]

I mean, I do see where GP would get the idea that you've got something concrete on Dusk Soldier

what with you pursuing him so boldly and claiming PR that you've breadcrumbed hints toward

Its the "If dusk is not town, lets lynch Salva" part I don't like.

I like Salva.

 

[Ourobolus]

I mean, if my death paves the way to a scum lynch, its not that big of a loss.

I sincerely doubt you getting NK'd gives us any information, mostly because you havent actually given us any

 

[SalvaPot]

I sincerely doubt you getting NK'd gives us any information, mostly because you havent actually given us any

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

 

[SalvaPot]

And this is not me giving up, I feel this is the best course of action, since I have ran out of shots.

 

[Dr. Worm]

Its the "If dusk is not town, lets lynch Salva" part I don't like.

I like Salva.

that's standard practice if someone claims PR to lynch scum, town follows, and then town lynches town.

GP seemed to have come a conclusion similar to the one I came to from your posts; your vagueness about your PR isn't helping you here.

 

[CCS]

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

And of those three, we should lynch Dusk?

 

[Ourobolus]

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

jfc

 

[SalvaPot]

And of those three, we should lynch Dusk?

Well...

Probably.

Again, I am not a cop.

 

[Dr. Worm]

UNVOTE

that's... something, I guess?

 

[SalvaPot]

jfc

Come on dude, by now you should know this is how I play. Stop acting like you didn't see it coming.

 

[Ourobolus]

Come on dude, by now you should know this is how I play. Stop acting like you didn't see it coming.

Yeah and I hold onto hope that you stop it

What can I say I am an optimist

 

[Sorian]

I'm confused because it doesn't sound like your power does anything useful in terms of info and you wanted to lynch someone just as badly pre and post targeting them.

 

[SalvaPot]

Yeah and I hold onto hope that you stop it

What can I say I am an optimist

Well, you are a smart kid.

 

[Ourobolus]

Anyway I doubt salva is scum. If I could vote I would be on either Fat4All or Giant Panda right now.

 

[Fat4all]

I didn’t receive any notices from N2, mind.

 

[Faddy]

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

When you target people what info do you get back?

 

[SalvaPot]

When you target people what info do you get back?

You should know, I targeted you.

 

[Sorian]

Anyway I doubt salva is scum. If I could vote I would be on either Fat4All or Giant Panda right now.

And who would you be on that has a chance of being scum?

 

[Ourobolus]

He can't be claiming an investigative role because what he has given us is useless without the results. It also seems like the player isn't notified (or at least the people targeted weren't)

So my guess is either roleblocker or doctor.

 

[acohrs]

Can you elaborate on why Zeusy? I've been hearing suspicion but nothing damning.

Are you serious Acorns? You legitimately didn't seem to understand why your post was getting called out. It was a bad post. I explained it because that's also what I felt.

Deadly

 

[SalvaPot]

When you target people what info do you get back?

I was joking in my previous post, how would you know?

It will all be clear with my death.

 

[Ourobolus]

And who would you be on that has a chance of being scum?

Those two. I know you like to have an air of authority in these games but you'll forgive me for thinking you are wrong and have been so far.

 

[SalvaPot]

He can't be claiming an investigative role because what he has given us is useless without the results. It also seems like the player isn't notified (or at least the people targeted weren't)

So my guess is either roleblocker or doctor.

Wouldn't it be hilarious if I was both?

 

[Sorian]

He can't be claiming an investigative role because what he has given us is useless without the results. It also seems like the player isn't notified (or at least the people targeted weren't)

So my guess is either roleblocker or doctor.

He protected the person he's had a hard on for lynching?

Maybe he's a mailman.

lol

 

[Faddy]

I was joking in my previous post, how would you know?

It will all be clear with my death.

So when you flip ordinary we will know this has all been a waste of time.

 

[CCS]

I feel good about Giant Panda. This is a good lynch.

 

[Sorian]

Those two. I know you like to have an air of authority in these games but you'll forgive me for thinking you are wrong and have been so far.

Ok, I'm glad you can't vote.

Wouldn't it be hilarious if I was both?

Ok

 

[acohrs]

This post reads extremely manipulative. I still don't actually town read you Faddy. Zeusy yesterday and this today, you're grabbing people who don't want to go with the majority and making it sound like they have to fall in line to compete. That's why I didn't want Zeusy right away and I find it interesting that acohrs isn't an approved choice for you.



This in no way answered the point, you also can't tell other people what is NAI about you. So less smoke and mirrors, why aren't you developing reads? You seem content to just go down your list without actually listening to anyone on the list.



It's also weird that you're in agreement with me but then jumping down my throats for.....? I think you're losing the story.



Unless Salva had no interest in reporting his other checks, I don't think he is softing cop.

Developed reads and now im acting on them. Thought that was the point of reads.

Speaking of...

vote: sorian

 

[SalvaPot]

So when you flip ordinary we will know this has all been a waste of time.

Well, duh.

 

[Fat4all]

I doubt even Salva would throw away a 3-shot Doc right away.

 

[Dr. Worm]

Wouldn't it be hilarious if I was both?

what is Jailer?

 

[Sorian]

Developed reads and now im acting on them. Thought that was the point of reads.

Speaking of...

vote: sorian

You're doing that on purpose at this point. You're quoting me and not actually answering the question and then trying to flip it on me.

Speaking of, is there a vote count?

 

[SalvaPot]

what is Jailer?

I really dislike the Jailer role, so much pressure to play well.

 

[Ourobolus]

Ok, I'm glad you can't vote.



Ok

Me too. I'm clearly on the right track and needed to be silenced.

 

[SalvaPot]

Me too. I'm clearly on the right track and needed to be silenced.

Ouro, do you feel we should lynch Sorian?

 

[Zeusy]

vote: faddy

 

[Fat4all]

Me too. I'm clearly on the right track and needed to be silenced.

Not really. If you needed to be silenced you would of been NK’d, ya?

Scum wants you to be loud.

 

[Ourobolus]

Ouro, do you feel we should lynch Sorian?

I honestly don't think he is scum (maybe neutral), but if getting rid of him means we actually get on the right track for once i am all for it. Would rather Panda or fat go though.

 

[Ourobolus]

Not really. If you needed to be silenced you would of been NK’d, ya?

Scum wants you to be loud.

WIFOM - people were already bitching about you going up for a lynch even before I was silenced

and also I am clearly frustrated which I am sure is hilarious for scum

 

[acohrs]

You're doing that on purpose at this point. You're quoting me and not actually answering the question and then trying to flip it on me.

Speaking of, is there a vote count?

Who, little old ne?

 

[Faddy]

vote: faddy

The ever helpful Zeusy post

 

[The Wizard]

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

Did you targeting dusk night 3 give you any increased confidence on your read of him?

 

[Ourobolus]

I mean so far there don't appear to be any no-kill nights and he chose different people each time so unless he got super lucky there doesn't look like a Serial Killer in play. So his actions don't tell us anything either way.

 

[Verelios]

Fiiiiine.

Lord of Castemere targeted Faddy on night 1.

I targeted Fat4All on night 2 (At random, since I actually hadn't read the thread by then)

And, obviously, I targeted Dusk on night 3.

What exactly did I do, well, hopefully you can read about it on my death post.

Well, that bolsters my confidence. Holy hell, what would you have done if we ran a dusk lynch on this shit? These gambits are poison.

 

[SalvaPot]

Did you targeting dusk night 3 give you any increased confidence on your read of him?

No.

 

[Ty4on]

Day 4 votes (#1797):

kawl_usc (2)
sorian 1474 (1565)
faddy 1566 (1624)
dusk soldier 1645
faddy 1714

giant panda (2)
ccs 1688
salvapot 1742

fat4all (1)
giant panda 1511 (1719)
nomadic sparks 1563

zeusy (1)
sorian 1565 (1651)
fat4all 1686

acohrs (1)
sorian 1651

penguin (1)
the wizard 1705

sorian (1)
acohrs 1780

faddy (1)
zeusy 1788



Day 4 ends:

Automated vote tally here

9 votes for majority

 

[Verelios]

I mean so far there don't appear to be any no-kill nights and he chose different people each time so unless he got super lucky there doesn't look like a Serial Killer in play. So his actions don't tell us anything either way.

That's

1). A pretty odd conclusion when you don't know night actions
2). Pretty optimistic
3). If you turn out to be neutral, very convenient

 

[Faddy]

I mean so far there don't appear to be any no-kill nights and he chose different people each time so unless he got super lucky there doesn't look like a Serial Killer in play. So his actions don't tell us anything either way.

There also doesn't appear to be any Vig kills. So if he is a Jailer he might have hit either the Mafia target, the Vig target or the Vig each night. It seems an unlikely but possible scenario.