-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rick & Morty [Mafia] |OT| Someone's been spending too much time around glowing rocks
- Thread starter AbsolutBro
- Start date
Scum typically wouldn't have a re-direct and I think it is unlikely they have a roleblocker since we have a weak cop so strategies like Follow the Cop would not come into play.
It's good to talk hypotheticals but when something happens it's a bit too late for oops.
A roleblocker is an easy counter to anything, follow the cop isn't it's only use.
The Wizard
Member
Buying into Soriams claim, explains his confidence at certain moments quite well. The _ is town posts were starting to look odd but line up with his claim.
I'm kinda busy for the next hour but hope to be back to contribute to the discussion for the final vote frenzy. I'm feeling a bit better on my Penguin vote now especially with his reduction of today's events to "a bunch of finger pointing" but if nobody else is seeing it I'm interested in other options, less so kawl/Zeusy as I'm not seeing much there but would lean zeusy of the two.
Based on the Dorian info above we can be reasonably confident Panda is town, which gives this Dusk post brownie points in my book since he would likely have less hesitation about Panda as scum.
I'm kinda busy for the next hour but hope to be back to contribute to the discussion for the final vote frenzy. I'm feeling a bit better on my Penguin vote now especially with his reduction of today's events to "a bunch of finger pointing" but if nobody else is seeing it I'm interested in other options, less so kawl/Zeusy as I'm not seeing much there but would lean zeusy of the two.
Ok, so if Sorian is to be believed we can narrow this down a bit:
-
01. Sorian [m]
13. CCS [m]
18. Fat4all [m]
19. Giant Panda [m]
22. Ourobolus [m]
-
02. Dr. Worm [m]
03. Dusk Soldier [m]
05. Acohrs [m]
07. Zeusy [m]
10. Kawl_USC [m]
11. The Wizard [m]
14. Verelios [m]
15. Faddy [m]
16. SalvaPot [m]
17. Nomadic Sparks [m]
21. Penguin [m]
Thats 5 assumed Town, leaving 11. My guess would be there are either 4 or 5 Scum, and maybe one Neutral. That puts us at a bit under a 50/50 shot at hitting Scum today. I still feel like Zeusy would be a good target for today, but Ill look over a few more options, looking back over today specifically as I just kinda glossed over it before.
-
01. Sorian [m]
13. CCS [m]
18. Fat4all [m]
19. Giant Panda [m]
22. Ourobolus [m]
-
02. Dr. Worm [m]
03. Dusk Soldier [m]
05. Acohrs [m]
07. Zeusy [m]
10. Kawl_USC [m]
11. The Wizard [m]
14. Verelios [m]
15. Faddy [m]
16. SalvaPot [m]
17. Nomadic Sparks [m]
21. Penguin [m]
Thats 5 assumed Town, leaving 11. My guess would be there are either 4 or 5 Scum, and maybe one Neutral. That puts us at a bit under a 50/50 shot at hitting Scum today. I still feel like Zeusy would be a good target for today, but Ill look over a few more options, looking back over today specifically as I just kinda glossed over it before.
Ive actually caught out Scum acohrs in the past for dropping a vote and then avoiding the end of the day (in Arkham Mafia), its not much like his Town play.
Though, acohrs didnt avoid the end of D3 really, and even called possible negative attention to himself by flopping their vote between me and Zee, so Im not certain where they land in this game.
Though, acohrs didnt avoid the end of D3 really, and even called possible negative attention to himself by flopping their vote between me and Zee, so Im not certain where they land in this game.
Thanks
Zeuzy gives no fucks, I like this guy.
How would you like to test it?
lynch either you or one of your town confirms
So you would like to cause another mislynch just to check things out? Really? How about you let scum handle their own kills instead of lynching for them.
That is probably not getting us anywhere.
1) We have very little reason to doubt Sorian.
2) There is a chance we have other power roles that can help prove Sorian's claim.
Also odds are better if we hit one of the not confirmed players.
I mean, if your shelf life is already limited, I'd rather confirm your results now
What the what? Why? Just assuming we lynch one today, scum Nk's the other and we're left with one town and I guess CCS if it's true.
Not to mention a waste of a day.
What the hell is this logic. If you think Sorian has a limited shelf life we will soon get his flip and then we will have confirmation.
Giant Panda
Member
Well, town's got to have some sort of investigative role right? No one has counter-claimed Sorian.
This logic is flawed, but you know that, right?
Not always the case. We have Masons which sorta confirm each other.
This doesn't make any sense. Dying by my own action or a NK is infinitely better than being lynched. Every wrong lynch moves us closer to a loss.
Giant Panda
Member
That's true. But I can't remember the last game I played that didn't have something more than that.
That was actually my thought. I want to give town points just on the basis that I don't think scum would be that stupid.
Lol.
I think Dr. Worm is an option to keep in mind going forward, but Im not too sure if they are actually scum. Worm put decent pressure on me on D2, and then on D3 was given the vote block to try and dig them in even more against me, but instead it seemed to soften their stance on me a bit. Their early aggressive behavior was good, but theyve slowed down a bit which is worrying.
Im a bit mixed on them.
Day 4 votes (#1883):
kawl_usc (2)
sorian 1474 (1565)
faddy 1566 (1624)
dusk soldier 1645
faddy 1714
fat4all (1)
giant panda 1511 (1719)
nomadic sparks 1563
dusk soldier (1)
salvapot 1642 (1742)
giant panda 1719 (1734)
salvapot 1813
acohrs (1)
sorian 1651
giant panda (1)
ccs 1688
salvapot 1742 (1813)
penguin (1)
the wizard 1705
sorian (1)
acohrs 1780
faddy (1)
zeusy 1788
Day 4 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
kawl_usc (2)
dusk soldier 1645
faddy 1714
fat4all (1)
nomadic sparks 1563
dusk soldier (1)
salvapot 1813
acohrs (1)
sorian 1651
giant panda (1)
ccs 1688
penguin (1)
the wizard 1705
sorian (1)
acohrs 1780
faddy (1)
zeusy 1788
Day 4 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
I don't believe that. There are votes for and against him to track.
what was this from, anyway
Its pretty much just been you and me for, and everyone else at about eeeehhhh levels, though.
It just aint enough right now.
Maybe a bit later in the game.
People who are "confirmed" town from Sorian's claim should now be actively working together to pick a lynch
There seems to be a lot of players who im considering who are afk, though.
Dusk, acohrs, Kawl, id be surprised of any of them pop back up in the next 30 mins.
Being absent doesn't make someone not scum.
I'm fine with most people now that my cards on the table, my town reads are clear and acohrs is my clear preference. Gun to my head, I'd say Faddy is my second. But I'd entertain a Zeusy, Penguin,Worm, or Nomadic lynch all to varying degrees though none of those are a ton more than a random weird occurrence or just being too quiet.
That list isn't even exhaustive since I forgot about Kawl and he isn't a bad choice just annoying he isn't here.
That list isn't even exhaustive since I forgot about Kawl and he isn't a bad choice just annoying he isn't here.
Im not saying it doesnt, im just saying complaining about voting for an afk seems kinda moot where theres been a lot of afks today in general.
There's been a lot of afks in the game in general. I call out Kawl because he at least said something about a wedding.
Yeah it's a bad weekend
NYCC in the East Coast, Canadian Thanksgiving, Columbus Day weekend, but I mean I was upfront with my missing status, have others offered any updates?
And in my case, I don't feel it's the first day Nomadic has been mostly quiet.
Day 4 votes (#1898):
kawl_usc (3)
sorian 1474 (1565)
faddy 1566 (1624)
dusk soldier 1645
faddy 1714
verelios 1892
acohrs (2)
sorian 1651
ccs 1895
fat4all (1)
giant panda 1511 (1719)
nomadic sparks 1563
nomadic sparks (1)
faddy 1624 (1690)
penguin 1890
dusk soldier (1)
salvapot 1642 (1742)
giant panda 1719 (1734)
salvapot 1813
penguin (1)
the wizard 1705
sorian (1)
acohrs 1780
faddy (1)
zeusy 1788
Day 4 ends:
Automated vote tally here
kawl_usc (3)
dusk soldier 1645
faddy 1714
verelios 1892
acohrs (2)
sorian 1651
ccs 1895
fat4all (1)
nomadic sparks 1563
nomadic sparks (1)
penguin 1890
dusk soldier (1)
salvapot 1813
penguin (1)
the wizard 1705
sorian (1)
acohrs 1780
faddy (1)
zeusy 1788
Day 4 ends:
Automated vote tally here