• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Rottenwatch: AVATAR (82%)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jibril said:
4ptduh.jpg

this scene is a visual orchestra.
Weird, I don't remember this.
 
Jtwo said:
Weird, I don't remember this.

Right after Jake tames his Banshee, they begin talking about how to fly and the art behind flying a Banshee. It's rather short, in the middle of a montage of sorts.
 
Dead said:
- Earth scenes consisted of: street shot and Jakes apartment (mentioned by Cameron) along with a barfight and an alley outside the bar where the corp guys originally approach Jake.


Sounds a bit like Star Trek actually... I am sort of glad Cameron made the cut and left Earth a bit vague. Whereas at the moment we can assume that Earth is a bit like ours, just worst, this might bring too much comparison with Blade Runner. It would almost be as alien to us as Pandora is and then we would have to understand two worlds instead of one.

Also wondered if his brother getting killed was ever a conspiracy to get a marine into the avatar program.
 
Jtwo said:
Weird, I don't remember this.
Jake tames the Banshee. They start having fun and retelling the day.

Neytiri: I switch, like this...
2j5mo1w.png


2ch4x7c.png


Brrrmmm... Strong left.

Jake: yeah yeah! and I went like so:
24m9o40.png

Or something along those lines.
 
2nd viewing tickets for tomorrow afternoon purchased.

This time in ReadD 3D. Last time was in bufu Kentucky. It was 3D but kinda gave me a headache over time.

Such an amazing experience overall.
 
GhaleonEB said:
Agree, that's a perfect summation of my thoughts on Avatar.

I loved this little vignette. Most movies would have skipped it, just focusing on the spectacle of the flight. But this one moment brought it down a notch and made it more real; how Jake was learning the mechanics of flying (adjusting properly for the wind, taking the correct angles on approaches), and how he and Neytiri were bonding during his training. Avatar's story is pretty straight forward, but it's got these kind of moments throughout that just add so much to the characters and the story.

I really think Cameron's story telling instincts are underrated by those who dismiss the overall framework of the plot as being too familiar. He grounds the fantastic in a way that's instantly relatable.
Well said sir, I loved that seen a lot too, it's such a damn shame it cost so much to make this. It would have been soo much better as a 4 hour epic, with little scenes like this but so much more detailed. I seen it mentioned it the thread earlier and I had the same thought about this movie being similar to "Dances with Wolves, and I love that it was all about the "Alien"(Costner) becoming one of the Indians, and growing to love them as a people, and eventually saw himself as one, I also think he should have portrayed Jake's and Neytiri's love for one another more, or make Quaritch a little more less one-dimensional. Example, he could have made a scene where he was looking at his kids/wife or something not sure, and showing that he missed them dearly, something I'm not sure. Fox should have just given him and Bil and made it, 4 or 5 hours( or in 2 movie released 4 months apart! I do agree the story wasn't the best story ever, but the visuals are there, the wonderful acting(expectantly Zoe), but the fine detail in the (character's) wasn't. I guess it's just one of those things. Where you need more time to flesh out the character's. It still worked though, I'm not saying this is a knock on the film, I just reaaallly liked it. It has it all there, for more(sequals), and if so.. then it could turn into Cameron's own ""trilogy"". I just hope he does them, and makes it his. Because I hate when they make something soo awesome and just give it to another director on the sequals, it's just not the same! Don't worry I know this was/is ... wishful thinking......
 
Dead said:
- He says Earth scenes were about 99% finished and when they were cut, everybody was pretty surprised

- Earth scenes aren't that long, they are part of a brief introductory.

- Earth scenes consisted of: street shot and Jakes apartment (mentioned by Cameron) along with a barfight and an alley outside the bar where the corp guys originally approach Jake.

- Says a lot of nice character development and depth was dropped. Says that should there be an extended cut, it should be at least 30 minutes longer rather than 12 (a number Cameron brandied about in an interview)

- Lot of trimmed dialogue from Quaritch here and there that really gave you a better feel for the character

- Regarding there only being 12 or so minutes of finished/near finished footage left over, he says there should be a good batch of other material that is in pretty good shape as well (meaning, probably near-finished). All depends on how much is spent on making an extended cut.

- About the Deleted scene picture posted several pages back (Here), he says: "it's a pretty awesome acting/cg-acting moment as well, and was fully finished AFAIK"
That's some good shit right there. Though it only helps make the wait for the extended edition more annoying. Especially since it's not going to be coming for a while. I'm actually wondering which will get released first, that or perhaps the novel. Jeez, Cameron has a lot on his plate, especially if he takes on The Dive as well.
neoism said:
Well said sir, I loved that seen a lot too, it's such a damn shame it cost so much to make this. It would have been soo much better as a 4 hour epic...
I would imagine that Cameron wanted to be that long too. But in the end, technical and audience considerations had to be taken into account (again, IMAX runtime limit and if audiences can tolerate long 3D movies) which forced them to cut it to about 2 and a half hours. For the home edition, well, Cameron can probably make it as long as he wants now, it just depends on how many scenes he still would want in an extended cut.
 
Dead said:
Was reading an Avatar thread at http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?f=2&t=833716&page=1&pp=15 and one of the posters who worked on the movie let out several little nuggets regarding deleted/trimmed scenes.

rundown:

- He says Earth scenes were about 99% finished and when they were cut, everybody was pretty surprised

- Earth scenes aren't that long, they are part of a brief introductory.

- Earth scenes consisted of: street shot and Jakes apartment (mentioned by Cameron) along with a barfight and an alley outside the bar where the corp guys originally approach Jake.

- Says a lot of nice character development and depth was dropped. Says that should there be an extended cut, it should be at least 30 minutes longer rather than 12 (a number Cameron brandied about in an interview)

- Lot of trimmed dialogue from Quaritch here and there that really gave you a better feel for the character

- Regarding there only being 12 or so minutes of finished/near finished footage left over, he says there should be a good batch of other material that is in pretty good shape as well (meaning, probably near-finished). All depends on how much is spent on making an extended cut.

- About the Deleted scene picture posted several pages back (Here), he says: "it's a pretty awesome acting/cg-acting moment as well, and was fully finished AFAIK"
2wqhm5e.gif
 
To be honest, I would take a Kingdom of Heaven level Director's Cut, a fully realized version of this film, over a sequel. I liked how the KoH DC worked with an intermission. Truly epic, but as a singular work of art. A sequel might be messy, takes too long and Cameron might get tired of it.
 
We could've used more time with Jake prior to him joining the Avatar program. That one scene where he finally gets to use his legs again as an Avatar would have held far more poignancy if we'd spent a longer time with paraplegic Jake. We would've had greater overall attachment to the character, which would have buffed up the love story and pretty much every conflict he becomes involved in.
 
Jibril said:
Jake tames the Banshee. They start having fun and retelling the day.

Neytiri: I switch, like this...
2j5mo1w.png


2ch4x7c.png


Brrrmmm... Strong left.

Jake: yeah yeah! and I went like so:
24m9o40.png

Or something along those lines.

I just realized the Na'vi have Simpsons fingers. Mind blown.
 
Combine said:
I would imagine that Cameron wanted to be that long too. But in the end, technical and audience considerations had to be taken into account (again, IMAX runtime limit and if audiences can tolerate long 3D movies) which forced them to cut it to about 2 and a half hours. For the home edition, well, Cameron can probably make it as long as he wants now, it just depends on how many scenes he still would want in an extended cut.
If anyone could have had an intermission, it's Cameron!
 
neoism said:
If anyone could had had an intermission, it's Cameron!
I laughed, but even now it's hard to remember just how much of a risk Avatar was. A hugely expensive, original, sci-fi mostly-CG movie filmed in 3D and released during the holidays. Just two weeks ago this was a huge question mark.

I'm guessing if Cameron knew how positive the reception would be and in particular how well the 3D has been embraced he would have added a bit more time, at least up until the IMAX run time limit.
 
neoism said:
If anyone could had had an intermission, it's Cameron!

On opening night the theatre I went to had an intermission for about 15min. About halfway through it however, they announced there wasn't supposed to be one and so to apologize they gave everyone free refills on popcorn and soda. :rolleyes: Maybe if it were 3 1/2 hrs or 4 an intermission might work.
 
RedShift said:
Na'vi do, Avatars don't. It's stuff like that which makes this film awesome, tiny details never explicitly said.
Woah, I sure missed that. I did knew that Na'vis had four fingers though..
 
Combine said:
I didn't see the theatrical version of Watchmen, but I think I remember what people were complaining about. Was it the scene with
the death of Hollis Mason
?


Yes, that is the scene. I think you can watch it on youtube. I thought the scene was pretty well done.
 
Im just hoping and praying that seeing the worldwide praise and these incredible box office numbers for Avatar has inspired Cameron to say GTFO to The Dive, and jump back into Pandora for Avatar 2. Add to that what happened with the Terminator franchise.

You already spent a decade dicking around underseas, James. The silver screen needs you.
 
Never read Battle Angel, but I'd settle for it seeing as it's a hard R Sci Fi with naked ladies. No one can shoot tits like Cameron.





But I'd still rather have Avatar 2.
 
Solo said:
Im just hoping and praying that seeing the worldwide praise and these incredible box office numbers for Avatar has inspired Cameron to say GTFO to The Dive, and jump back into Pandora for Avatar 2. Add to that what happened with the Terminator franchise.

You already spent a decade dicking around underseas, James. The silver screen needs you.
I dunno, I think Cameron's in love with the underseas. Besides he'd probably use it as a partial excuse to get inspired for the sequels to come up with new vistas and creatures. I just hope that the project doesn't take him too long.

There's no way in hell Cameron will give up the franchise though, he's stated he learned from doing so with both Aliens and Terminator, especially since Avatar is his dream project.
 
Dead said:
The Dive - 2012
AVTR2 - 2013
Battle Angel - 2015
AVTR3 - 2016


FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUU
Considering how much Avatar aged Cameron, he's going to be a skeleton with a wisp of white hair if he tries that schedule.
 
Personally, Id like to see:

- Avatar 2: 2012
- Avatar 3: 2014
- Battle Angel: after the Avatar trilogy is done
- The Dive: never
 
Solo said:
Personally, Id like to see:

- Avatar 2: 2012
- Avatar 3: 2014
- Battle Angel: after the Avatar trilogy is done
- The Dive: never
I cant see Avatar 2 being ready that soon. Even with the fact that they have all the tech in place and if Cameron made A2 his next project, I cant imagine seeing it any sooner than 2013
 
I saw this tonight (in 2D) and enjoyed it way more than I thought I would. I have to be honest and say that all of the internet hype actually had the opposite effect on me and I started to anticipate it being a big letdown, but it blew me away in a lot of ways.

Obviously the world of Pandora was what struck me the most. I loved how it was crafted, the creatures within it and the way in which everything was connected. Clearly a lot of effort went into the construction and I'll happily admit I sat there a lot of the time simply going "so prettyyyy" in my head. :lol

I felt the story dragged at times as I was watching it, but as it reached the conclusion I suddenly became very appreciative of the character building that took place. I'll spoiler the rest to be safe:
What really struck me was the way in which I loathed the humans. Usually it's okay to enjoy some people being killed because they are being killed by good people, but in this you have a whole other species doing the killing and it's completely justified. It was gut wrenching when the tree was burnt down and during the battle I was loving every single body that flew from the helicopters. In terms of characters the only one I truly felt for was Neytiri, who had a fantastic performance. The bad army dude was pretty damn fun to hate too, as generic as he was.

So yeah, it's definitely not the best film of the year, but it was much better than I expected. I quite regret the fact I couldn't see it in 3D as I'm sure it's awesome like that, but nevermind.
 
I have been reading up on this thread ever so often, loving the craziness of it all

I love the universe Cameron has created

I'm playing Jame's Cameron Avatar: The Game, it really helps flesh out the movie + universe so much

I'm really liking it so far, so if you enjoyed the movie and starting to feel that itch to go back to Pandora, you can't go wrong with this game.
 
Dead said:
I cant see Avatar 2 being ready that soon. Even with the fact that they have all the tech in place and if Cameron made A2 his next project, I cant imagine seeing it any sooner than 2013

Well, like you said, the tech is in place (of course they'd keep refining and improving it, but they're no longer reinventing the wheel), which is a major timesink for the first film. Then Cameron has said that he already has outlines for the second and third film. The actors were probably signed to a standard three movie deal way back when, so the important cast would be locked up. Really the time comes down to a) how long it takes Cameron to write a script and b) how long it takes to shoot principal photography. Post should take about as long as it did on the first film, but maybe a bit shorter now that WETA/ILM have gone through the experience once.

James Horner is already done his score. He is just reworking Aliens :D
 
Solo said:
Personally, Id like to see:

- Avatar 2: 2012
- Avatar 3: 2014
- Battle Angel: after the Avatar trilogy is done
- The Dive: never

Realistically

Avatar book 2013
Avatar 2 2014
Avatar 3 2016 (they will be filmed together)

Battle Angel, probably produce only. Cameron only do stuff no one has done before. I can't think of any new technology that he can't incorporate into A2 A3.

Afterward he probably will spend his money on more deep sea diving, maybe even funding private manned Moon mission. He is that kind of guy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom