I have the same feeling except exactly the opposite way, I thought I saw an average sony conference and I see tons of people gushing about how godlike it all was, like I don't even understand. I kinda understood it last year but this year? nah son.
Eh, I don't think anyone is comparing it to last years conference, but it was definitely solid. I'm seeing mostly negativity on gaf though, and very little of it seems to be based on anything other than "it's different".
My initial reaction was disappointment. Obviously we don't know what the game is going to actually be like until someone figures out the puzzle but from what I've played an un-scary P.T clone isn't doing much for me.
I'd say as of right now I'm just very conflicted on what this game may or may not be. I'm trying to hold off judging too much.
That's fair. I've yet to play the demo, but I feel like Capcom deserves to be given a proper chance with this new approach to the series. You'd think RE4 would have shown people that not only can RE mean more than traditional RE1 style controls/exploration, but to also not rush to conclusions when the series decides to change/reinvent itself.