It's a very cool narrative experience with stunning graphics, I love this sort of thing. I wonder why this game gets shit for lack of gameplay, is it because it sort of hints at being an action game with a bit of combat? People, myself included, appreciate Telltale games like The Walking Dead, Life is Strange, Detroit Become Human, Supermassive games like Until Dawn, Firewatch, Soma, The Invincible and so on and this is game has more gameplay than those, even if it is limited. I feel like people expected something it isn't. It's almost like it would have been higher rated if they scrapped combat altogether. Maybe it sailed a bit far into AAA territory for a narrative game, these tend to be AA and perhaps expectations change.