The Undertaker of New Generation was such a boring clod in and out of the ring just because of how they wanted his character(or lack of) working.
How I remember it was that it seemed like they were trying to keep Taker a big unstoppable monster face character but at the same time constantly try to find reasons for him to not go after the title belt.
Just like the finger poke of doom, I'll never understand the complaints about this. If you want to talk long-term ramifications because of a lack of an interesting follow-through storyline then sure. But the act itself? Who else was going to beat Goldberg? Hogan? The only other option I could think of is Steiner and Steiner wasn't ready for it then.
I think you have another mega face be the guy who ends Goldberg's streak. Probably Sting.
That way another face gets a major rub in the process, plus you can have him and Goldberg shake hands after the match and you can build the whole aftermath in a way that doesn't ruin the mystique of Goldberg. Like "oh look, it took FUCKING STING to beat Goldberg, every bad guy is still totally fucked"