The reason why people say he's a bad source is because was a GAF member and he was completely full of shit for the better part of a decade. It was clear that he was absolutely DESPERATE to become one of the famous leakers from this forum, but he was wrong most (if not all) of the time. Yeah it seems he's finally gotten his hands on an actual source in the industry but his reputation is still in the gutter because that's what happens when you lie about such things before you've even built a solid reputation.