Skyward Sword review thread [Newest Reviews - Cubed3 10/10, GC: A, AusGamers: 7/10]

Always Honest said:
Huh, the Edge review was allready quoted in that trailer?
Click to expand...

ONM and Edge are both made by Future Publishing, and this trailer is for the Golden Joystick Awards in London tonight - which is a GamesMaster magazine event, a mag and event also made / organised by Future.

So basically, yeah, they quoted their own review in the trailer.
 
From the Destructoid preview:

One thing I haven't really had a chance to get into in my last couple of previews of The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword is how much more immersive the entire world actually is compared to past Zelda games. In some ways, it's almost like playing a "Bethesda-lite" version of Zelda.
Click to expand...

IGN WAS RIGHT! :O
 
I think this will turn into some kind of historical event as far as EDGE reviews are concerned.

EDGE giving a 10 for a game in what is by all accounts outdated hardware.

wow, mind blown.
 
Meikiyou said:
He didn't talk to you, he talked to me =C
Click to expand...

YGetq.jpg
 
Only 10/10 from Edge? Guess you can blame their UK bias as usual. If this was a British game I wouldn't be surprised if they scored it 11/10.
 
sphinx said:
I think this will turn into some kind of historical event as far as EDGE reviews are concerned.

EDGE giving a 10 for a game in what is by all accounts outdated hardware.

wow, mind blown.
Click to expand...

have you heard of these two games called super mario galaxy and super mario galaxy 2?
 
sphinx said:
I think this will turn into some kind of historical event as far as EDGE reviews are concerned.

EDGE giving a 10 for a game in what is by all accounts outdated hardware.

wow, mind blown.
Click to expand...

Super Mario Galaxy 1 & 2 also have a 10 too. They just like good games :3
 
sphinx said:
I think this will turn into some kind of historical event as far as EDGE reviews are concerned.

EDGE giving a 10 for a game in what is by all accounts outdated hardware.

wow, mind blown.
Click to expand...

Third 10 EDGE gives to a Wii game though.
 
Nice to hear it is already getting such high accolades. Can't wait to play this on Dolphin! I'm hoping it runs without a hitch day 1.
 
Well, I don't really give Edge's reviews much merit (wildly inconsistent), but I suppose a 10 from them is an achievement. So long as you ignore the one they gave Halo 3.

Anyway, I'm pumped. I do have this feeling that it could be one of the, if not the best Zelda yet!
 
radioheadrule83 said:
People are mentioning the Mario Galaxy / other Wii games like it makes the score more dubious... SMG 1 & 2 are AAA 10/10 games!
Click to expand...
By all means, SMG 1 & 2 are the best games of this gen. Here's hoping they are dethroned by Zelda SS.
 
The Mana Legend said:
TP would have been 8/1o+ material had it just been straight up dungeons and none of that wolf/twilight zone nonsense. Seriously ruined the game for me (besides the empty world that was far too large, and the crappy fishing ;_;).
Click to expand...
lol wut?
Fish was great and far better than all of tww's mini games. TWW also had a large empty world.
 
This game is gonna be amazing, too bad I won't have a way of playing it, ever. Enjoyed the fuck out of Wind Waker and Ocarina of Time, but Twilight Princess, not so much. What game in the series does it resemble the most?
 
jred250 said:
He is a king that has been transformed INTO a dog you ******* idiot! SHOW YOUR KING RESPECT. I WAS ALWAYS ON YOUR SIDE NOBEL KING
Click to expand...
see now look what you did he is not a dog anymore he is a king not a dog and so i was wrong about calling him a dog with a crown on because he is now a person with a crown on his head and therefore full of smartness because I was wrong

I indirectly got stumpo to change his avatar, do I get a cookie
 
Drek said:
Except that you're going off of a score from EDGE, who don't know shit about shit.

The Witcher = 5
The Witcher 2 = 6
GTA IV = 10
God of War II = 7 (after giving GoW an 8)
Sid Meier's Pirates! = 6 (PC version)
Dark Cloud 2 = 6
Warhammer 40K Dawn of War II = 7
Little Big Planet = 6
Zone of the Enders: The 2nd Runner = 4
Jet Grind Radio = 4

I could go on, but I'm pretty sure EDGE has at least what I consider the wrong idea for a review publication. Instead of viewing it from a "will people who like this genre/franchise/etc. like this game?" standpoint its entirely "I like it/I don't like it".

Add the fact that their "I like it/I don't like it" has a sliding scale that apparently gives bonus points to UK based developers and Nintendo titles, while taking them away from Sony titles (EDGE is nearly without fail more negative on every Sony game or Sony console exclusive than industry average).

They aren't a harsh reviewing publication, they're a shitty reviewing publication that tries to act like they hold games to a higher standard and use the full range of scoring when in reality they'll throw a perfect score on anything that strikes their fancy faster than anyone around. The only reason their reviews show any real range is that they love throwing a 5-7 on any really good game that doesn't personally click with them.

Why the rant? Because I'm sick of seeing public sentiment go "LOLZ, EDGE!" when a game they like gets a low score (like Dead Island getting a 3/10) but then acting like EDGE is somehow a stalwart of integrity when they give a 9 or 10 to a game they're excited for.

They're a bunch of twits with quite possibly the most obtuse perspective on game reviews you'll ever find. They should generally just be dismissed and ignored. That simple.
Click to expand...
I'm pretty sure LittleBigPlanet got a 10 from Edge.
 
Vulcano's assistant said:
Third 10 EDGE gives to a Wii game though.
Click to expand...

well, I stand corrected.

Still, giving a 10 to a Wii game in holidays 2011, 5 freaking years after the Wii and its already-on-launch outdated hardware was released is mindblowing.

Awesome, can't wait.
 
Stumpokapow said:
They gave the GBA version a 4. They gave the DC version an 8. He searched some database for "Jet Grind Radio" not knowing that the DC version is called "Jet Set Radio" everywhere else in the world except North America.

The LittleBigPlanet score is also their score for the PSP version, not the PS3 version, which they gave a 10.

And I'm guessing his God of War "3" getting a 7 was that they gave a 7 to Chains of Olympus. They gave an 8 to God of War 3.

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL.
Click to expand...



Deeeeeestroyed. Oh...my...god... Wow.
 
radioheadrule83 said:
People are mentioning the Mario Galaxy / other Wii games like it makes the score more dubious... SMG 1 & 2 are AAA 10/10 games!
Click to expand...

Damn right, both are in every way deserving of a 10. Absolutely excited beyond belief for SS now - haters/doubters be damned.

I can't wait for the latest issue to arrive in the mail, but given the inconsistency of their international delivery I'll probably be finished the game by then.
 
radioheadrule83 said:
People are mentioning the Mario Galaxy / other Wii games like it makes the score more dubious... SMG 1 & 2 are AAA 10/10 games!
Click to expand...

Going to start taking notes in this thread. People who down-play incredible works like Mario Galaxy just because they are "inferior" tech are making it to the list for future review.
 
A flagship Nintendo franchise getting a "10" isn't mindblowing at all.

I know some fans weren't thrilled that they were evolving the stale Zelda formula, but I was happy to see it, and it looks like it's paid off.
 
It seems rare for Edge to hand out 10 scores. As far as Wii games go, it looks like only the two Mario Galaxy games received that honor.

Super Mario Galaxy - 10
Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 10
Twilight Princess - 9
No More Heroes - 9
Xenoblade Chronicles - 9
Smash Bros Brawl - 9
No More Heroes - 9
Sin & Punishment 2 - 8
Punch-Out!! - 8
Kirby's Epic Yarn - 8
GoldenEye 007 - 8
No More Heroes 2 - 7
Monster Hunter Tri - 7
Red Steel 2 - 7
Tatsunoko vs. Capcom - 7
Metroid Prime 3 - 7
Donkey Kong Country Returns - 7
Wii Sports Resort - 7
Animal Crossing: City Folk -7
Geometry Wars Galaxies - 7
Red Steel 2 - 7
Epic Mickey - 7
Mario Kart Wii - 6
Muramasa: The Demon Blade - 6
Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - 6
MadWorld - 6
Sonic Colors - 6
Red Steel - 5
The Conduit - 4
The Conduit 2 - 4
Soul Calibur Legends - 2
 
daakusedo said:
ZOTY
Click to expand...

"Taking into account all competition, The Legend of Zelda: Skyward sword is without a doubt, unequivocally, the greatest The Legend of Zelda title of 2011."
 
EatChildren said:
"Taking into account all competition, The Legend of Zelda: Skyward sword is without a doubt, unequivocally, the greatest The Legend of Zelda title of 2011."
Click to expand...
That quote makes no sense. SS is the only Zelda title of 2011.
 
JonCha said:
That quote makes no sense. SS is the only Zelda title of 2011.
Click to expand...
Like Nintendo, you've forgotten about Link's Awakening. Also Four Swords was released just a while back.
 
Chet Rippo said:
Ocarina of Time 3D
Click to expand...
But you already mentioned that. Also my comment was a dig at the fact that there is no music from Link's Awakening for the Zelda concert. OoT, on the other hand, is well represented.
 
sphinx said:
well, I stand corrected.

Still, giving a 10 to a Wii game in holidays 2011, 5 freaking years after the Wii and its already-on-launch outdated hardware was released is mindblowing.

Awesome, can't wait.
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure Edge would be offended by the idea that they'd mark down a game because of the hardware it's on.
 
CrunchyFrog said:
see now look what you did he is not a dog anymore he is a king not a dog and so i was wrong about calling him a dog with a crown on because he is now a person with a crown on his head and therefore full of smartness because I was wrong

I indirectly got stumpo to change his avatar, do I get a cookie
Click to expand...

blame space?
 
sphinx said:
well, I stand corrected.

Still, giving a 10 to a Wii game in holidays 2011, 5 freaking years after the Wii and its already-on-launch outdated hardware was released is mindblowing.

Awesome, can't wait.
Click to expand...
I really don't understand your logic here. So are you really saying later into the hardwares lifecycle you're surprised that such a good game could be achieved? I would think it would be just the opposite, and more highly rated games would come later in any consoles life as the developers get more used to the hardware.

Sure, the Wii was pretty much outdated spec-wise from the start, but that doesn't mean it can't have games that a reviewer thinks are head and shoulders above the rest. And as Dar as graphics, it should only be judged on what the console can do, not what's possible on other systems.
 
Wow, Stump, when did Mario return the rod to you?



Oh, and yeah, starting to get pretty hyped. Didn't expect that kind of score from Edge, of all magazines.


And everyone: stop giving a damn about whatever Jeff Gerstmann will say about this game. He lost interest long ago in almost anything that isn't an American-developed console shooter or a driving simulator. If he reviews it, he'll give it two or three stars, say that it's "the same game as all the other Zeldas" and complain that it doesn't have voice acting, and then he'll go back to chainsawing a slightly different-looking brown alien in the third Gears of War game released since Twilight Princess came out.

And yet, I still have hope that I'm wrong, for some reason.
 
Stumpokapow said:
Ah yes, Nintendo bias.

Random sampling of games developed by Nintendo, wholly owned subsidiaries, and external partners, from the west and the east, across genres, across the full score range, and across platformers. I'm sure there are scores both above and below the Metacritic that I've excluded, I literally just sorted by scores upwards and picked random stuff from platforms that Metacritic covers:

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon - Explorers of Time - 3 (MC 60) BELOW
Wario - Master of Disguise - 4 (MC 60) BELOW
Trace Memory R - 4 (MC 66) BELOW
Yoshi's Topsy-Turvy - 4 (MC 60) BELOW
Battalion Wars 2 - 5 (MC 75, bonus this is also a UK developer OMG BIAS) BELOW
DK King of Swing - 5 (MC 70) BELOW
Mario Kart Double Dash - 5 (MC 87--yes, they scored 37 points below the Metacritic average here) BELOW
Mario Strikers Charged - 6 (MC 79) BELOW
Excite Truck - 6 (MC 72) BELOW
Wario Land: Shake It - 6 (MC 78) BELOW
Hotel Dusk - 6 (MC 78) BELOW
Wii Sports Resort - 6 (MC 80) BELOW
Golden Sun - 7 (MC 91) BELOW
Tetris DS - 7 (MC 84) BELOW
New Super Mario Bros Wii - 7 (MC 87) BELOW
Drill Dozer - 7 (MC 81) BELOW
Professor Layton 1 - 7 (MC 85) BELOW
Paper Mario - 7 (MC 93) BELOW
DK Jungle Beat - 8 (MC 80) Exactly on Metacritic
Animal Crossing City Folk - 7 (MC 73) BELOW, but just one score bracket.
Punch-Out! - 8 (MC 86) BELOW, but just one score bracket
Minish Cap - 8 (MC 89) BELOW, but just one score bracket.
Twilight Princess - 9 (MC 95) BELOW, but just one score bracket.
Brawl - 9 (MC 93) BELOW, but just one score bracket.
M&L3 - Bowser's Inside Story - 9 (MC 90) Exactly on Metacritic
Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 10 (MC 97) FOUND IT! BIAS! HIGHER SCORE THAN METACRITIC! EDGE ALERT! ALERT! NINTENDO BIAS DETECTED! JOURNALISTIC SCANDAL! MONEYHATS! VENGEANCE AT LAST!!!!!


Edited with a second pass to fill out a few franchises that weren't represented in my original list.
Click to expand...

And... scene.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Infinity Nikki Review - IGN (9/10) > Stellar blade: IGN 7/10
NSFW  2 3
123
9K
tTHANOSs replied
Secret Level IGN Review: 5/10
Review  2 3
137
13K
Luc2010 replied
Splatoon 10 year anniversary.
News 
23
208
Starhowl replied
Doom: The Dark Ages Review Embargo Lifts May 9, at 7 am/10 am PDT/EDT, 3 pm/4 pm BST/CEST
12
208
Efren is G.O.A.T. replied
  • Locked
Edge scores Clair Obscur : E33 a 10/10, raising its Metacritic score to 93
News 
2
160
Orpheus replied
Top Bottom