Sliding the Switch in and out of the dock will inevitably scratch the screen

Is it too much to ask for proof is someone claims that the scratching and is happening to them? I don't believe it is.
naked-gun-nothing-to-see-here-reaction-frank-drebin-police-squad-13911001861.gif
 
Just jumped into this shitstorm. I'm not too concerned as I feel like this issue may be overblown, but are there any other reports of this happening? With proof, rather, I'm gonna get a screen protector eventually; but I'm not tryna fly off the handles and grab one this instant.

A little unusual if this was the case, hope it's not an 'inevitable' situation.
 
So.
After 12 pages of discussions.
Are there any reports of the screen being scratched by the dock besides the one in the OP?
Not just touching, but actually leaving scratches on the screen.

You have to remember that the console just got released today and the people in this thread are cautious about it already.
 
People didn't believe the ps4 sticks were breaking either.

Considering that, I'm inclined to believe at least some people can encounter this issue.
 
Where are all the people that said you can't get scratches when playing in your house haha?

I'm going to get a tempered screen protector ASAP.
 
I feel like as long as you're careful when you insert and take it out of the dock you should be fine. All these Switch day oner's probably are taking it in and out a million times over in a rough fashion.
 
You have to remember that the console just got released today and the people in this thread are cautious about it already.

It was mentioned off-hand in a video review I watched, but can't remember where I watched it. She said after a week it was already scratched due to the docking, but not over the screen area.
 
People didn't believe the ps4 sticks were breaking either.

Considering that, I'm inclined to believe at least some people can encounter this issue.
Definitely something that can be countered, it's just surprising that they wouldn't line the inside face of dock with felt or something soft.
 
There are tight space tolerances on the sides of the Switch (as in, it doesn't have a lot of wiggle-room from side to side), I assume? Then how are those scratches being made by docking it? If it was caused by that rubber bumper, there should be grooved vertical scratches, in a narrow range, not scratches going at different angles and some close to the edge of the screen and others farther away. There's a curved scratch a half-inch away!

It is odd. How do you get curved scratches moving it in and out of a dock where it only goes in vertically?

Also the little guides on the right and left sides don't have hard edges that make contact with the switch.. it's a flat surface.

That said it should have been a softer plastic for the dock internals, especially the guides that run on the right and left sides.

When I dock it I have the rear panel leaning against the back of the dock for sure.
 
Can someone else show some pictures of their switch as its docking or even a video if possible to reproduce the scenario?



Who're you talking to? Your post is pointless.

he had that response typed out in word ready to copy/paste for weeks now, lol
 
it doesn't use Gorilla glass? the Vita and the 3DS didn't also
Pebble Time Steel (at least) is using Gorilla Glass and is insanely scratch-prone...

Not because of Gorilla Glass, but because to improve the transparency, they had to add a non-reflective layer, and this layer is destroyed at the slightest "abuse".


Back on OP story, I find the shape of the scratches strange for damages because of insertion... But I'll see by myself tomorrow.
 
People didn't believe the ps4 sticks were breaking either.

Considering that, I'm inclined to believe at least some people can encounter this issue.

and this is what I'm thinking..

personally, I have never witnessed a PS4 stick coming apart (both launch controllers are still fine)

If anything, I'm guessing this may be more than 1 site.. but probably won't affect EVERY user.. like say the launch 3DS issue.
 
Some people are turning some scratches (which IMO shouldn't happen when using a product in intended/designed methods, especially on a $300 product) into this:
exploding-pinto-o.gif


It shouldn't happen, but it's not the end of the world either.
 
Damn, the Nintendo apologists are out in force today. Jesus guys, criticisms railed against the Switch isn't an attack on it. People don't seem to get this.

At the same time being a little skeptical of an issue isn't a defense Force. Those scratches are not uniform in direction or location. The 3ds scratching issue happened the same way repeatedly, which is what should be happening here because the console only goes in the dock one way.
 
Lmao at people saying they prefer plastic over glass because it doesn't break as easily when dropped. Maybe don't drop your shit? Y'all born slippy or what?
 
I guess 900p is more taxing than 720p. I guess you can argue docked clocks should be higher.
900p sure is more taxing, namely 1.875 times the pixels. Fortunately, GPU docked clock is twice higher than undocked.
 
Those scratches look like the Switch was put into a Jean pocket with a metal button or with keys. I'm sceptical for two reasons.

  1. There is a noticeable gap between the screen and dock.
  2. Plastic isn't hard enough to create deep gouges in glass like this on it's own. It could create scuffs, but not deep vertical gouges.

In grief i believe
 
There are tight space tolerances on the sides of the Switch (as in, it doesn't have a lot of wiggle-room from side to side), I assume? Then how are those scratches being made by docking it? If it was caused by that rubber bumper, there should be grooved vertical scratches, in a narrow range, not scratches going at different angles and some close to the edge of the screen and others farther away. There's a curved scratch a half-inch away!

I read this as if it were from an Ace Attorney game.
 
what worries me is if some debris or something falls into the dock that you're unaware of. Not like you're going to check that theres something in there everytime you dock the Switch.
 
I only want a glass screen protector, but I'm not seeing one at GameStop or Best Buy. Those plastic ones are junk.

I thought I read in the early previews that there was some sort of padding? I never inspected my dock, but I can imagine there being an issue with scratching.
 
900p sure is more taxing, namely 1.875 times more pixels. Fortunately, GPU docked clock is twice higher than undocked.
1600x900 is 0.5625 more pixels than 1280x720.

Going back on topic, yeah, I'd expect dock-caused scratches to look pretty straight.
 
Lmao at people saying they prefer plastic over glass because it doesn't break as easily when dropped. Maybe don't drop your shit? Y'all born slippy or what?
I know people and I've seen dozens of strangers on the bus using smartphones with cracked screens. I'm sure you do too so maybe ask one of those people? It isn't exactly an uncommon sight.

At the same time being a little skeptical of an issue isn't a defense Force. Those scratches are not uniform in direction or location. The 3ds scratching issue happened the same way repeatedly, which is what should be happening here because the console only goes in the dock one way.
Your explanation makes sense. It's definitely weird.
 
Lmao at people saying they prefer plastic over glass because it doesn't break as easily when dropped. Maybe don't drop your shit? Y'all born slippy or what?

I've owned 5 smart phones over the years. I can count on one hand how many times I dropped them all combined. None have ever shattered but as careful as I am they have dropped on me. Accidents happen.
 
Right but I guess in every situation that won't correlate to 2x performance.
Or they pushed more things on screen/upped the IQ additionally in docked mode. Either way, claiming that 'switch drops frames when in docked mode because insufficiently higher clocks' is as ridiculous a claim to make without a profiling tool as they come.

1600x900 is 0.5625 more pixels than 1280x720.
Is that what BoTW renders at? Otherwise 1920x900 is 1.875x 1280x720.
 
I know people and I've seen dozens of strangers on the bus using smartphones with cracked screens. I'm sure you do too so maybe ask one of those people? It isn't exactly an uncommon sight.

My phone has a crack line half the size of my screen. It's on tempered glass though so it's not really that bad. I never bothered changing it though since it hasn't affected my daily use and I can't feel the cracks themselves. They kinda get in the way of watching a video though sometimes.
 
So, I'll comment on my experience.

I experimented with the dock when I came home at midnight, and I had trouble placing it in and taking out the joycons without removing the system from the dock. This is directly because I was being extra careful of not knocking things over (i was half asleep).

I did that about three times, and when I took the system out, I saw what looked like scratches on the bezel in the exact location as the OP.

Needless to say I was mortified. I grabbed a microfiber cloth and was able to buff them off. If anything, they were just smudges from the plastic in the dock.

I could see how it could happen with a cheap plastic screen protector within in a week, but, IMO, you would have to be aggressively taking the console in and out of the dock multiple times.
 
This is why I have a regular screen protector or a tempered glass screen protector waiting on my electronics or coming in at the same time as my electronics that have screens. Both my Vita and Wii U had them day one.
 
900p sure is more taxing, namely 1.875 times more pixels. Fortunately, GPU docked clock is twice higher than undocked.

He probably means that memory bandwidth only increases by 20% from undocked to docked:
Laying out the maths here, docking increases pixel count from 720p to 900p, a 56 per cent in resolution. However, memory bandwidth only rises by 20 per cent, from 1331MHz to 1600MHz. Bandwidth is shared between CPU and GPU, so the higher resolution in the home console mode may be sapping memory bandwidth away from the main processor cores, making us more prone to slowdown when the CPU is under load. Bandwidth concerns may also explain why resolution doesn't scale closer in line with the difference in clock-speeds (307.2MHz or 384MHz undocked, 768MHz docked).
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/d...e-legend-of-zelda-breath-of-the-wild-face-off
 
Has anyone affixed the screen protextor that comes with the official Switch case? Impressions?
I hate it. The first time in my life that i was not able to apply on without bubbles. I tried every trick in the book and gave up.
I ordered a tempered glass one now from amFilm

But I also have to add two friends of mine applied it without any problem and no bubbles.

The quality, once applied without bubbles is good for a protector that came as a set with the case.
 
Top Bottom