Rez said:
Played through the first world.
I'm not feeling it. So much automation and the platforming feels really slippery.
Not awful, so in that regard it might end up being the best Sonic game in years, just not super-fantastic or anything.
The first world is fairly automatic, and the two worlds that unlock after that don't really impress much until after you've beaten the game.
I hated the game when I first played it, specifically with the platforming (it also doesn't help that I was deliberately trying to get the red rings at every turn on my first playthrough). Ultimately, I picked it up and put it down several times over the course of a month, before I finally settled in and started to really like it.
The controls are the worst part of the game, they feel off when you first pick them up, and it's only after a lot of time with the game that you end up settling in with it.
The game just assumes that you were some zen monk at Sonic Unleashed; it tends to do a rather poor job of explaining the nuance of the various of mechanics in the game. You more or less end up figuring things out through trial and error and plenty of cheap deaths. Since most of the cool exploration elements are locked away with various Wisp powers, most of your first playthroughs are going to do the levels a huge disservice and feel much simpler and uninteresting than they actually end up being.
It feels like the bottomless pits barely exist once you've figured the game out, but you're going to see and feel every single 1 hit death before that point.
But again, give it time. It just sucks that the game you end up peeling out is so much better than the game you're initially presented with.
Once you get that down, and start going back to levels after unlocking various Wisps, and exploring for red rings, you're going to be surprised at just how deep and complex the levels actually are. I wonder if it's really that much worse than the learning curve of the classic 2D Sonic games, seeing as people frequently complained about the controls accessibility back in the day, but in the end this game really does end up evoking the same sensibilities of classic Sonic (namely exploration and fun) but does so with the much refined Sonic Unleashed style gameplay.
It's so much better than any 3D Sonic game yet; it actually legitimizes the Sonic Unleashed approach to Sonic gameplay, and that's no small feat.
Just don't stress trying to see everything in your first run through, focus on having fun, otherwise the game is needlessly frustrating.