So Makai could be:
(1) A Hutt / Undercover Imperial
(2) A Neutral
(3) A Rebel who just wants to survive (lying about the gun)
(4) A Rebel who received a gun
Scenario (1) is certainly the best outcome.
Scenario (2) is not really a loss to Town.
Scenario (3) means we lose a Rebel, but since we are lynching someone, he seems to be a good candidate since there was a
'suspicious activity' performed by or to Makai and with this, we could verify Setre's claim of his ability.
If it's scenario (4) then he would have the power to kill people, and I don't think that's a good idea.
My reasons:
1. His voting selection, day1: No detain, day2: Blargonaut, day3: Setre before finally choosing Palmer_v1
For me, all of these choices seem to be against the Town's interest.
And if he has a gun, would he allow us to decide who to kill? Because his own lynching decision are suspect so far.
2. Even if he defers the killing based on Town's decision, getting rid of two people a day is very risky since we have been losing quite a lot of people. At this time, we should not be so trigger happy since
AbsolutBro explains that in the worst case scenario, we might lose the game by tomorrow's night.
3. The fact that he has a gun means that he will probably become the thief's target tonight.
Under no circumstances should we allow the gun to fall into the thief's possession, since we don't know if they would be able to use it or not. Too risky to consider though.
Based on these reasonings, I believe it's best for Town to lynch Makai.
VOTE: Makai