Conceptually, I like the idea of the Jedi/Sith being legends. I subscribe to
Mike Ryan's thesis that
the Jedi are actually really fuckin' boring. They wear boring one color old people robes, have stilted condescending vocabulary, super powers that can seemingly do anything which is bad for drama, and live by a code that basically removes anything fun or remotely interesting emotions from their lives. Their downtime seems to be solely concerned with sitting around meditating and lookin
oh so serious. One of the many faults of the prequels was shifting us away from reletable human underdogs in their crappy lived-in worlds to broody superheroes living in their shiny sterile towers.
But they
sound really cool, right? Legends of space knights with laser swords and magic powers bringing order to the galaxy. And that's where they work best. At the edges of the narrative. As something fantastic in a ugly, dirty world of space pirates, bounty hunters, and young scrappy folks fighting space nazis.