I'm not too keen on the look of the Valve controller myself.
Specifically, it's the absence of physical thumbsticks or d-pad that bums me out. I know some of you guys are of the opinion that touch control's the future, but for the most part I've always seen it as a poor man's substitute for real physical input devices (see: laptop trackpads). The main type of physical feedback I want from a controller is a sensation of resistance from the sticks as I move them with my thumbs or hold them a certain distance from center. The haptic feedback they're describing sounds nice, but it's not the same thing.
I'll probably end up checking it out, and I can think of some games that I might want to use it for. I'm just kind of disappointed that it's not going to be the "one gamepad to rule them all" that would make me shelf my old Dual Shock for good, which is kind of what I was hoping for when this was announced.
ineveraskedforthis.gif