Teknopathetic said:
Disciples II Gold and Jagged Alliance 2 are, by far, the best 2 games in the compilation. Not to take away from some of those other games, but those 2 are fantastic. Superb.
I'll agree with that, but I'd also like to say that Birth of America (get the most updated patch for that off AGEOD's forums) and Space Empires IV are really not very far behind. Birth of America especially is a friendly heap o' kickass wargaming.
It's sort of a shame that people won't try any of the Sonalysts games, especially Dangerous Waters, which is about as good as it gets in terms of modern naval stuff if you don't want to go into one of the Harpoon re-releases.
Making History is not a bad game if you don't have Hearts of Iron 2. In which case, there is really no point to playing it over HoI2, WW2 game of the forever.
Alien Shooter: Vengeance, Darkstar One, Culpa Innata, and Ghost Master are decent quality games as well.