I hesitated on the ordering here for a while. At one point I had XCOM 2 at #1 but I figured if I was excluding Dark Souls III for just being more of the same, then XCOM 2 had to go as well. Honestly, I'm not even sure if VA-11 Hall-A is actually my GOTY. Maybe I'm picking it because I only played it last week and it's still fresh in my mind. But unlike the other titles in my top 5, I just can't move on from it. When it was over, I really, really wished it wasn't. I wanted to keep hanging out with these characters and serve them more drinks and I'm still listening to the soundtrack obsessively (it's actually playing as I'm typing this).
And I'm not really much of a VN guy usually. I mean, I love stuff like Ace Attorney, Zero Escape and Danganronpa but pure VNs don't appeal to me as much. I usually need at least some small amount of gameplay to keep things engaging. So, I was really surprised by how much I ended up loving VA-11 Hall-A. Because of it, my most anticipated game right now is the enhanced rerelease of Read Only Memories coming out in a few days. I hadn't even really heard about ROM and only bought it randomly during the holidays sale because it looked kinda cool and somehow found its way onto my wishlist (probably while doing the discovery queue from a previous sale). But when I found out it's actually set in the same world as VA-11 Hall-A, I got super hyped for it.